Tuesday, November 17, 2026

The Propaganda/Narrative Industry's Game

It has been said that part of the Republican losses this month has to do with the Republican (or 'conservative') inability to construct a narrative which persuades.

So here's a persuasive narrative story told by Leftists.  There are no lies, but there are omissions.  The most important detail is buried midway through because most readers or listeners will never get that far.  The Lawbreaker's Sympathy Symphony is written and played in the first few grafs:

 For nearly two months, Immigration and Customs Enforcement held Dr. Ann Lawani, a California nurse and professor who holds a Ph.D. in nursing and taught at the University of San Francisco, more than 2,000 miles from her home, in a Louisiana immigration detention center.

ICE arrested the 39-year-old during a targeted enforcement operation in Lodi, California, on Sept. 16. For days afterward, her family couldn't find her. The agency eventually transferred Lawani to a facility in Louisiana, where she contacted her brother. Before then, her family and colleagues said they couldn't locate her because she wasn't listed in the government's online detainee locator....

Get it?  Start with the (mean, awful, violent, and cold-hearted) ICE.  Use "held"--implying a level of force.  Bring in the honorific "Dr." and "Ph.D", and the ultimate 'harmless' job:  teaching at a Jesuit college.  Add a 2,000 mile (horrible!!) distance.  Tell us about the fearful, stressed family and the horrible injustice of taking down the locator tool--which is not a "right" in the first place.

See?

Now bury the really significant fact in the third graf:

...  on Sept. 15, ICE quietly removed the names of detainees with final removal orders from its public locator....

Oh.  She had been told to get the Hell out of the US?  Huh!  

But the Lawbreaker-Apologists are not finished with this.

... "We found out that she had been shackled. That she had been held in a bus in the hot September heat of California, Central Valley, that she has been moved to Texas and then to Louisiana during this time," Fry-Bowers said....

Shackled (like any fugitive). In a bus!  On a hot day!  OH, THE HUMANITY!!!!  Is your estrogen boiling yet??

(Ever try Army's basic combat training in a desert, sweet-cheeks?  We did.  And we survived!)

Then--by all means!--invent tortures that didn't happen and pretend that they will.

Fry-Bowers said she feared Lawani would be deported to a third country.

..."That she would be sent somewhere where she wasn't safe, where she had no resources, maybe where she didn't speak the language," she said....

(Surprised the friend didn't conjure up "helicoptering") 

Now, then.  How about another important fact in the story?  

ELEVENTH GRAF:

 ...The Department of Homeland Security said Lawani overstayed an expired visa in 2007 and previously received a final removal order....

She's been an illegal for damn near 20 years. 

Think the Conservatives will learn something here about "narrative" and how it works?

Nah. 

No comments: