Only Kafka could make this up...but then, we have DarthDoyle (D-Babykillers).
In his Tuesday budget message, Gov. Jim Doyle is expected to propose a tax on hospitals.
Although details of Doyle's proposal aren't known, Illinois levies its 2.5% hospital tax on gross revenue. If Wisconsin did likewise, a 2% tax could raise about $225 million from hospitals, since the Wisconsin Hospital Association reported total revenue of $11.2 billion in 2004.
Stone inanity? The Feds (of course) are partially responsible.
A new tax on Wisconsin hospital revenue would bring in more federal aid for this reason: The federal government pays 57 cents out of every $1 that Wisconsin spends on Medicaid; state government pays 43 cents. So, if revenue from a hospital tax is used to boost state Medicaid spending, the federal government would pay the state much more than it does now.
For more complex (and asinine) ideas, there IS the Wisconsin school-aid formula.
"If hospitals are taxed in this state, there's no question those taxes are going to be passed on to patients in our hospitals," Borgerding [Wisconsin Hospital Ass'n] said.
Duhhhhh!
Experience should be instructive to Darth. Let's hope he reads this:
Jennifer Jackson, chief executive officer of the Connecticut Hospital Association, said that state eliminated its hospital tax in 2003 - after nearly a decade - after a lawsuit from the hospital group.
Such programs look appealing the first year because of the revenue potential, she said, but it's hard to keep the original program and reimbursement rates in later years, as federal rules change and the money is diverted to other programs.
Darth could put the money into schools, I suppose.
Friday, February 09, 2007
Thursday, February 08, 2007
Legal Prostitution?
The Libertarian instincts of Sykes were unleashed this morning while he commented on using police time and resources to track down and arrest local whores; he asked the question 'whether prostitution should be legal?'
He didn't mention "safe and rare," but hey...
That's a question that I satirized when I was around 21 years of age, in discussing what could be done with a fine old mansion at the east end of Wisconsin Avenue. Back then, not even the Democrat I worked for was amused.
Regardless, by co-incidence (perhaps NOT,) another blogger published a brief on our old pal, Friedrich Nietzsche, whose philosophy just happens to coincide with Libertarian thinking on the subject. (Or perhaps it's more accurate to state that Libertarian thinking follows that of Nietzsche.)
Quoting Peter Kreeft, the blogger posts:
Friedrich Nietzsche called himself “the Anti-Christ,” and wrote a book by that title. He argued for atheism as follows: “I will now disprove the existence of all gods. If there were gods, how could I bear not to be a god? Consequently, there are no gods.”
He scorned reason as well as faith, often deliberately contradicted himself, said that “a sneer is infinitely more noble that a syllogism” and appealed to passion, rhetoric and even deliberate hatred rather than reason.
He saw love as “the greatest danger” and morality as mankind’s worst weakness. He died insane, in an asylum, of syphilis-signing his last letters “the Crucified One.” He was adored by the Nazis as their semi-official philosopher.
But in Nietzsche’s last work, “The Will to Power,” the lack of an end or goal appears as demonic, and mirrors the demonic character of the modern mind. Without a God, a heaven, truth, or an absolute Goodness to aim at, the meaning of life becomes simply “the will to power.” Power becomes its own end, not a means. Life is like a bubble, empty within and without; but its meaning is self-affirmation, egotism, blowing up your bubble, expanding the meaningless self into the meaningless void. “Just will,” is Nietzsche’s advice. It does not matter what you will or why.
We are now in a position to see why Nietzsche is such a crucially important thinker, not despite but because of his insanity. No one in history, except possibly the Marquis de Sade, has ever so clearly, candidly and consistently formulated the complete alternative to Christianity.
Pre-Christian (i.e., pagan) societies and philosophies were like virgins. Post-Christian (i.e., modern) societies and philosophies are like divorcees. Nietzsche is no pagan pre-Christian, but the essential, modern post-Christian and anti-Christian.
Note that Nietzsche's "will to power" sees love as "the greatest danger." When you've internalized that, you begin to understand the flaw in his thinking--but to cut to the chase, N. postulates that one can "make his own rules" through the Will to Power.
This is also referred to as 'the transvaluation of all values' by other critics of N., and acceptance of N.'s position implies not only the legitimization of prostitution, but an anarchical situation which neither Conservatives nor good Republicans should espouse.
He didn't mention "safe and rare," but hey...
That's a question that I satirized when I was around 21 years of age, in discussing what could be done with a fine old mansion at the east end of Wisconsin Avenue. Back then, not even the Democrat I worked for was amused.
Regardless, by co-incidence (perhaps NOT,) another blogger published a brief on our old pal, Friedrich Nietzsche, whose philosophy just happens to coincide with Libertarian thinking on the subject. (Or perhaps it's more accurate to state that Libertarian thinking follows that of Nietzsche.)
Quoting Peter Kreeft, the blogger posts:
Friedrich Nietzsche called himself “the Anti-Christ,” and wrote a book by that title. He argued for atheism as follows: “I will now disprove the existence of all gods. If there were gods, how could I bear not to be a god? Consequently, there are no gods.”
He scorned reason as well as faith, often deliberately contradicted himself, said that “a sneer is infinitely more noble that a syllogism” and appealed to passion, rhetoric and even deliberate hatred rather than reason.
He saw love as “the greatest danger” and morality as mankind’s worst weakness. He died insane, in an asylum, of syphilis-signing his last letters “the Crucified One.” He was adored by the Nazis as their semi-official philosopher.
But in Nietzsche’s last work, “The Will to Power,” the lack of an end or goal appears as demonic, and mirrors the demonic character of the modern mind. Without a God, a heaven, truth, or an absolute Goodness to aim at, the meaning of life becomes simply “the will to power.” Power becomes its own end, not a means. Life is like a bubble, empty within and without; but its meaning is self-affirmation, egotism, blowing up your bubble, expanding the meaningless self into the meaningless void. “Just will,” is Nietzsche’s advice. It does not matter what you will or why.
We are now in a position to see why Nietzsche is such a crucially important thinker, not despite but because of his insanity. No one in history, except possibly the Marquis de Sade, has ever so clearly, candidly and consistently formulated the complete alternative to Christianity.
Pre-Christian (i.e., pagan) societies and philosophies were like virgins. Post-Christian (i.e., modern) societies and philosophies are like divorcees. Nietzsche is no pagan pre-Christian, but the essential, modern post-Christian and anti-Christian.
Note that Nietzsche's "will to power" sees love as "the greatest danger." When you've internalized that, you begin to understand the flaw in his thinking--but to cut to the chase, N. postulates that one can "make his own rules" through the Will to Power.
This is also referred to as 'the transvaluation of all values' by other critics of N., and acceptance of N.'s position implies not only the legitimization of prostitution, but an anarchical situation which neither Conservatives nor good Republicans should espouse.
Iran Helping Shoot Down Choppers?
Roggio reports:
The suspicion is the Islamic Republic of Iran is behind supplying al-Qaeda with the needed weapons, training and logistical support to supply and field a successful anti-aircraft force, much as the United States provided the mujahideen with Stingers in Afghanistan in the 1980s.
They're using Russian-made SA-7's, which are not quite as sophisticated as the US Stinger.
What is really interesting is this:
During the Baghdad and Irbil raids, the U.S. detained seven members of Iran's Qods Force (Iranian special forces) and captured documentation which proved Iran was supporting both the Sunni and Shia insurgent and death squads, as well as Al_Qaeda and Ansar al-Sunnah.
It's not surprising that Iran is involved; but their support of ALL the combative splinters will eventually bite them where it counts.
The suspicion is the Islamic Republic of Iran is behind supplying al-Qaeda with the needed weapons, training and logistical support to supply and field a successful anti-aircraft force, much as the United States provided the mujahideen with Stingers in Afghanistan in the 1980s.
They're using Russian-made SA-7's, which are not quite as sophisticated as the US Stinger.
What is really interesting is this:
During the Baghdad and Irbil raids, the U.S. detained seven members of Iran's Qods Force (Iranian special forces) and captured documentation which proved Iran was supporting both the Sunni and Shia insurgent and death squads, as well as Al_Qaeda and Ansar al-Sunnah.
It's not surprising that Iran is involved; but their support of ALL the combative splinters will eventually bite them where it counts.
Tim Russert: Not As Bad As Dan Rather
Clearly, the Government's side of the Libby case is going poorly.
But that's not nearly as bad as things are for Tim Russert, former (D) political operative and currently hosting some NBC program.
Here's a summary of the cross-examination of Russert from Just One Minute.
Wells [Libby's attorney] ... established that (a) the FBI report of [Russert's] conversations (they say he had two, he only recalls one) made far closer in time to the event indicate he conceded that Ms. Wilson's name may have come up in their conversation though he earlier discounted that as "impossible" (b) In a heated matter involving the Buffalo News, [Russert's] own memory was faulty. He'd made two angry calls to a critical reporter, denied that he had, and then, after checking his phone records, apologized, asserting he had no memory whatsoever of the calls, and (c) while making an impassioned plea for the right of reporters to protect the confidentiality of sources, [Rusert had] already twice discussed the Libby exchanges with the FBI and failed to disclose that to the Court or the public.
"Not as bad as Dan Rather" is not how Timmy wants to be remembered. But he's getting there.
But that's not nearly as bad as things are for Tim Russert, former (D) political operative and currently hosting some NBC program.
Here's a summary of the cross-examination of Russert from Just One Minute.
Wells [Libby's attorney] ... established that (a) the FBI report of [Russert's] conversations (they say he had two, he only recalls one) made far closer in time to the event indicate he conceded that Ms. Wilson's name may have come up in their conversation though he earlier discounted that as "impossible" (b) In a heated matter involving the Buffalo News, [Russert's] own memory was faulty. He'd made two angry calls to a critical reporter, denied that he had, and then, after checking his phone records, apologized, asserting he had no memory whatsoever of the calls, and (c) while making an impassioned plea for the right of reporters to protect the confidentiality of sources, [Rusert had] already twice discussed the Libby exchanges with the FBI and failed to disclose that to the Court or the public.
"Not as bad as Dan Rather" is not how Timmy wants to be remembered. But he's getting there.
How Much More Can Mayfair Take?
About a year ago, we issued the orders: none of our children living at home would be allowed at Mayfair shopping center after 7:00 PM. Further, since their parents weren't going there after 7:00 PM, either, no use asking for a "parent-accompanied" exception.
That was before it became dangerous to ride the bus or trying to PARK in the place.
The owners of the land underneath Mayfair don't have to worry too much; a redevelopment into office space will sustain the value of the land quite well, thank you.
But the retailers currently paying very heavy rent--that's another thing.
That was before it became dangerous to ride the bus or trying to PARK in the place.
The owners of the land underneath Mayfair don't have to worry too much; a redevelopment into office space will sustain the value of the land quite well, thank you.
But the retailers currently paying very heavy rent--that's another thing.
McIlheran vs. Folkbum: No Contest
Whenever Folkbum decides to take on McIlheran (P-Mac), it's always fun to read Folkie's attempt to refute P-Mac.
"Where's the beef?" is always appropriate--sometimes, "Where's the bread?" fits, too.
McIlheran:
Sen. John Edwards (D-N.C.) has hired a campaign blogmaster, just the thing for a candidate with young and hip hair. The background check missed something, though:
She’s got a real problem with Catholics.
Specifically, when Amanda Marcotte was writing on her own blog, Pandagon, about the church’s view of birth control, she started with a little joke that, in crude terms, involved the Virgin Mary, the Plan B contraceptive, a nasty description of the “holy spirit” and a reference to Catholic doctrine as an “ancient mythology” meant to justify misognyny. Follow the link if you want to read it; it won’t be reprinted on the Journal Sentinel’s Web site.
Folkie:
It's the way he's dumbly parroting the party line without considering the double standards, without recognizing the cognitive dissonance that must be overcome to complain about Amanda.
For example, among those leading the charge is the Catholic League's Bill Donohue; you might remember him as the one who famously said
"Who really cares what Hollywood thinks? All these hacks come out there. Hollywood is controlled by secular Jews who hate Christianity in general and Catholicism in particular. It's not a secret, okay?
And that, my friends, is the tip of the porverbial iceberg--just google Donohue, and you can learn all about his hateful speech--less profane, but no less offensive--against Jews and homosexuals (or see, yes, Pandagon for more). Yet Donohue gets to go on TV to represent Catholics everywhere while Amanda may get fired from her gig as a blogger. Go figure.
It's reasonably well-known that Donohue is a pit-bull Catholic, as aggressive in defending Catholicism and Catholics as is the ADL in defending Judaism and Jews. (By the way, Donohue's remarks about Hollywood are accurate.)
Then Folkie launches into a rant about a second-rate (R) operative who works for a sure-loser (R) Presidential candidate (McPain); the operative apparently dissed Henry Waxman. This IS relevant--both Edwards and McPain are DOA in the primaries.
McIlheran's point was that John Edwards (D--The Richest America), in hiring a flame-throwing anti-Catholic bigot, made an error in judgment which may tell us something about the Breck Girl's overall Presidential timber.
Folkie's point was....what? That Edwards was right?
Pointing out that someone has a history of blind-rage-hatred of the Catholic Church is not a "party" line, Folkie. The Republicans actually don't do all that well with Catholics.
But Edwards' choice of 'net spokesman may change that.
By the way, Folkie: you never mentioned whether you disagree with Ms. Marcotte.
UPDATED: It now appears that the BreckGirl will keep the bloggers on his staff. Glad that's cleared up, hey!
"Where's the beef?" is always appropriate--sometimes, "Where's the bread?" fits, too.
McIlheran:
Sen. John Edwards (D-N.C.) has hired a campaign blogmaster, just the thing for a candidate with young and hip hair. The background check missed something, though:
She’s got a real problem with Catholics.
Specifically, when Amanda Marcotte was writing on her own blog, Pandagon, about the church’s view of birth control, she started with a little joke that, in crude terms, involved the Virgin Mary, the Plan B contraceptive, a nasty description of the “holy spirit” and a reference to Catholic doctrine as an “ancient mythology” meant to justify misognyny. Follow the link if you want to read it; it won’t be reprinted on the Journal Sentinel’s Web site.
Folkie:
It's the way he's dumbly parroting the party line without considering the double standards, without recognizing the cognitive dissonance that must be overcome to complain about Amanda.
For example, among those leading the charge is the Catholic League's Bill Donohue; you might remember him as the one who famously said
"Who really cares what Hollywood thinks? All these hacks come out there. Hollywood is controlled by secular Jews who hate Christianity in general and Catholicism in particular. It's not a secret, okay?
And that, my friends, is the tip of the porverbial iceberg--just google Donohue, and you can learn all about his hateful speech--less profane, but no less offensive--against Jews and homosexuals (or see, yes, Pandagon for more). Yet Donohue gets to go on TV to represent Catholics everywhere while Amanda may get fired from her gig as a blogger. Go figure.
It's reasonably well-known that Donohue is a pit-bull Catholic, as aggressive in defending Catholicism and Catholics as is the ADL in defending Judaism and Jews. (By the way, Donohue's remarks about Hollywood are accurate.)
Then Folkie launches into a rant about a second-rate (R) operative who works for a sure-loser (R) Presidential candidate (McPain); the operative apparently dissed Henry Waxman. This IS relevant--both Edwards and McPain are DOA in the primaries.
McIlheran's point was that John Edwards (D--The Richest America), in hiring a flame-throwing anti-Catholic bigot, made an error in judgment which may tell us something about the Breck Girl's overall Presidential timber.
Folkie's point was....what? That Edwards was right?
Pointing out that someone has a history of blind-rage-hatred of the Catholic Church is not a "party" line, Folkie. The Republicans actually don't do all that well with Catholics.
But Edwards' choice of 'net spokesman may change that.
By the way, Folkie: you never mentioned whether you disagree with Ms. Marcotte.
UPDATED: It now appears that the BreckGirl will keep the bloggers on his staff. Glad that's cleared up, hey!
Wednesday, February 07, 2007
Rudy? No.
You've noticed the sudden increase in blog accolades of Rudy Giuliani. By no coincidence, the laudatory bits are all over the place in the rightist 'sphere.
The fact that Rudy announced yesterday is not a coincidence.
Given the amount of antipathy to McPain (whose personal campaign-finance "reform" is to opt out of the system and maximize his donation-intake) and the relatively low-visibility of others (Brownback, e.g.,) the Right-Side Kingmakers have decided Rudy's the man.
Somewhere along the line, I thought there were supposed to be some caucuses and primaries. Maybe I missed them.
GWB was also a relatively conservative guy who suddenly materialized as "the man." He's pretty good on judicial picks, has done a yeoman's (and thankless) job with foreign affairs and a somewhat amorphous war, and stuck to his principles on ESCR.
But there are a couple of areas in which it's clear that he's not a Conservative. He's a drunken sailor with a budget, and he doesn't have a firm grip on the concept of borders and citizenship.
But what is likely to hurt GWB's reputation most are his clearly horrific picks for domestic staff: FEMA comes to mind, and now his US Attorneys in Texas are clearly problems.
Rudy's promised that his Judiciary picks will be just great.
No noises on budgets, and he thinks that the 2nd Amendment right to self-defense only applies to country folks.
God only knows about his US Attorney picks, tax policy, or his thoughts on such things as borders and citizenship.
Not King yet. Maybe not even a prince.
The fact that Rudy announced yesterday is not a coincidence.
Given the amount of antipathy to McPain (whose personal campaign-finance "reform" is to opt out of the system and maximize his donation-intake) and the relatively low-visibility of others (Brownback, e.g.,) the Right-Side Kingmakers have decided Rudy's the man.
Somewhere along the line, I thought there were supposed to be some caucuses and primaries. Maybe I missed them.
GWB was also a relatively conservative guy who suddenly materialized as "the man." He's pretty good on judicial picks, has done a yeoman's (and thankless) job with foreign affairs and a somewhat amorphous war, and stuck to his principles on ESCR.
But there are a couple of areas in which it's clear that he's not a Conservative. He's a drunken sailor with a budget, and he doesn't have a firm grip on the concept of borders and citizenship.
But what is likely to hurt GWB's reputation most are his clearly horrific picks for domestic staff: FEMA comes to mind, and now his US Attorneys in Texas are clearly problems.
Rudy's promised that his Judiciary picks will be just great.
No noises on budgets, and he thinks that the 2nd Amendment right to self-defense only applies to country folks.
God only knows about his US Attorney picks, tax policy, or his thoughts on such things as borders and citizenship.
Not King yet. Maybe not even a prince.
Defense Costs in Perspective
While the Milwaukee JS seems to be embarking on the "Pentagon Costs a Lot" boat, here's a reality check statistic:
Mr. Bush's request would only bring defense outlays to 4.2% of GDP, or about 20% of total federal spending. That compares to 4.7% of GDP even under Jimmy Carter
(Source: WSJ, HT Betsy)
Mr. Bush's request would only bring defense outlays to 4.2% of GDP, or about 20% of total federal spending. That compares to 4.7% of GDP even under Jimmy Carter
(Source: WSJ, HT Betsy)
Tuesday, February 06, 2007
Bp. Gumbleton Gets Vatican Smackdown? About Time!
This fellow, Bp Gumbleton, is long overdue for a good smackdown. Now maybe he got it.
Bishop Thomas Gumbleton of Detroit must seek permission from local bishops anywhere he wishes to speak, by order of the papal nuncio, the Vatican's ambassador to the United States, according to local leaders of Call to Action. The group has taken a variety of positions at odds with church policy.
Normally, Catholic clergy need permission only to conduct religious services. The Vatican has penalized dissident theologians in the past, but Robert Blair Kaiser, a Phoenix author who has covered the Vatican since 1962, said he had never heard of a nuncio restricting a bishop.
A source close to Gumbleton in Detroit confirmed the nuncio's action. A man who declined to identify himself at the nuncio's office in Washington, D.C., said the office would not talk about any such order.
Here's the "Gumby/Call to Action Spin" on the silencing:
Call to Action leaders said Archbishop Pietro Sambi, the papal nuncio, laid down the requirement to Gumbleton several months ago, reportedly as a result of testimony Gumbleton gave a year ago to the Ohio Legislature in favor of expanded time frames for abuse victims to file lawsuits.
Frankly, Bp G's outspoken heterodoxy is far more compelling than some Ohio lobbying. But CTA's major theme is that the Church is all about 'money and power,' so they reflexively assign the Vatican's action to a money-related item.
HT: Pro Ecclesia
Bishop Thomas Gumbleton of Detroit must seek permission from local bishops anywhere he wishes to speak, by order of the papal nuncio, the Vatican's ambassador to the United States, according to local leaders of Call to Action. The group has taken a variety of positions at odds with church policy.
Normally, Catholic clergy need permission only to conduct religious services. The Vatican has penalized dissident theologians in the past, but Robert Blair Kaiser, a Phoenix author who has covered the Vatican since 1962, said he had never heard of a nuncio restricting a bishop.
A source close to Gumbleton in Detroit confirmed the nuncio's action. A man who declined to identify himself at the nuncio's office in Washington, D.C., said the office would not talk about any such order.
Here's the "Gumby/Call to Action Spin" on the silencing:
Call to Action leaders said Archbishop Pietro Sambi, the papal nuncio, laid down the requirement to Gumbleton several months ago, reportedly as a result of testimony Gumbleton gave a year ago to the Ohio Legislature in favor of expanded time frames for abuse victims to file lawsuits.
Frankly, Bp G's outspoken heterodoxy is far more compelling than some Ohio lobbying. But CTA's major theme is that the Church is all about 'money and power,' so they reflexively assign the Vatican's action to a money-related item.
HT: Pro Ecclesia
Want to Get Old Fast?
Read this:
The group had been celebrating [actress Farah] Fawcett's 60th birthday
(From a story about Ryan O'Neal's self-defense vs. his son, Griffin.)
HT: John Lott
The group had been celebrating [actress Farah] Fawcett's 60th birthday
(From a story about Ryan O'Neal's self-defense vs. his son, Griffin.)
HT: John Lott
B-16's Analysis of Islam and the West
While most of the shallow-thinking MSM (and Muslim) reaction to the Pope's Regensburg speech was focused on a passage relating to Muslim conquests, the REST of the Pope's address was largely ignored.
There are two reasons for that. First, the press thrives on controversy--the bigger, the better. When the Successor of Peter quotes remarks which are uncomfortable to the next-largest world religion, it sells newspapers.
But the second reason may be far more important: B-16 also fired a serious shot at Western society:
While the pope is asking Islam for dialogue based on culture, human rights, the refusal of violence, he is asking the West, at the same time, to go back to a vision of human nature and rationality in which the religious dimension is not excluded.
"God-talk" does not win the hearts and minds of the MSM, folks. Certainly not in Old Europe, and not in East-Coast press/broadcast headquarters buildings.
To understand Benedict XVI’s thinking on Islamic religion, we must go over its evolution.
...First of all, he shows that there is no orthodoxy in Islam, because there is no one authority, no common doctrinal magisterium. This makes dialogue difficult: when we engage in dialogue, it is not “with Islam”, but with groups.
But the key point that he tackles is that of shari’a. He points out that:
“the Koran is a total religious law, which regulates the whole of political and social life and insists that the whole order of life be Islamic. Shari’a shapes society from beginning to end. In this sense, it can exploit such freedoms as our constitutions give, but it cannot be its final goal to say: Yes, now we too are a body with rights, now we are present [in society] just like the Catholics and the Protestants. In such a situation, [Islam] would not achieve a status consistent with its inner nature; it would be in alienation from itself”.
...Ratzinger saw clearly an essential difficulty of socio-political relations with the Muslim world, which comes from the totalizing conception of Islamic religion, which is profoundly different from Christianity. For this reason, he insists in saying that we cannot try to project onto Islam the Christian vision of the relationship between politics and religion.
In brief:
The essential idea is that dialogue with Islam and with other religions cannot be essentially a theological or religious dialogue, except in the broad terms of moral values; it must instead be a dialogue of cultures and civilizations.
This goes to the nature of the religious belief-system: Shari'a is 'complete in itself' as law, (it "descended upon" Mohammed, per se excluding interpretation) whereas in the Judaeo-Christian tradition, Scripture "was inspired," allowing for interpretation.
Therefore,
...it is a question of tackling the question of coexistence in the concrete terms of politics, economy, history, culture, customs.
For which the Natural Law is a common ground.
As to the West, now feverishly working to dis-join reason from faith, the Pope has another message.
“It has been said that we must not speak of God in the European constitution, because we must not offend Muslims and the faithful of other religions. The opposite is true: what offends Muslims and the faithful of other religions is not talking about God or our Christian roots, but rather the disdain for God and the sacred, that separates us from other cultures and does not create the opportunity for encounter, but expresses the arrogance of diminished, reduced reason, which provokes fundamentalist reactions.”
The author of the piece comments:
Benedict XVI admires in Islam the certainty based on faith, which contrasts with the West where everything is relativized; and he admires in Islam the sense of the sacred, which instead seems to have disappeared in the West. He has understood that a Muslim is not offended by the crucifix, by religious symbols: this is actually a laicist polemic that strives to eliminate the religious from society. Muslims are not offended by religious symbols, but by secularized culture, by the fact that God and the values that they associate with God are absent from this civilization.
This is also my experience, when I chat every once in a while with Muslims who live in Italy. They tell me: this country offers everything, we can live as we like, but unfortunately there are no “principles” (this is the word they use). This is felt very much by the pope, who says: let’s go back to human nature, based on rationality, on conscience, which gives an idea of human rights; on the other hand, let’s not reduce rationality to something which is impoverished, but let’s integrate the religious in rationality; the religious is part of rationality.
...[Benedict XVI's] proposal is that, if we want to find a common basis, we must get out of religious dialogue to give humanistic foundations to this dialogue, because only these are universal and shared by all human beings. Humanism is a universal factor; faiths can be factors of clash and division.
The pope’s position never falls into the justification of terrorism and violence. ...But, on the other hand, he has never fallen into the behaviour found in certain Christian circles in the West marked by “do-goodism” and by guilt complexes.
The Pope's proposal to the world is simple: recognize the essential junction of faith and reason, which promotes and protects the universal human values found in the natural law and conscience.
Attempting to "reason without faith" is as impossible as attempting "faith without reason."
HT: Dhimmi Watch
There are two reasons for that. First, the press thrives on controversy--the bigger, the better. When the Successor of Peter quotes remarks which are uncomfortable to the next-largest world religion, it sells newspapers.
But the second reason may be far more important: B-16 also fired a serious shot at Western society:
While the pope is asking Islam for dialogue based on culture, human rights, the refusal of violence, he is asking the West, at the same time, to go back to a vision of human nature and rationality in which the religious dimension is not excluded.
"God-talk" does not win the hearts and minds of the MSM, folks. Certainly not in Old Europe, and not in East-Coast press/broadcast headquarters buildings.
To understand Benedict XVI’s thinking on Islamic religion, we must go over its evolution.
...First of all, he shows that there is no orthodoxy in Islam, because there is no one authority, no common doctrinal magisterium. This makes dialogue difficult: when we engage in dialogue, it is not “with Islam”, but with groups.
But the key point that he tackles is that of shari’a. He points out that:
“the Koran is a total religious law, which regulates the whole of political and social life and insists that the whole order of life be Islamic. Shari’a shapes society from beginning to end. In this sense, it can exploit such freedoms as our constitutions give, but it cannot be its final goal to say: Yes, now we too are a body with rights, now we are present [in society] just like the Catholics and the Protestants. In such a situation, [Islam] would not achieve a status consistent with its inner nature; it would be in alienation from itself”.
...Ratzinger saw clearly an essential difficulty of socio-political relations with the Muslim world, which comes from the totalizing conception of Islamic religion, which is profoundly different from Christianity. For this reason, he insists in saying that we cannot try to project onto Islam the Christian vision of the relationship between politics and religion.
In brief:
The essential idea is that dialogue with Islam and with other religions cannot be essentially a theological or religious dialogue, except in the broad terms of moral values; it must instead be a dialogue of cultures and civilizations.
This goes to the nature of the religious belief-system: Shari'a is 'complete in itself' as law, (it "descended upon" Mohammed, per se excluding interpretation) whereas in the Judaeo-Christian tradition, Scripture "was inspired," allowing for interpretation.
Therefore,
...it is a question of tackling the question of coexistence in the concrete terms of politics, economy, history, culture, customs.
For which the Natural Law is a common ground.
As to the West, now feverishly working to dis-join reason from faith, the Pope has another message.
“It has been said that we must not speak of God in the European constitution, because we must not offend Muslims and the faithful of other religions. The opposite is true: what offends Muslims and the faithful of other religions is not talking about God or our Christian roots, but rather the disdain for God and the sacred, that separates us from other cultures and does not create the opportunity for encounter, but expresses the arrogance of diminished, reduced reason, which provokes fundamentalist reactions.”
The author of the piece comments:
Benedict XVI admires in Islam the certainty based on faith, which contrasts with the West where everything is relativized; and he admires in Islam the sense of the sacred, which instead seems to have disappeared in the West. He has understood that a Muslim is not offended by the crucifix, by religious symbols: this is actually a laicist polemic that strives to eliminate the religious from society. Muslims are not offended by religious symbols, but by secularized culture, by the fact that God and the values that they associate with God are absent from this civilization.
This is also my experience, when I chat every once in a while with Muslims who live in Italy. They tell me: this country offers everything, we can live as we like, but unfortunately there are no “principles” (this is the word they use). This is felt very much by the pope, who says: let’s go back to human nature, based on rationality, on conscience, which gives an idea of human rights; on the other hand, let’s not reduce rationality to something which is impoverished, but let’s integrate the religious in rationality; the religious is part of rationality.
...[Benedict XVI's] proposal is that, if we want to find a common basis, we must get out of religious dialogue to give humanistic foundations to this dialogue, because only these are universal and shared by all human beings. Humanism is a universal factor; faiths can be factors of clash and division.
The pope’s position never falls into the justification of terrorism and violence. ...But, on the other hand, he has never fallen into the behaviour found in certain Christian circles in the West marked by “do-goodism” and by guilt complexes.
The Pope's proposal to the world is simple: recognize the essential junction of faith and reason, which promotes and protects the universal human values found in the natural law and conscience.
Attempting to "reason without faith" is as impossible as attempting "faith without reason."
HT: Dhimmi Watch
Monday, February 05, 2007
Coming Soon: Network Wailing Over the Dead
You can expect some crying, a lot of fake pictures, and even MORE lies transmitted as "truth" from the usual BSCBSNBSCCNNBSABSBC.
Plans for a joint American-Iraqi offensive against insurgents in Baghdad have been laid, and the commanding Iraqi general, an American nominee, has been named. American officers say the offensive will dwarf all prior efforts:
"It's going to be an operation unlike anything this city has seen," Col. Doug Heckman added. "It's a multiple-order magnitude of difference, not just a 30 percent, I mean a couple hundred percent" larger than previous offensives.
HT: Powerline
Plans for a joint American-Iraqi offensive against insurgents in Baghdad have been laid, and the commanding Iraqi general, an American nominee, has been named. American officers say the offensive will dwarf all prior efforts:
"It's going to be an operation unlike anything this city has seen," Col. Doug Heckman added. "It's a multiple-order magnitude of difference, not just a 30 percent, I mean a couple hundred percent" larger than previous offensives.
HT: Powerline
How to Kill Terrorists
These bozo/wannabe "soldiers" are dumber than boxes of rocks:
Like the time when some ISF were driving and got blasted by an IED, causing numerous casualties and preventing them from recovering the vehicle. The terrorists came out and did their rifle-pumping-in-the-air thing, shooting AKs, dancing around like monkeys. Videos went ’round the world, making it appear the terrorists were running Mosul, which was pretty much what was being reported at the time.
But that wasn’t the whole story. In the Yarmuk neighborhood, only terrorists openly carry AK-47s. The lawyers call this Hostile Intent. The soldiers call this Dead Man Walking.
Deuce Four is an overwhelmingly aggressive and effective unit, and they believe the best defense is a dead enemy. They are constantly thinking up innovative, unique, and effective ways to kill or capture the enemy; proactive not reactive. They planned an operation with snipers, making it appear that an ISF vehicle had been attacked, complete with explosives and flash-bang grenades to simulate the IED. The simulated casualty evacuation of sand dummies completed the ruse.
The Deuce Four soldiers left quickly with the “casualties,” “abandoning” the burning truck in the traffic circle. The enemy took the bait. Terrorists came out and started with the AK-rifle-monkey-pump, shooting into the truck, their own video crews capturing the moment of glory. That’s when the American snipers opened fire and killed everybody with a weapon. Until now, only insiders knew about the AK-monkey-pumpers smack-down."
Monkey-pump, indeed.
Like the time when some ISF were driving and got blasted by an IED, causing numerous casualties and preventing them from recovering the vehicle. The terrorists came out and did their rifle-pumping-in-the-air thing, shooting AKs, dancing around like monkeys. Videos went ’round the world, making it appear the terrorists were running Mosul, which was pretty much what was being reported at the time.
But that wasn’t the whole story. In the Yarmuk neighborhood, only terrorists openly carry AK-47s. The lawyers call this Hostile Intent. The soldiers call this Dead Man Walking.
Deuce Four is an overwhelmingly aggressive and effective unit, and they believe the best defense is a dead enemy. They are constantly thinking up innovative, unique, and effective ways to kill or capture the enemy; proactive not reactive. They planned an operation with snipers, making it appear that an ISF vehicle had been attacked, complete with explosives and flash-bang grenades to simulate the IED. The simulated casualty evacuation of sand dummies completed the ruse.
The Deuce Four soldiers left quickly with the “casualties,” “abandoning” the burning truck in the traffic circle. The enemy took the bait. Terrorists came out and started with the AK-rifle-monkey-pump, shooting into the truck, their own video crews capturing the moment of glory. That’s when the American snipers opened fire and killed everybody with a weapon. Until now, only insiders knew about the AK-monkey-pumpers smack-down."
Monkey-pump, indeed.
Nader Defines The Hildebeeste
The lefties don't like HRC, do they?
Asked on CNN's Late Edition news program if he would run in 2008, the lawyer and consumer activist said, "It's really too early to say. ...
Nader, 72, said he did not plan to vote for Clinton, a Democratic senator from New York and former first lady.
"I don't think she has the fortitude. Actually she's really a panderer and a flatterer. As she goes around the country, you'll see more of that," Nader said.
On whether he would be encouraged to run if Clinton gets the Democratic nomination, Nader said, "It would make it more important that that be the case."
No question that HRC studied the X42 book.
HT: Captain's Quarters
Asked on CNN's Late Edition news program if he would run in 2008, the lawyer and consumer activist said, "It's really too early to say. ...
Nader, 72, said he did not plan to vote for Clinton, a Democratic senator from New York and former first lady.
"I don't think she has the fortitude. Actually she's really a panderer and a flatterer. As she goes around the country, you'll see more of that," Nader said.
On whether he would be encouraged to run if Clinton gets the Democratic nomination, Nader said, "It would make it more important that that be the case."
No question that HRC studied the X42 book.
HT: Captain's Quarters
Risser Shows His Wrinkles, Snows Owen
There comes a time when being 'old' is not the same as being 'wise.'
Fred Risser, the oldest Lefty in Wisconsin government, has passed that point.
Wisconsin would become one of a handful of states allowing some 17-year-olds to vote in primary elections, under a bill introduced by a Madison lawmaker.
The proposal would allow 17- year-olds who would turn 18 by the date of the general election to vote in the primary.
Freddie says that 'it's good public policy' to let the little darlings participate in 'the whole cycle.' Balderdash. There's a cutoff for everything, and that's the way it is.
HT: Owen, (who is wrong on this one.)
Fred Risser, the oldest Lefty in Wisconsin government, has passed that point.
Wisconsin would become one of a handful of states allowing some 17-year-olds to vote in primary elections, under a bill introduced by a Madison lawmaker.
The proposal would allow 17- year-olds who would turn 18 by the date of the general election to vote in the primary.
Freddie says that 'it's good public policy' to let the little darlings participate in 'the whole cycle.' Balderdash. There's a cutoff for everything, and that's the way it is.
HT: Owen, (who is wrong on this one.)
MMSD: Cheap Front-End, Expensive Results
The MMSD's original "Deep Tunnels" were only partially lined with concrete (that saved a few bucks, no?) and as a result, at least one Downtown building is settling. Damage to this one building so far? $9+ million.
Because the building owners cannot recover the full amount of the damages under the law, the judge in the case has ordered MMSD to line their tunnel with concrete to prevent further damage.
Henry Maier's "legacy:" buildings collapsing, but plenty of beer and song at Summerfest.
Because the building owners cannot recover the full amount of the damages under the law, the judge in the case has ordered MMSD to line their tunnel with concrete to prevent further damage.
Henry Maier's "legacy:" buildings collapsing, but plenty of beer and song at Summerfest.
"Real ID" in Trouble?
A major element of both national security AND vote-fraud prevention may be in trouble.
A revolt against a national driver's license, begun in Maine last month, is quickly spreading to other states.
The issue may be moot for states if Congress takes action.
Republican Sen. John Sununu of New Hampshire, along with Democratic Sen. Daniel Akaka of Hawaii, filed a bill last year to repeal the law. Sununu expects similar legislation will be introduced soon.
"The federal government should not be in charge of defining and issuing drivers' licenses," Sununu said in a statement.
Privacy advocates say a national driver's license will promote identity theft.
Barry Steinhardt, a lawyer with the American Civil Liberties Union, said the Real ID ordered by Congress would require a digital photo and probably a fingerprint on each driver's license or state-issued ID card. That, he said, will make it more valuable to identity thieves because the ID card will be accepted as much more than a driving credential.
"It's going to be a honey pot out there that's going to be irresistible to identity thieves," Steinhardt said.
The ACLU's opinion on the matter doesn't reflect their actual thought. The ACLU doesn't give a tinkers' damn about identity theft.
Their agitation will have the effect of allowing much greater freedom for illegal aliens (some of whom are terrorists) and, of course, for undermining the integrity of the vote.
DarthDoyle has also complained about "the cost" of implementing Real ID. In reality, this is also a smokescreen, as Darth's priorities do not include prevention of election fraud.
A revolt against a national driver's license, begun in Maine last month, is quickly spreading to other states.
The issue may be moot for states if Congress takes action.
Republican Sen. John Sununu of New Hampshire, along with Democratic Sen. Daniel Akaka of Hawaii, filed a bill last year to repeal the law. Sununu expects similar legislation will be introduced soon.
"The federal government should not be in charge of defining and issuing drivers' licenses," Sununu said in a statement.
Privacy advocates say a national driver's license will promote identity theft.
Barry Steinhardt, a lawyer with the American Civil Liberties Union, said the Real ID ordered by Congress would require a digital photo and probably a fingerprint on each driver's license or state-issued ID card. That, he said, will make it more valuable to identity thieves because the ID card will be accepted as much more than a driving credential.
"It's going to be a honey pot out there that's going to be irresistible to identity thieves," Steinhardt said.
The ACLU's opinion on the matter doesn't reflect their actual thought. The ACLU doesn't give a tinkers' damn about identity theft.
Their agitation will have the effect of allowing much greater freedom for illegal aliens (some of whom are terrorists) and, of course, for undermining the integrity of the vote.
DarthDoyle has also complained about "the cost" of implementing Real ID. In reality, this is also a smokescreen, as Darth's priorities do not include prevention of election fraud.
Sunday, February 04, 2007
The Good Fight
This should be very interesting, indeed.
A Wisconsin church whose leaders created a video and passed out leaflets to support a state ban on gay marriage is fighting allegations that it violated campaign finance laws by failing to disclose its activities.
Monona Oaks Community Church acknowledges it spent more than $25 - which triggers a requirement to register with the Elections Board - urging people to vote for the gay marriage ban, which passed with 59 percent of the vote last November.
But its lawyers asked the board this week to dismiss complaints filed by voters and the Freedom From Religion Foundation, arguing the registration requirement cannot apply to religious groups.
The requirement is unconstitutional because the video program on public access television and distribution of 1,500 pamphlets by church members "were protected exercises of their rights and responsibilities to freely exercise their religion," they wrote.
The Diocese of Madison was also named as an "offender" by Mike McCabe, a professional pain in the ass. But there's a difference between the two cases.
McCabe's group made a similar argument before the Nov. 7 referendum when it accused the Catholic Diocese of Madison of trying to sway the election without registering. The group cited a diocese flier urging a "yes" vote distributed outside a Catholic church in Madison.
But Madison Bishop Robert Morlino said the reporting requirement did not apply since the fliers were given to church members and called the complaint an attempt to intimidate the Catholic Church.
"To claim that I must pay a fee and report to the state about my teaching activities in Catholic venues blatantly violates the rights of myself and my sister and brother Catholics to the free exercise of religion," Morlino said at the time.
The Elections Board didn't act on the accusation [about the Catholic church] since it never received a formal complaint from a witness.
The Monona Oaks church apparently went door-to-door with its flyers.
When someone comes to my door with religious tract-materials I generally thank them for their time, shoo them away (politely as possible,) and toss their materials. It matters not whether their materials are "political" or "religious."
Seems to me that Annie, Mikie, & Co. take themselves FAR too seriously.
Or maybe they don't have any common sense.
A Wisconsin church whose leaders created a video and passed out leaflets to support a state ban on gay marriage is fighting allegations that it violated campaign finance laws by failing to disclose its activities.
Monona Oaks Community Church acknowledges it spent more than $25 - which triggers a requirement to register with the Elections Board - urging people to vote for the gay marriage ban, which passed with 59 percent of the vote last November.
But its lawyers asked the board this week to dismiss complaints filed by voters and the Freedom From Religion Foundation, arguing the registration requirement cannot apply to religious groups.
The requirement is unconstitutional because the video program on public access television and distribution of 1,500 pamphlets by church members "were protected exercises of their rights and responsibilities to freely exercise their religion," they wrote.
The Diocese of Madison was also named as an "offender" by Mike McCabe, a professional pain in the ass. But there's a difference between the two cases.
McCabe's group made a similar argument before the Nov. 7 referendum when it accused the Catholic Diocese of Madison of trying to sway the election without registering. The group cited a diocese flier urging a "yes" vote distributed outside a Catholic church in Madison.
But Madison Bishop Robert Morlino said the reporting requirement did not apply since the fliers were given to church members and called the complaint an attempt to intimidate the Catholic Church.
"To claim that I must pay a fee and report to the state about my teaching activities in Catholic venues blatantly violates the rights of myself and my sister and brother Catholics to the free exercise of religion," Morlino said at the time.
The Elections Board didn't act on the accusation [about the Catholic church] since it never received a formal complaint from a witness.
The Monona Oaks church apparently went door-to-door with its flyers.
When someone comes to my door with religious tract-materials I generally thank them for their time, shoo them away (politely as possible,) and toss their materials. It matters not whether their materials are "political" or "religious."
Seems to me that Annie, Mikie, & Co. take themselves FAR too seriously.
Or maybe they don't have any common sense.
Your Cough Won't Stop? Here's a Possible Remedy
From Some Have Hats:
Last time we were in North Carolina, my husband came home from the drug store with the worst tasting thing I have ever put anywhere near my mouth. He said, "The pharmacist said it's horrific, but if you want to stop coughing, this will do it." He was right on both counts.
The stuff is called "Buckley's Mixture."
Buckley's ad campaign seems to be straightforward:
"We're #1, But We Taste Like #2" quipped a former Buckley's ad—just one example of a ‘tell like it is’ advertisement for Buckley's cough suppressant. To be sure, Buckley's is nasty tasting, awful smelling stuff. The thick, gooey, sugar- and alcohol-free liquid is the kind of elixir that will send shivers down your spine and clear the cobwebs from your head at the first wince-filled spoonful.
So you know, neither "Hats" nor I are MDs. Didn't sleep in a Holiday Inn Express, either.
Last time we were in North Carolina, my husband came home from the drug store with the worst tasting thing I have ever put anywhere near my mouth. He said, "The pharmacist said it's horrific, but if you want to stop coughing, this will do it." He was right on both counts.
The stuff is called "Buckley's Mixture."
Buckley's ad campaign seems to be straightforward:
"We're #1, But We Taste Like #2" quipped a former Buckley's ad—just one example of a ‘tell like it is’ advertisement for Buckley's cough suppressant. To be sure, Buckley's is nasty tasting, awful smelling stuff. The thick, gooey, sugar- and alcohol-free liquid is the kind of elixir that will send shivers down your spine and clear the cobwebs from your head at the first wince-filled spoonful.
So you know, neither "Hats" nor I are MDs. Didn't sleep in a Holiday Inn Express, either.
How ICEL Works: Liturgeists Loose!
Here's the short story on ICEL's 'dynamic' translation techniques and results.
There's a Latin plaque in the Pontifical Lateran University, inscribed as follows:
SEMPER MEMORIA SERVETUR FAUSTI DIEI XII ANTE KAL NOVEMBRIS MMVI QUO BENEDICTUS XVI PONTIFEX MAXIMUS DECESSORUM SUORUM VESTIGIA SECUTUS ACADEMICA COMMUNITATE SUMMA LAETITIA RECEPTUS PONTIFICIAM UNIVERSITATEM LATERANENSEM INVISITNOVAM BIBLIOTHECAM UTI STUDIORUM ET INVESTIGATIONIS SEDEM AD SACRAM TRADITIONEM ALENDAM BENEDIXIT AULAM MAGNAM SIBI DICATAM INAUGURAVIT COMITANTIBUS CAMILLO S.R.E. CARDINALE RUINI MAGNO CANCELLARIO ET RINO FISICHELLA EPISCOPO TIT VICO HABENTINO MAGNIFICO RECTORE QUI OPUS SUSCIPIENDUM AC PERFICIENDUM CURAVIT
Here's the English translation, by Fr. George Rutler:
May the memory always be preserved of the auspicious day of 21 October 2006 on which Benedict XVI, Pontifex Maximus, following the footsteps of his predecessors, and having been received with greatest joy by the academic community, visited the Pontifical Lateran University, blessed the new library as a seat of studies and research to foster sacred tradition, and inaugurated the Great Hall dedicated to himself. Accompanying him were Camillo Ruini, Cardinal of the Holy Roman Church, the Grand Chancellor, and Rino Fisichella, titular bishop of Voghenza, the Magnificent Rector, who saw to it that the work was begun and completed.
Were ICEL the translator of the plaque, here's how it would read:
“One day last year, the Pope came to our school. He made us all very happy when he said a prayer for the new bookcases and a big room with his name on it. Cardinal Ruini (who is very important) was there and so was Bishop Rino who got it all done.”
HT: First Things and The Hermeneutic of Continuity (which provided the ICEL language.)
There's a Latin plaque in the Pontifical Lateran University, inscribed as follows:
SEMPER MEMORIA SERVETUR FAUSTI DIEI XII ANTE KAL NOVEMBRIS MMVI QUO BENEDICTUS XVI PONTIFEX MAXIMUS DECESSORUM SUORUM VESTIGIA SECUTUS ACADEMICA COMMUNITATE SUMMA LAETITIA RECEPTUS PONTIFICIAM UNIVERSITATEM LATERANENSEM INVISITNOVAM BIBLIOTHECAM UTI STUDIORUM ET INVESTIGATIONIS SEDEM AD SACRAM TRADITIONEM ALENDAM BENEDIXIT AULAM MAGNAM SIBI DICATAM INAUGURAVIT COMITANTIBUS CAMILLO S.R.E. CARDINALE RUINI MAGNO CANCELLARIO ET RINO FISICHELLA EPISCOPO TIT VICO HABENTINO MAGNIFICO RECTORE QUI OPUS SUSCIPIENDUM AC PERFICIENDUM CURAVIT
Here's the English translation, by Fr. George Rutler:
May the memory always be preserved of the auspicious day of 21 October 2006 on which Benedict XVI, Pontifex Maximus, following the footsteps of his predecessors, and having been received with greatest joy by the academic community, visited the Pontifical Lateran University, blessed the new library as a seat of studies and research to foster sacred tradition, and inaugurated the Great Hall dedicated to himself. Accompanying him were Camillo Ruini, Cardinal of the Holy Roman Church, the Grand Chancellor, and Rino Fisichella, titular bishop of Voghenza, the Magnificent Rector, who saw to it that the work was begun and completed.
Were ICEL the translator of the plaque, here's how it would read:
“One day last year, the Pope came to our school. He made us all very happy when he said a prayer for the new bookcases and a big room with his name on it. Cardinal Ruini (who is very important) was there and so was Bishop Rino who got it all done.”
HT: First Things and The Hermeneutic of Continuity (which provided the ICEL language.)
GKChesterton on Religious Liberty
This sums it up:
"Religious liberty might be supposed to mean that everybody is free to discuss religion. In practice it means that hardly anybody is allowed to mention it."
GKC, Autobiography
HT: Chesterton and Friends
"Religious liberty might be supposed to mean that everybody is free to discuss religion. In practice it means that hardly anybody is allowed to mention it."
GKC, Autobiography
HT: Chesterton and Friends
Saturday, February 03, 2007
Evaporating Cash
So what happens when cash as a % of household debt goes back to a norm of...let's say, 85%?


HT: The Big Picture
Garbage In, Garbage Out: Fox6 "News" and UN Modeling "Warming"
Despite the efforts of Channel 6' "News" to declare that the End of the World is coming to Wisconsin (savannah, anyone? swim and fish in Canada, not Three Lakes? No more dairy cows? You'll DIE of breathing difficulties......)
It was a disgusting display of opinion, and they've run the damn thing TWICE in the last 3 weeks...
Well, as I began, despite their propaganda, a few interesting notes about the UN's Climate report from Random 10:
UN scientists faced several problems their computer models had not predicted [in previous reports]. Globally, temperature is not rising at all, and sea level is not rising anything like as fast as had been forecast. … The report’s generally more cautiously-expressed projections confirm scientists’ warnings that the UN’s heavy reliance on computer models had exaggerated the temperature effect of greenhouse-gas emissions.
Previous reports in 1990, 1995 and 2001 had been progressively more alarmist. In the final draft of the new report there is a change in tone. Though carbon dioxide in the air is increasing, global temperature is not.
Computer models heavily relied on by the UN did not predict the considerable cooling of the oceans that has occurred since 2003 – a cooling which demonstrates that neither the frequency nor the intensity of the hurricanes in the year of Katrina was attributable to “global warming”.
The UN’s models also failed to predict the halt to the rise in methane concentrations in the air that began in 2001. And they did not predict the timing or size of the El Nino which hiked temperature in 1998. Without it, the satellite record shows little or no greenhouse warming. Landbased temperature records may accordingly overstate the problem. Likewise the UN’s models have recently been found to have over-projected the observed rise in sea temperatures, which has had to be corrected downward to allow for over reading by incorrectly-calibrated instrumentation.
There's more at the link. Maybe the Fox6 "news team" should actually read the news...
The reliance on "computer models" is a serious flaw, because somebody programs the computers. And if that programmer writes assumptions, well, you know the old saying about "assume."
Looks like the old saying is true.
It was a disgusting display of opinion, and they've run the damn thing TWICE in the last 3 weeks...
Well, as I began, despite their propaganda, a few interesting notes about the UN's Climate report from Random 10:
UN scientists faced several problems their computer models had not predicted [in previous reports]. Globally, temperature is not rising at all, and sea level is not rising anything like as fast as had been forecast. … The report’s generally more cautiously-expressed projections confirm scientists’ warnings that the UN’s heavy reliance on computer models had exaggerated the temperature effect of greenhouse-gas emissions.
Previous reports in 1990, 1995 and 2001 had been progressively more alarmist. In the final draft of the new report there is a change in tone. Though carbon dioxide in the air is increasing, global temperature is not.
Computer models heavily relied on by the UN did not predict the considerable cooling of the oceans that has occurred since 2003 – a cooling which demonstrates that neither the frequency nor the intensity of the hurricanes in the year of Katrina was attributable to “global warming”.
The UN’s models also failed to predict the halt to the rise in methane concentrations in the air that began in 2001. And they did not predict the timing or size of the El Nino which hiked temperature in 1998. Without it, the satellite record shows little or no greenhouse warming. Landbased temperature records may accordingly overstate the problem. Likewise the UN’s models have recently been found to have over-projected the observed rise in sea temperatures, which has had to be corrected downward to allow for over reading by incorrectly-calibrated instrumentation.
There's more at the link. Maybe the Fox6 "news team" should actually read the news...
The reliance on "computer models" is a serious flaw, because somebody programs the computers. And if that programmer writes assumptions, well, you know the old saying about "assume."
Looks like the old saying is true.
US Attorney in Texas: Nuts? or Just Soros-Lite?
You recall the story about the two Border Patrolmen who have been imprisoned for wounding an illegal alien after he shot at them.
Well, there's another one brewing:
After a Texas deputy sheriff fired shots at the tires of a fleeing vehicle that had tried to run him down, he was arrested for injuring one of the passengers, a Mexican who was being illegally smuggled into the USA.
Edwards County Deputy Sheriff Guillermo F. Hernandez could get up to 10 years in prison for doing his thankless job after being prosecuted by the office of Bush-appointed US attorney Johnny Sutton, who recently was able to obtain draconian prison terms for Border Patrol agents Ignacio Ramos and Jose Alonso Compean for wounding a drug-smuggling illegal alien who had assaulted Compean.
Hernandez's boss Sheriff Donald Letsinger confirms that he "followed the letter of the law" in defending himself — for what little that's worth.
When Hernandez is thrown in jail for violating the "civil rights" of Mexican invader Maricela Rodriguez-Garcia, he will leave behind a wife and 4-month-old daughter.
Prosecutors had offered Hernandez probation in exchange for a guilty plea, but he turned down the deal on the grounds that he had done absolutely nothing wrong.
You know, it occurs to me that I haven't heard a damn thing about either of these cases from the usual BushBotBoyzzz...
What's the matter? Worshipping at the Bush-God takes your breath away?
HT: Moonbattery
Well, there's another one brewing:
After a Texas deputy sheriff fired shots at the tires of a fleeing vehicle that had tried to run him down, he was arrested for injuring one of the passengers, a Mexican who was being illegally smuggled into the USA.
Edwards County Deputy Sheriff Guillermo F. Hernandez could get up to 10 years in prison for doing his thankless job after being prosecuted by the office of Bush-appointed US attorney Johnny Sutton, who recently was able to obtain draconian prison terms for Border Patrol agents Ignacio Ramos and Jose Alonso Compean for wounding a drug-smuggling illegal alien who had assaulted Compean.
Hernandez's boss Sheriff Donald Letsinger confirms that he "followed the letter of the law" in defending himself — for what little that's worth.
When Hernandez is thrown in jail for violating the "civil rights" of Mexican invader Maricela Rodriguez-Garcia, he will leave behind a wife and 4-month-old daughter.
Prosecutors had offered Hernandez probation in exchange for a guilty plea, but he turned down the deal on the grounds that he had done absolutely nothing wrong.
You know, it occurs to me that I haven't heard a damn thing about either of these cases from the usual BushBotBoyzzz...
What's the matter? Worshipping at the Bush-God takes your breath away?
HT: Moonbattery
Screw George Soros AND His Horse
From Captain's Quarters:
It's hard to get surprised by Leftist characterizations of conservatives as fascists The epithet flows so freely that even members of the Senate have used it, the last time by an ex-Klansman. The latest version of the insult comes from George Soros, speaking at the Davos Economic Forum last week about the situation in Iraq. Claiming that the US needs to cleanse itself from conservatives, Soros compared the process necessary to that used by the US in Germany: He went on to say that Turkey and Japan are still hurt by a reluctance to admit to dark parts of their history, and contrasted that reluctance to Germany's rejection of its Nazi-era past.
"America needs to follow the policies it has introduced in Germany," Soros said. "We have to go through a certain de-Nazification process.
Now THERE'S a guy who deserves a few buckets of spit tossed at him, either end first, at his next appearance in America.
Obama is Soros' favorite (D) candidate, by the way.
It's hard to get surprised by Leftist characterizations of conservatives as fascists The epithet flows so freely that even members of the Senate have used it, the last time by an ex-Klansman. The latest version of the insult comes from George Soros, speaking at the Davos Economic Forum last week about the situation in Iraq. Claiming that the US needs to cleanse itself from conservatives, Soros compared the process necessary to that used by the US in Germany: He went on to say that Turkey and Japan are still hurt by a reluctance to admit to dark parts of their history, and contrasted that reluctance to Germany's rejection of its Nazi-era past.
"America needs to follow the policies it has introduced in Germany," Soros said. "We have to go through a certain de-Nazification process.
Now THERE'S a guy who deserves a few buckets of spit tossed at him, either end first, at his next appearance in America.
Obama is Soros' favorite (D) candidate, by the way.
Kudos to Katie and Jessica!
The local girl makes REALLY good.
Last February, the main folks judging Katie Crabb's work were her teachers at Brookfield Central High School. This February, some 90 million people will get to see what she can do.
The college freshman, who just turned 19, has won a national contest and the honor of having a Chevrolet commercial she developed shown during the Super Bowl, the premier forum for the ad industry.
It was an improbable victory: Crabb has no advertising background. She competed against more than 200 entrants and, in the finals at General Motors headquarters in Detroit, stood alone against four other teams, each consisting of seniors or graduate students in fields such as advertising and visual communications.
She entered the Chevy Super Bowl College Ad Challenge as part of a first-semester media-writing class at the University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee. Her teacher, Jessica McBride, gave students the option of designing contest ads for the week they spend on broadcast ad writing.
OK. We'll watch for the commercial.
Last February, the main folks judging Katie Crabb's work were her teachers at Brookfield Central High School. This February, some 90 million people will get to see what she can do.
The college freshman, who just turned 19, has won a national contest and the honor of having a Chevrolet commercial she developed shown during the Super Bowl, the premier forum for the ad industry.
It was an improbable victory: Crabb has no advertising background. She competed against more than 200 entrants and, in the finals at General Motors headquarters in Detroit, stood alone against four other teams, each consisting of seniors or graduate students in fields such as advertising and visual communications.
She entered the Chevy Super Bowl College Ad Challenge as part of a first-semester media-writing class at the University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee. Her teacher, Jessica McBride, gave students the option of designing contest ads for the week they spend on broadcast ad writing.
OK. We'll watch for the commercial.
Friday, February 02, 2007
"Second Hand Smoke" Blown Away
Those dratted fact-based scientists spoil everyone's fun. Here's a guy with credentials:
Gio Batta Gori, an epidemiologist and toxicologist, is a fellow of the Health Policy Center in Bethesda. He is a former deputy director of the National Cancer Institute's Division of Cancer Cause and Prevention, and he received the U.S. Public Health Service Superior Service Award in 1976 for his efforts to define less hazardous cigarettes.
So what does he have to say?
...[D]o the studies Carmona references support his claims, and are their findings as sound as he suggests?
Lung cancer and cardiovascular diseases develop at advancing ages. Estimating the risk of those diseases posed by secondhand smoke requires knowing the sum of momentary secondhand smoke doses that nonsmokers have internalized over their lifetimes. Such lifetime summations of instant doses are obviously impossible, because concentrations of secondhand smoke in the air, individual rates of inhalation, and metabolic transformations vary from moment to moment, year after year, location to location.
In an effort to circumvent this capital obstacle, all secondhand smoke studies have estimated risk using a misleading marker of "lifetime exposure." Yet, instant exposures also vary uncontrollably over time, so lifetime summations of exposure could not be, and were not, measured.
Typically, the studies asked 60--70 year-old self-declared nonsmokers to recall how many cigarettes, cigars or pipes might have been smoked in their presence during their lifetimes, how thick the smoke might have been in the rooms, whether the windows were open, and similar vagaries. Obtained mostly during brief phone interviews, answers were then recorded as precise measures of lifetime individual exposures.
(This is called 'scientific studies'? Good heavens, I coulda hadda Ph.D.)
In reality, it is impossible to summarize accurately from momentary and vague recalls, and with an absurd expectation of precision, the total exposure to secondhand smoke over more than a half-century of a person's lifetime. No measure of cumulative lifetime secondhand smoke exposure was ever possible, so the epidemiologic studies estimated risk based not only on an improper marker of exposure, but also on exposure data that are illusory.
Adding confusion, people with lung cancer or cardiovascular disease are prone to amplify their recall of secondhand smoke exposure. Others will fib about being nonsmokers and will contaminate the results. More than two dozen causes of lung cancer are reported in the professional literature, and over 200 for cardiovascular diseases; their likely intrusions have never been credibly measured and controlled in secondhand smoke studies. Thus, the claimed risks are doubly deceptive because of interferences that could not be calculated and corrected.
In addition, results are not consistently reproducible. The majority of studies do not report a statistically significant change in risk from secondhand smoke exposure, some studies show an increase in risk, and--astoundingly--some show a reduction of risk.
Some prominent anti-smokers have been quietly forthcoming on what "the science" does and does not show. Asked to quantify secondhand smoke risks at a 2006 hearing at the UK House of Lords, Oxford epidemiologist Sir Richard Peto--a leader of the secondhand smoke crusade-- replied, "I am sorry not to be more helpful; you want numbers and I could give you numbers..., but what does one make of them? ...These hazards cannot be directly measured."
It has been fashionable to ignore the weakness of "the science" on secondhand smoke, perhaps in the belief that claiming "the science is settled" will lead to policies and public attitudes that will reduce the prevalence of smoking. But such a Faustian bargain is an ominous precedent in public health and political ethics. Consider how minimally such policies as smoking bans in bars and restaurants really reduce the prevalence of smoking, and yet how odious and socially unfair such prohibitions are.
By any sensible account, the anachronism of tobacco use should eventually vanish in an advancing civilization. Why must we promote this process under the tyranny of deception?
Presumably, we are grown-up people, with a civilized sense of fair play, and dedicated to disciplined and rational discourse. We are fortunate enough to live in a free country that is respectful of individual choices and rights, including the right to honest public policies. Still, while much is voiced about the merits of forceful advocacy, not enough is said about the fundamental requisite of advancing public health with sustainable evidence, rather than by dangerous, wanton conjectures.
A frank discussion is needed to restore straight thinking in the legitimate uses of "the science" of epidemiology--uses that go well beyond secondhand smoke issues. Today, health rights command high priority on many agendas, as they should. It is not admissible to presume that people expect those rights to be served less than truthfully.
Well, well.
They lied about "secondhand smoke." They're lying about "global warming" being caused by SUV's and industry.
What ELSE are they lying about? And to what ends?
Gio Batta Gori, an epidemiologist and toxicologist, is a fellow of the Health Policy Center in Bethesda. He is a former deputy director of the National Cancer Institute's Division of Cancer Cause and Prevention, and he received the U.S. Public Health Service Superior Service Award in 1976 for his efforts to define less hazardous cigarettes.
So what does he have to say?
...[D]o the studies Carmona references support his claims, and are their findings as sound as he suggests?
Lung cancer and cardiovascular diseases develop at advancing ages. Estimating the risk of those diseases posed by secondhand smoke requires knowing the sum of momentary secondhand smoke doses that nonsmokers have internalized over their lifetimes. Such lifetime summations of instant doses are obviously impossible, because concentrations of secondhand smoke in the air, individual rates of inhalation, and metabolic transformations vary from moment to moment, year after year, location to location.
In an effort to circumvent this capital obstacle, all secondhand smoke studies have estimated risk using a misleading marker of "lifetime exposure." Yet, instant exposures also vary uncontrollably over time, so lifetime summations of exposure could not be, and were not, measured.
Typically, the studies asked 60--70 year-old self-declared nonsmokers to recall how many cigarettes, cigars or pipes might have been smoked in their presence during their lifetimes, how thick the smoke might have been in the rooms, whether the windows were open, and similar vagaries. Obtained mostly during brief phone interviews, answers were then recorded as precise measures of lifetime individual exposures.
(This is called 'scientific studies'? Good heavens, I coulda hadda Ph.D.)
In reality, it is impossible to summarize accurately from momentary and vague recalls, and with an absurd expectation of precision, the total exposure to secondhand smoke over more than a half-century of a person's lifetime. No measure of cumulative lifetime secondhand smoke exposure was ever possible, so the epidemiologic studies estimated risk based not only on an improper marker of exposure, but also on exposure data that are illusory.
Adding confusion, people with lung cancer or cardiovascular disease are prone to amplify their recall of secondhand smoke exposure. Others will fib about being nonsmokers and will contaminate the results. More than two dozen causes of lung cancer are reported in the professional literature, and over 200 for cardiovascular diseases; their likely intrusions have never been credibly measured and controlled in secondhand smoke studies. Thus, the claimed risks are doubly deceptive because of interferences that could not be calculated and corrected.
In addition, results are not consistently reproducible. The majority of studies do not report a statistically significant change in risk from secondhand smoke exposure, some studies show an increase in risk, and--astoundingly--some show a reduction of risk.
Some prominent anti-smokers have been quietly forthcoming on what "the science" does and does not show. Asked to quantify secondhand smoke risks at a 2006 hearing at the UK House of Lords, Oxford epidemiologist Sir Richard Peto--a leader of the secondhand smoke crusade-- replied, "I am sorry not to be more helpful; you want numbers and I could give you numbers..., but what does one make of them? ...These hazards cannot be directly measured."
It has been fashionable to ignore the weakness of "the science" on secondhand smoke, perhaps in the belief that claiming "the science is settled" will lead to policies and public attitudes that will reduce the prevalence of smoking. But such a Faustian bargain is an ominous precedent in public health and political ethics. Consider how minimally such policies as smoking bans in bars and restaurants really reduce the prevalence of smoking, and yet how odious and socially unfair such prohibitions are.
By any sensible account, the anachronism of tobacco use should eventually vanish in an advancing civilization. Why must we promote this process under the tyranny of deception?
Presumably, we are grown-up people, with a civilized sense of fair play, and dedicated to disciplined and rational discourse. We are fortunate enough to live in a free country that is respectful of individual choices and rights, including the right to honest public policies. Still, while much is voiced about the merits of forceful advocacy, not enough is said about the fundamental requisite of advancing public health with sustainable evidence, rather than by dangerous, wanton conjectures.
A frank discussion is needed to restore straight thinking in the legitimate uses of "the science" of epidemiology--uses that go well beyond secondhand smoke issues. Today, health rights command high priority on many agendas, as they should. It is not admissible to presume that people expect those rights to be served less than truthfully.
Well, well.
They lied about "secondhand smoke." They're lying about "global warming" being caused by SUV's and industry.
What ELSE are they lying about? And to what ends?
More NYSlimes Lies
I know it's hard to imagine...but the NYT also lies in its magazine. Here's an excerpt from the National Right to Life Committee's Dave Andrusko's interview with Dr. Priscilla Coleman of Bowling Green U.:
I recently spoke with Dr. Priscilla Coleman who was interviewed by Ms Bazelon and briefly mentioned in the article. Dr. Coleman was disturbed by what she considers "out-right misrepresentation of the science by a reporter who was given the evidence and clearly understood it."
Bazelon writes: "The idea that abortion is at the root of women's psychological ills is not supported by the bulk of the research." She offers this conclusion, early in her lengthy essay, after having received from Dr. Coleman an overview of the more than a dozen studies published just since 2002 by the Bowling Green State University Researcher and her colleagues suggesting otherwise.
SOME facts are just not going to emerge in the NYT.
I recently spoke with Dr. Priscilla Coleman who was interviewed by Ms Bazelon and briefly mentioned in the article. Dr. Coleman was disturbed by what she considers "out-right misrepresentation of the science by a reporter who was given the evidence and clearly understood it."
Bazelon writes: "The idea that abortion is at the root of women's psychological ills is not supported by the bulk of the research." She offers this conclusion, early in her lengthy essay, after having received from Dr. Coleman an overview of the more than a dozen studies published just since 2002 by the Bowling Green State University Researcher and her colleagues suggesting otherwise.
SOME facts are just not going to emerge in the NYT.
On the Contrary re: the Muslims
Dinesh D'Souza is a respectable guy with very solid conservative credentials. Recently, however, he's been the object of derision (to say the least) because he has made remarks which undermine the "kill all the Muslims" Company line espoused by the usual suspects.
Crisis magazine interviewed him.
DD: In talking about “liberal” Muslims, we have to distinguish between the old and new liberalism. Classical liberalism—the idea that we must have the freedom to vote or to assemble or be religiously tolerant—has wide support in the Islamic world. You can look at the Pew studies or the World Values Survey for confirmation of that. Muslims can accept the old liberalism.
On the other hand, we have the new liberalism of a Nancy Pelosi, Hillary Clinton, or Michael Moore. This brand of liberalism has almost no support in the Islamic world. You can find isolated individuals like Salman Rushdie, but they have no constituency among Muslims.
[Well, GrannyNan, Hildebeeste, and Moore are icons of the atheist/materialist wacko Left, and are certainly not enjoying huge support from the average American.]
The Muslim world is divided between the radical Muslims and the traditional Muslims. Both groups are religiously and socially conservative. The main difference between the two is that the radicals support violence as a way of striking out against America, while traditional Muslims do not. However, the radicals have been very successful over the past decade in recruiting traditional Muslims into their ranks. So no long-term victory in the war on terrorism can work unless it finds a way to put a wedge between traditional Islam and radical Islam.
That makes sense.
BSP: I don’t think it’s going too far to say that most conservatives and faithful Christians would agree with 90 percent of the Islamic critique of America’s liberal culture. Given this, what can we do to help win this war? We may have more common ground than we thought.
DD: I would say three things. First, don’t condemn Islam as a whole. The clash-of-civilizations idea has a grain of truth in it, but it is both tactically and morally wrong. In fact, it plays right into bin Laden’s hands. He wants to construe the war in exactly those terms.
If you dismiss Islam as being inherently violent or say the Prophet Mohammed is the founder of terrorism, then you’re pushing the traditional Muslims into the radical camp. This is a foolish thing to do, even if what you’re saying is true.
The clash-of-civilizations thing had something to do with the, ah, nasty patch back when the Muslims grabbed Jerusalem and a bunch of Spain, too. But going on:
There must be something going on in Islam today to make it an incubator for violent fanaticism.
While rejecting Islamic theology, Christians and conservatives can find common cause with traditional Muslims on issues of morality—particularly in the foreign sphere and in the United Nations. Traditional Christians, Muslims, and Jews can help promote traditional values on the international stage.
True fact; the Roman Catholic Church has worked VERY well with the Muslims at the UN to squelch the Hildebeeste/GrannyNan (etc.)-type initiatives on global abortion, e.g.
I'd certainly rather believe D'Souza than his critics, whose War!!! Blood!! Vanquish!! screeches are not only tiresome, but impossible to execute.
Crisis magazine interviewed him.
DD: In talking about “liberal” Muslims, we have to distinguish between the old and new liberalism. Classical liberalism—the idea that we must have the freedom to vote or to assemble or be religiously tolerant—has wide support in the Islamic world. You can look at the Pew studies or the World Values Survey for confirmation of that. Muslims can accept the old liberalism.
On the other hand, we have the new liberalism of a Nancy Pelosi, Hillary Clinton, or Michael Moore. This brand of liberalism has almost no support in the Islamic world. You can find isolated individuals like Salman Rushdie, but they have no constituency among Muslims.
[Well, GrannyNan, Hildebeeste, and Moore are icons of the atheist/materialist wacko Left, and are certainly not enjoying huge support from the average American.]
The Muslim world is divided between the radical Muslims and the traditional Muslims. Both groups are religiously and socially conservative. The main difference between the two is that the radicals support violence as a way of striking out against America, while traditional Muslims do not. However, the radicals have been very successful over the past decade in recruiting traditional Muslims into their ranks. So no long-term victory in the war on terrorism can work unless it finds a way to put a wedge between traditional Islam and radical Islam.
That makes sense.
BSP: I don’t think it’s going too far to say that most conservatives and faithful Christians would agree with 90 percent of the Islamic critique of America’s liberal culture. Given this, what can we do to help win this war? We may have more common ground than we thought.
DD: I would say three things. First, don’t condemn Islam as a whole. The clash-of-civilizations idea has a grain of truth in it, but it is both tactically and morally wrong. In fact, it plays right into bin Laden’s hands. He wants to construe the war in exactly those terms.
If you dismiss Islam as being inherently violent or say the Prophet Mohammed is the founder of terrorism, then you’re pushing the traditional Muslims into the radical camp. This is a foolish thing to do, even if what you’re saying is true.
The clash-of-civilizations thing had something to do with the, ah, nasty patch back when the Muslims grabbed Jerusalem and a bunch of Spain, too. But going on:
There must be something going on in Islam today to make it an incubator for violent fanaticism.
While rejecting Islamic theology, Christians and conservatives can find common cause with traditional Muslims on issues of morality—particularly in the foreign sphere and in the United Nations. Traditional Christians, Muslims, and Jews can help promote traditional values on the international stage.
True fact; the Roman Catholic Church has worked VERY well with the Muslims at the UN to squelch the Hildebeeste/GrannyNan (etc.)-type initiatives on global abortion, e.g.
I'd certainly rather believe D'Souza than his critics, whose War!!! Blood!! Vanquish!! screeches are not only tiresome, but impossible to execute.
Charting the Seven Deadly Sins
Here's an interesting way to look at some current fads. First look at the column on the left, which is the key. Then guffaw your way through the geometric exercise.

HT: Dappled Things

HT: Dappled Things
Eleven Myths of Liturgy
The Adoremus Bulletin usually has good stuff, and this is no exception. The author is a 20-year veteran parish musician who has obviously read the documents--not just rolled over for the Liturgeist Crowd of American Idol rejects. Here are the Myths and some comments:
1) There is no need for a choir in today’s parish. If you have one, its only function is to support congregational singing.
But the General Instruction of the Roman Missal (GIRM) says: “Among the faithful, the schola cantorum or choir exercises its own liturgical function, ensuring that the parts proper to it, in keeping with the different types of chants, are properly carried out and fostering the active participation of the faithful through the singing”.
2. The liturgy requires a leader of song.
Regarding the “leader of song”, the GIRM says: “It is fitting that there be a cantor or a choir director to lead and sustain the people’s singing. When in fact there is no choir, it is up to the cantor to lead the different chants, with the people taking part.”
Note that the GIRM specifies that it is up to the cantor to lead the singing when there is no choir. I served at a parish for many years that had no “leader of song;” instead the congregational singing, which was unusually robust for a Catholic church, was led by a trained choir and an accomplished organist who knew how to simultaneously guide and support the congregation. (See, e.g., St. Anthony's on 9th and Mitchell, for a local example.)
3. Mass must open with a congregational gathering song.
A congregational hymn or song as the Entrance chant has become de rigueur, yet it is not required by the GIRM. The American version of the GIRM permits it but only as the last of four options.
4. The nine-fold Kyrie, required in the pre-Vatican II Mass, is obsolete.
But the GIRM says: “As a rule, each acclamation (of the Kyrie) is sung or said twice, though it may be repeated several times, by reason of the character of the various languages, as well as of the artistry of the music or of other circumstances.”
5. The Gloria is strictly a congregational part.
Yet the GIRM states: “The Gloria is intoned by the priest or, if appropriate, by a cantor or by the choir; but it is sung either by everyone together, or by the people alternately with the choir or by the choir alone.”
6. When the psalm between the readings is sung, it must be sung responsorially.
It is preferable that the responsorial Psalm be sung, at least as far as the people’s response is concerned. Hence, the psalmist, or the cantor of the Psalm, sings the verses of the Psalm from the ambo or another suitable place. The entire congregation remains seated and listens but, as a rule, takes part by singing the response, except when the Psalm is sung straight through without a response. (Of course, a trained cantor is necessary.)
7. The readings, Creed, and general intercessions should not be sung.
Concerning the general intercessions, the GIRM says: “The intentions are announced from the ambo or from another suitable place, by the deacon or by a cantor, a lector, or one of the lay faithful.”
Regarding the Creed, the GIRM says “If it is sung, it is begun by the priest or, if this is appropriate, by a cantor or by the choir. It is sung, however, either by all together or by the people alternating with the choir.”
8. The Lamb of God is a litany that properly includes tropes.
There is simply no provision in the liturgical rules for any changes or insertions to the text of the Lamb of God, except for the option to repeat the petition as often as needed to cover the fraction rite.
9. The congregation must sing during Communion.
In describing the Communion chant, the GIRM says: “This is sung either by the choir alone or by the choir or cantor with the people.”
10. The time before Mass and the time after Communion are ideal opportunities for the choir to sing by itself.
It is clear that the song after Communion is to be sung by the congregation, not by the choir. It is not a time for a “performance” by the choir. Nor is it necessarily a time of meditation (one frequently hears mention of “the Meditation Song”), since a “psalm or other canticle of praise or a hymn” may be sung.
I like to call this “throwing a bone to the choir”. The choir has its own proper liturgical role. It does not exist to “fill in the gaps”.
11. The most important congregational parts of the Mass are the hymns and songs.
But the GIRM says: “The acclamations and the responses of the faithful to the priest’s greetings and prayers constitute that level of active participation that the gathered faithful are to contribute in every form of the Mass, so that the action of the entire community may be clearly expressed and fostered.”
In addition to their generally astounding ignorance of the documents governing liturgy, most current "music directors" have an abysmal (or worse) knowledge of the Church's patrimony of music for the liturgy.
But they make up for it with insufferable sanctimony and condescension!
1) There is no need for a choir in today’s parish. If you have one, its only function is to support congregational singing.
But the General Instruction of the Roman Missal (GIRM) says: “Among the faithful, the schola cantorum or choir exercises its own liturgical function, ensuring that the parts proper to it, in keeping with the different types of chants, are properly carried out and fostering the active participation of the faithful through the singing”.
2. The liturgy requires a leader of song.
Regarding the “leader of song”, the GIRM says: “It is fitting that there be a cantor or a choir director to lead and sustain the people’s singing. When in fact there is no choir, it is up to the cantor to lead the different chants, with the people taking part.”
Note that the GIRM specifies that it is up to the cantor to lead the singing when there is no choir. I served at a parish for many years that had no “leader of song;” instead the congregational singing, which was unusually robust for a Catholic church, was led by a trained choir and an accomplished organist who knew how to simultaneously guide and support the congregation. (See, e.g., St. Anthony's on 9th and Mitchell, for a local example.)
3. Mass must open with a congregational gathering song.
A congregational hymn or song as the Entrance chant has become de rigueur, yet it is not required by the GIRM. The American version of the GIRM permits it but only as the last of four options.
4. The nine-fold Kyrie, required in the pre-Vatican II Mass, is obsolete.
But the GIRM says: “As a rule, each acclamation (of the Kyrie) is sung or said twice, though it may be repeated several times, by reason of the character of the various languages, as well as of the artistry of the music or of other circumstances.”
5. The Gloria is strictly a congregational part.
Yet the GIRM states: “The Gloria is intoned by the priest or, if appropriate, by a cantor or by the choir; but it is sung either by everyone together, or by the people alternately with the choir or by the choir alone.”
6. When the psalm between the readings is sung, it must be sung responsorially.
It is preferable that the responsorial Psalm be sung, at least as far as the people’s response is concerned. Hence, the psalmist, or the cantor of the Psalm, sings the verses of the Psalm from the ambo or another suitable place. The entire congregation remains seated and listens but, as a rule, takes part by singing the response, except when the Psalm is sung straight through without a response. (Of course, a trained cantor is necessary.)
7. The readings, Creed, and general intercessions should not be sung.
Concerning the general intercessions, the GIRM says: “The intentions are announced from the ambo or from another suitable place, by the deacon or by a cantor, a lector, or one of the lay faithful.”
Regarding the Creed, the GIRM says “If it is sung, it is begun by the priest or, if this is appropriate, by a cantor or by the choir. It is sung, however, either by all together or by the people alternating with the choir.”
8. The Lamb of God is a litany that properly includes tropes.
There is simply no provision in the liturgical rules for any changes or insertions to the text of the Lamb of God, except for the option to repeat the petition as often as needed to cover the fraction rite.
9. The congregation must sing during Communion.
In describing the Communion chant, the GIRM says: “This is sung either by the choir alone or by the choir or cantor with the people.”
10. The time before Mass and the time after Communion are ideal opportunities for the choir to sing by itself.
It is clear that the song after Communion is to be sung by the congregation, not by the choir. It is not a time for a “performance” by the choir. Nor is it necessarily a time of meditation (one frequently hears mention of “the Meditation Song”), since a “psalm or other canticle of praise or a hymn” may be sung.
I like to call this “throwing a bone to the choir”. The choir has its own proper liturgical role. It does not exist to “fill in the gaps”.
11. The most important congregational parts of the Mass are the hymns and songs.
But the GIRM says: “The acclamations and the responses of the faithful to the priest’s greetings and prayers constitute that level of active participation that the gathered faithful are to contribute in every form of the Mass, so that the action of the entire community may be clearly expressed and fostered.”
In addition to their generally astounding ignorance of the documents governing liturgy, most current "music directors" have an abysmal (or worse) knowledge of the Church's patrimony of music for the liturgy.
But they make up for it with insufferable sanctimony and condescension!
Stella Awards (DumbAss Lawsuits)--2006
They're out! Courtesy DomBet, here's the Final Five:
#5: Marcy Meckler. While shopping at a mall, Meckler stepped outside and was “attacked” by a squirrel that lived among the trees and bushes. And “while frantically attempting to escape from the squirrel and detach it from her leg, [Meckler] fell and suffered severe injuries,” her resulting lawsuit says. That’s the mall’s fault, the lawsuit claims, demanding in excess of $50,000, based on the mall’s “failure to warn” her that squirrels live outside.
#4: Ron and Kristie Simmons. The couple’s 4-year-old son, Justin, was killed in a tragic lawnmower accident in a licensed daycare facility, and the death was clearly the result of negligence by the daycare providers. The providers were clearly deserving of being sued, yet when the Simmons’s discovered the daycare only had $100,000 in insurance, they dropped the case against them and instead sued the manufacturer of the 16-year-old lawn mower because the mower didn’t have a safety device that 1) had not been invented at the time of the mower’s manufacture, and 2) no safety agency had even suggested needed to be invented. A sympathetic jury still awarded the family $2 million.
#3: Robert Clymer. An FBI agent working a high-profile case in Las Vegas, Clymer allegedly created a disturbance, lost the magazine from his pistol, then crashed his pickup truck in a drunken stupor—his blood-alcohol level was 0.306 percent, more than three times the legal limit for driving in Nevada. He pled guilty to drunk driving because, his lawyer explained, “With public officials, we expect them to own up to their mistakes and correct them.” Yet Clymer had the gall to sue the manufacturer of his pickup truck, and the dealer he bought it from, because he “somehow lost consciousness” and the truck “somehow produced a heavy smoke that filled the passenger cab.” Yep: the drunk-driving accident wasn’t his fault, but the truck’s fault. Just the kind of guy you want carrying a gun in the name of the law.
#2: KinderStart.com. The specialty search engine says Google should be forced to include the KinderStart site in its listings, reveal how its “Page Rank” system works, and pay them lots of money because they’re a competitor. They claim by not being ranked higher in Google, Google is somehow infringing KinderStart’s Constitutional right to free speech. Even if by some stretch they were a competitor of Google, why in the world would they think it’s Google’s responsibility to help them succeed? And if Google’s “review” of their site is negative, wouldn’t a government court order forcing them to change it infringe on Google’s Constitutional right to free speech?
And the winner of the 2006 True Stella Award: Allen Ray Heckard. Even though Heckard is 3 inches shorter, 25 pounds lighter, and 8 years older than former basketball star Michael Jordan, the Portland, Oregon, man says he looks a lot like Jordan, and is often confused for him—and thus he deserves $52 million “for defamation and permanent injury”—plus $364 million in “punitive damage for emotional pain and suffering”, plus the SAME amount from Nike co-founder Phil Knight, for a grand total of $832 million. He dropped the suit after Nike’s lawyers chatted with him, where they presumably explained how they’d counter-sue if he pressed on.
©2007 by Randy Cassingham
©2007 by Randy Cassingham,
#5: Marcy Meckler. While shopping at a mall, Meckler stepped outside and was “attacked” by a squirrel that lived among the trees and bushes. And “while frantically attempting to escape from the squirrel and detach it from her leg, [Meckler] fell and suffered severe injuries,” her resulting lawsuit says. That’s the mall’s fault, the lawsuit claims, demanding in excess of $50,000, based on the mall’s “failure to warn” her that squirrels live outside.
#4: Ron and Kristie Simmons. The couple’s 4-year-old son, Justin, was killed in a tragic lawnmower accident in a licensed daycare facility, and the death was clearly the result of negligence by the daycare providers. The providers were clearly deserving of being sued, yet when the Simmons’s discovered the daycare only had $100,000 in insurance, they dropped the case against them and instead sued the manufacturer of the 16-year-old lawn mower because the mower didn’t have a safety device that 1) had not been invented at the time of the mower’s manufacture, and 2) no safety agency had even suggested needed to be invented. A sympathetic jury still awarded the family $2 million.
#3: Robert Clymer. An FBI agent working a high-profile case in Las Vegas, Clymer allegedly created a disturbance, lost the magazine from his pistol, then crashed his pickup truck in a drunken stupor—his blood-alcohol level was 0.306 percent, more than three times the legal limit for driving in Nevada. He pled guilty to drunk driving because, his lawyer explained, “With public officials, we expect them to own up to their mistakes and correct them.” Yet Clymer had the gall to sue the manufacturer of his pickup truck, and the dealer he bought it from, because he “somehow lost consciousness” and the truck “somehow produced a heavy smoke that filled the passenger cab.” Yep: the drunk-driving accident wasn’t his fault, but the truck’s fault. Just the kind of guy you want carrying a gun in the name of the law.
#2: KinderStart.com. The specialty search engine says Google should be forced to include the KinderStart site in its listings, reveal how its “Page Rank” system works, and pay them lots of money because they’re a competitor. They claim by not being ranked higher in Google, Google is somehow infringing KinderStart’s Constitutional right to free speech. Even if by some stretch they were a competitor of Google, why in the world would they think it’s Google’s responsibility to help them succeed? And if Google’s “review” of their site is negative, wouldn’t a government court order forcing them to change it infringe on Google’s Constitutional right to free speech?
And the winner of the 2006 True Stella Award: Allen Ray Heckard. Even though Heckard is 3 inches shorter, 25 pounds lighter, and 8 years older than former basketball star Michael Jordan, the Portland, Oregon, man says he looks a lot like Jordan, and is often confused for him—and thus he deserves $52 million “for defamation and permanent injury”—plus $364 million in “punitive damage for emotional pain and suffering”, plus the SAME amount from Nike co-founder Phil Knight, for a grand total of $832 million. He dropped the suit after Nike’s lawyers chatted with him, where they presumably explained how they’d counter-sue if he pressed on.
©2007 by Randy Cassingham
©2007 by Randy Cassingham,
Going Vista? Read This First
I've found that these guys are really good, as is their advice. Lots of useful links in the article, too.
I'll stay with XP for a while, even though my Milwaukee PC hardware setup will be adequate.
Let me know about the bugs.
I'll stay with XP for a while, even though my Milwaukee PC hardware setup will be adequate.
Let me know about the bugs.
Is Alderman Donovan the Next Tom Reynolds?
While Tom Reynolds was a good conservative, he said and did a few wacky things. Most of us assigned the wacko moments to "charm," as in 'odd-but-not-harmful.'
Let's hope Milwaukee's Aldermen Donovan is in the same category. Here's the "odd" part, reported by Kevin Fischer in his blog:
Milwaukee Alderman Bob Donovan says the Governor should step in and take over control of the entire Milwaukee Public Schools System. Uhhh, Bob….about 50-100 people in a crowd of 1100 got out of hand. And you want the state to take over the entire MPS system?
Actually, Kevin, I'd rather have the Governor and the Legislature teaching schools than actually making laws and raising taxes...
Maybe Donovan has a point, eh?
Let's hope Milwaukee's Aldermen Donovan is in the same category. Here's the "odd" part, reported by Kevin Fischer in his blog:
Milwaukee Alderman Bob Donovan says the Governor should step in and take over control of the entire Milwaukee Public Schools System. Uhhh, Bob….about 50-100 people in a crowd of 1100 got out of hand. And you want the state to take over the entire MPS system?
Actually, Kevin, I'd rather have the Governor and the Legislature teaching schools than actually making laws and raising taxes...
Maybe Donovan has a point, eh?
David Trashed Goliath--Again
The State Journal (you know--the paper with the blackened Red Star logo) reports that "Fair Wisconsin" spent $4+MM to promote Homosex marriage.
"Vote Yes"--the folks with right order on their side--only spent $600K.
Heh.
"Vote Yes"--the folks with right order on their side--only spent $600K.
Heh.
ISM Goes Negative
Continuing a pattern of decreases for the last several months, the ISM index (Purchasing Managers' Index for us old fogies) has now gone negative. The index has been trending down since last April's 12-month high of 56.9. (It was also negative in November, bounced slightly "+" in December, and reverted in January.)
It's now 49.3, a 2 point drop from December.
As long as we mentioned old fogies, it's also noted in the ISM report that the price of copper is down. That's usually bad news for manufacturing.
It's now 49.3, a 2 point drop from December.
As long as we mentioned old fogies, it's also noted in the ISM report that the price of copper is down. That's usually bad news for manufacturing.
Iraq News
From my own Deep Throat on matters in Iraq, I'm informed that AlQ is taking a real beating at the hands (and guns) of Allied forces.
You saw it here. Don't look for it in AP/Reuters or the alphabet soup of networks.
Just like the story here. Still hasn't appeared in the local paper, nor on the 6/10PM news, albeit this target was a very important one.
You saw it here. Don't look for it in AP/Reuters or the alphabet soup of networks.
Just like the story here. Still hasn't appeared in the local paper, nor on the 6/10PM news, albeit this target was a very important one.
Sly Jab of the Week
Nominee: P-Mac.
Line?
...though Coulter's point is that it's far easier to believe Libby forgot than did President Willy.
It works because EVERYBODY knows, immediately, the object of the wickedly delightful pun.
Line?
...though Coulter's point is that it's far easier to believe Libby forgot than did President Willy.
It works because EVERYBODY knows, immediately, the object of the wickedly delightful pun.
Global Warming Is a Redux
The ABC News weatherman let one slip through.
"About 11,500 years ago . . . forests quickly regained the ground that they had lost to cold and aridity. Ice sheets again began melting, though because of their size they took about two thousand more years to disappear completely. The Earth entered several thousand years of conditions warmer and moister than today; the Saharan and Arabian deserts almost completely disappeared under a vegetation cover, and in the northern latitudes forests grew slightly closer to the poles than they do at present. This phase, known as the 'Holocene optimum' occurred between about 9,000 and 5,000 years ago.
"Perhaps even more signicantly, the paper paints a picture of mammoth climate changes going back hundreds of thousands of years, repeated cycles of heating and cooling that as recently as 18,000 years ago - a blink in geological terms -...
So who the Hell was flying jumbo jets?
"About 11,500 years ago . . . forests quickly regained the ground that they had lost to cold and aridity. Ice sheets again began melting, though because of their size they took about two thousand more years to disappear completely. The Earth entered several thousand years of conditions warmer and moister than today; the Saharan and Arabian deserts almost completely disappeared under a vegetation cover, and in the northern latitudes forests grew slightly closer to the poles than they do at present. This phase, known as the 'Holocene optimum' occurred between about 9,000 and 5,000 years ago.
"Perhaps even more signicantly, the paper paints a picture of mammoth climate changes going back hundreds of thousands of years, repeated cycles of heating and cooling that as recently as 18,000 years ago - a blink in geological terms -...
So who the Hell was flying jumbo jets?
How Much State-Supported College Is TOO Much?
GOP3 relays some interesting info while dissecting a tuition-increase notice from Marquette U.
The info pertains to more than just Marquette--it is noteworthy for Wisconsin taxpayers who will be funding DarthDoyle's $225 million spending-on-college program(s) in the future.
A good rule of thumb is that tuition rates will increase at about twice the general inflation rate. During any 17-year period from 1958 to 2001, the average annual tuition inflation rate was between 6% and 9%, ranging from 1.2 times general inflation to 2.1 times general inflation. On average, tuition tends to increase about 8% per year. An 8% college inflation rate means that the cost of college doubles every nine years.
Think about that.
UW students who are residents of Wisconsin do NOT pay the cost of their education; Wisconsin taxpayers kick in quite a bit.
It's about time for some legislator with cojones to propose a shut-down of a couple of UW campuses. River Falls? Parkside?
The GOP3 entry has a LOT more of interest to freight-payers--issues of governance, slop, inefficiency, rent-seeking...
In short, colleges are merely a form of Government in less-frenetic settings.
The info pertains to more than just Marquette--it is noteworthy for Wisconsin taxpayers who will be funding DarthDoyle's $225 million spending-on-college program(s) in the future.
A good rule of thumb is that tuition rates will increase at about twice the general inflation rate. During any 17-year period from 1958 to 2001, the average annual tuition inflation rate was between 6% and 9%, ranging from 1.2 times general inflation to 2.1 times general inflation. On average, tuition tends to increase about 8% per year. An 8% college inflation rate means that the cost of college doubles every nine years.
Think about that.
UW students who are residents of Wisconsin do NOT pay the cost of their education; Wisconsin taxpayers kick in quite a bit.
It's about time for some legislator with cojones to propose a shut-down of a couple of UW campuses. River Falls? Parkside?
The GOP3 entry has a LOT more of interest to freight-payers--issues of governance, slop, inefficiency, rent-seeking...
In short, colleges are merely a form of Government in less-frenetic settings.
Tell Me Again Why I Should Join the (R) Party-WI
Marcus Aurelius reports:
The country club Republicans are with the left on this issue. [While] debating resolutions one member of the resolution committee I am working with informed us since the RPW does not control the state senate the RPW is not going to push concealed carry and therefore we should drop concealed carry and second amendment rights resolutions.
Wow, the left loses on a Constitutional amendment issue and what do they do? They pretty much declare the fight is just starting.
And therein lies the key. RPW honchos duck for cover and comfort at the Milwaukee Athletic Club or wherever, while inner-city citizens duck for cover--prevented from self-defense.
Hell of a way to build a party.
The country club Republicans are with the left on this issue. [While] debating resolutions one member of the resolution committee I am working with informed us since the RPW does not control the state senate the RPW is not going to push concealed carry and therefore we should drop concealed carry and second amendment rights resolutions.
Wow, the left loses on a Constitutional amendment issue and what do they do? They pretty much declare the fight is just starting.
And therein lies the key. RPW honchos duck for cover and comfort at the Milwaukee Athletic Club or wherever, while inner-city citizens duck for cover--prevented from self-defense.
Hell of a way to build a party.
Clean Wisconsin and Sierra Club to Clean Your Clocks?
Some bunch of wackos wants you to pay a LOT more for your lights (and computer time.)
Clean Wisconsin and the Sierra Club pursued a legal challenge [about] whether 2 billion gallons of Lake Michigan water will be cycled through the power plant daily to cool it. Environmentalists say last week's ruling should require We Energies to build two huge water cooling towers rather than proceed with its plan to draw lake water through a pipe that they fear would kill fish and other aquatic life.
The ruling came from a Federal Appeals Court in New York State.
The Wisconsin DNR doesn't think that the NY ruling has anything to do with the WE permit, maintaining that the decision to allow WE's method was based on State law.
But at minimum, your electric bill will cover legal fees defending WE.
Clean Wisconsin and the Sierra Club pursued a legal challenge [about] whether 2 billion gallons of Lake Michigan water will be cycled through the power plant daily to cool it. Environmentalists say last week's ruling should require We Energies to build two huge water cooling towers rather than proceed with its plan to draw lake water through a pipe that they fear would kill fish and other aquatic life.
The ruling came from a Federal Appeals Court in New York State.
The Wisconsin DNR doesn't think that the NY ruling has anything to do with the WE permit, maintaining that the decision to allow WE's method was based on State law.
But at minimum, your electric bill will cover legal fees defending WE.
Perjury Watch
Well, somebody's going to dissemble.
Two of Gov. Jim Doyle's appointees told a Department of Transportation attorney to delay the release of a politically damaging 2004 report - in apparent violation of the state open records law - the attorney testified Thursday.
Attorney Jim Thiel said he was told to not release the report until after he got a copy of a Department of Administration rebuttal that questioned the DOT's finding that state engineers cost 18% less than consultants. The conclusion that state employees cost less conflicted with Doyle's platform of trimming state jobs.
Sure enough, the best part is scheduled for Friday:
Busalacchi and Romanski are among those slated to testify today.
Romanski is now a bigwig in DNR. That's comforting.
Two of Gov. Jim Doyle's appointees told a Department of Transportation attorney to delay the release of a politically damaging 2004 report - in apparent violation of the state open records law - the attorney testified Thursday.
Attorney Jim Thiel said he was told to not release the report until after he got a copy of a Department of Administration rebuttal that questioned the DOT's finding that state engineers cost 18% less than consultants. The conclusion that state employees cost less conflicted with Doyle's platform of trimming state jobs.
Sure enough, the best part is scheduled for Friday:
Busalacchi and Romanski are among those slated to testify today.
Romanski is now a bigwig in DNR. That's comforting.
China Is Our Friend!! (And They Bought Clinton & Berger)
When Red China shot a satellite out of the sky, Sandy (Pants) Berger knew he had been a success. It was his work which allowed Red China to obtain the technology needed for that little adventure, arguably the most significant Red Chinese arms development in the last 30 years.
It was Berger's influence on X42 (along with several hundred thou in campaign contributions) which brought X42 to a "coffee" tete-a-tete with a Red Chinese arms-smuggler.
So why isn't Sandy sharing a jail cell with the disgraced money-mad Bernie Schwartz, ex-CEO of Loral, who supplied the technology AND consulting?
The whole story is a bit complex for a blog, but it's here.
Maybe the Department of Justice will have a bit more interest in Berger.
Then again, maybe not.
It was Berger's influence on X42 (along with several hundred thou in campaign contributions) which brought X42 to a "coffee" tete-a-tete with a Red Chinese arms-smuggler.
So why isn't Sandy sharing a jail cell with the disgraced money-mad Bernie Schwartz, ex-CEO of Loral, who supplied the technology AND consulting?
The whole story is a bit complex for a blog, but it's here.
Maybe the Department of Justice will have a bit more interest in Berger.
Then again, maybe not.
Thursday, February 01, 2007
AT&T, Locals, Cable, and More Gummint Greed
Who owns the telephone poles?
Who "owns" the right-of-way?
Way back when, before Noah floated his boat, Wisconsin Electric Power Company put up poles which carried wires which carried electric current. Wisconsin Telephone Company agreed to use WEPCo's poles.
People (taxpayers!) who purchase electricity and telephone service eventually paid for all those damn poles.
"Right-of-way" is a concession made by people (taxpayers!) to their local Gummint. The right-of-way is there for the common good; it may be used for civic improvements. But the property-owner (taxpayer!!) maintains the right-of-way. They clear the sidewalks, if any. They mow the grass, if any. No municipality spends its money on the "right-of-way" on a day-to-day basis.
By and by, Wisconsin Telephone Company became AT&T. All those poles which ratepayers (taxpayers!!) paid for over these many years, and which AT&T and WEPCo (now Weenergies) maintain with ratepayer (taxpayer!!!) and shareholder (taxpayer!!!) moneys are still out there.
But suddenly, some municipalities think that THEY should derive revenues from the existence of those telephone poles and rights-of-way. Guaranteed revenues. From (are you ready for this?) guess who???
The Taxpayer!! who, after all, pays the Gummint's extortions through Rates!!
Of all the entities on Earth who deserve revenues from utility poles, the LAST ONE is your local Gummint. The very last.
Screw'em.
Who "owns" the right-of-way?
Way back when, before Noah floated his boat, Wisconsin Electric Power Company put up poles which carried wires which carried electric current. Wisconsin Telephone Company agreed to use WEPCo's poles.
People (taxpayers!) who purchase electricity and telephone service eventually paid for all those damn poles.
"Right-of-way" is a concession made by people (taxpayers!) to their local Gummint. The right-of-way is there for the common good; it may be used for civic improvements. But the property-owner (taxpayer!!) maintains the right-of-way. They clear the sidewalks, if any. They mow the grass, if any. No municipality spends its money on the "right-of-way" on a day-to-day basis.
By and by, Wisconsin Telephone Company became AT&T. All those poles which ratepayers (taxpayers!!) paid for over these many years, and which AT&T and WEPCo (now Weenergies) maintain with ratepayer (taxpayer!!!) and shareholder (taxpayer!!!) moneys are still out there.
But suddenly, some municipalities think that THEY should derive revenues from the existence of those telephone poles and rights-of-way. Guaranteed revenues. From (are you ready for this?) guess who???
The Taxpayer!! who, after all, pays the Gummint's extortions through Rates!!
Of all the entities on Earth who deserve revenues from utility poles, the LAST ONE is your local Gummint. The very last.
Screw'em.
The End of the World? Belling's Analysis Flawed
Heard the prediction of The End of the World this afternoon--taxwise, that is, in Wisconsin.
Well, maybe--and maybe not.
Let's clear some underbrush.
1) The commuter-rail deal is a buzzing fly. Taxing rental cars is a bad idea, but the rail system idea is fatuous, no matter how many Chicago-based executives tell us otherwise. It remains to be seen whether the rail system will be built; I think Tom Barrett and Scott Walker are waiting for a better place to put the Federal dollars, and the very second it comes along, this idea is dead, dead, dead.
2) The fact that two school referendums passed in November is NOT significant. Belling thinks otherwise, but his analysis is in error. As we have often mentioned, the November election was an anomaly: there was an extraordinary turnout of lefties because of ONE issue: the Homosex Marriage amendment. It's dangerous to draw any conclusions from that particular election--except that John Gard made a horrendous error in placing the Amendment on the ballot (as he had been told.)
Don't conclude that Wisconsin residents are now assuming the position and purchasing Vaseline based on the 11/06 results.
3) Elmbrook's School Board proposes; Elmbrook VOTERS dispose. Rarely (if ever)do Elmbrook District voters put up yard signs and carry on over massive tax-increase proposals. They just vote them down. The voters in Elmbrook are sophisticated, and realize that the referendum's dollar-amount is merely a 'negotiating position.' The voters have their own position: it's called "NO" on the ballot. My bet: 3 tries before approval, at a MUCH smaller number.
4) Doyle proposes; the Legislature disposes. While DarthDoyle can veto his way around most anything (at some risk,) it's not likely that he will ram a boatload of tax increases through the Legislature, because the Republicans will NOT support them. For that matter, there are Democrats that won't, either.
5) As to 'removing caps' on school district spending: no Conservative supported the concept that the State should govern local taxing decisions in the first damn place. Conservatives believe in LOCAL CONTROL. Refer to #3 above if you have questions.
Wisconsin taxes are onerous and everybody knows it. Don't bet the farm on massive increases--either in cigarette taxes or in other taxes. The large turnout of highly motivated Lefties won't happen again soon; they're tending to their pot plantations for a while.
Well, maybe--and maybe not.
Let's clear some underbrush.
1) The commuter-rail deal is a buzzing fly. Taxing rental cars is a bad idea, but the rail system idea is fatuous, no matter how many Chicago-based executives tell us otherwise. It remains to be seen whether the rail system will be built; I think Tom Barrett and Scott Walker are waiting for a better place to put the Federal dollars, and the very second it comes along, this idea is dead, dead, dead.
2) The fact that two school referendums passed in November is NOT significant. Belling thinks otherwise, but his analysis is in error. As we have often mentioned, the November election was an anomaly: there was an extraordinary turnout of lefties because of ONE issue: the Homosex Marriage amendment. It's dangerous to draw any conclusions from that particular election--except that John Gard made a horrendous error in placing the Amendment on the ballot (as he had been told.)
Don't conclude that Wisconsin residents are now assuming the position and purchasing Vaseline based on the 11/06 results.
3) Elmbrook's School Board proposes; Elmbrook VOTERS dispose. Rarely (if ever)do Elmbrook District voters put up yard signs and carry on over massive tax-increase proposals. They just vote them down. The voters in Elmbrook are sophisticated, and realize that the referendum's dollar-amount is merely a 'negotiating position.' The voters have their own position: it's called "NO" on the ballot. My bet: 3 tries before approval, at a MUCH smaller number.
4) Doyle proposes; the Legislature disposes. While DarthDoyle can veto his way around most anything (at some risk,) it's not likely that he will ram a boatload of tax increases through the Legislature, because the Republicans will NOT support them. For that matter, there are Democrats that won't, either.
5) As to 'removing caps' on school district spending: no Conservative supported the concept that the State should govern local taxing decisions in the first damn place. Conservatives believe in LOCAL CONTROL. Refer to #3 above if you have questions.
Wisconsin taxes are onerous and everybody knows it. Don't bet the farm on massive increases--either in cigarette taxes or in other taxes. The large turnout of highly motivated Lefties won't happen again soon; they're tending to their pot plantations for a while.
One Less Terrorist
There are successes, and this is a sweet one.
Mohammed Jamal Khalifa, one of Osama bin Laden's brother-in-laws with deep roots in al-Qaeda as a financier and facilitator, has been reported to have been murdered in his bedroom in Madagascar. Khalifa, "who mined and traded precious stones in Madagascar," was reported to have been murdered by "a gang of 20 to 30 gunmen broke into his brother's bedroom, shot him dead 'in cold blood' and stole his belongings."
And it was the US military!!
"I don't think [his death] was politically motivated," said Malek Khalifa, Mohammed Jamal's brother. But Khalifa's deep ties to al-Qaeda, coupled with his history of funding global terrorist operations, his operations in mining precious stones in Africa (a source of untraceable income), and the size of the 'gang' that murdered him, suggests otherwise. We suspect Khalifa was assassinated. "They stole everything — his computer, all of his things," said Khalifa's brother. Task Force 145 has a mandate to hunt down senior al-Qaeda operatives world wide, and is known to have operated in Pakistan to destroy Osama bin Laden's Black Guard. Also, the U.S. recently deployed naval assets to the region, as well as Task Force 145, in the hunt for al-Qaeda and Islamic Courts leaders fleeing Somalia.
This guy has a very long record as a terrorist-financier and all-around scumbag.
Good Show!!
HT: The Fourth Rail
Mohammed Jamal Khalifa, one of Osama bin Laden's brother-in-laws with deep roots in al-Qaeda as a financier and facilitator, has been reported to have been murdered in his bedroom in Madagascar. Khalifa, "who mined and traded precious stones in Madagascar," was reported to have been murdered by "a gang of 20 to 30 gunmen broke into his brother's bedroom, shot him dead 'in cold blood' and stole his belongings."
And it was the US military!!
"I don't think [his death] was politically motivated," said Malek Khalifa, Mohammed Jamal's brother. But Khalifa's deep ties to al-Qaeda, coupled with his history of funding global terrorist operations, his operations in mining precious stones in Africa (a source of untraceable income), and the size of the 'gang' that murdered him, suggests otherwise. We suspect Khalifa was assassinated. "They stole everything — his computer, all of his things," said Khalifa's brother. Task Force 145 has a mandate to hunt down senior al-Qaeda operatives world wide, and is known to have operated in Pakistan to destroy Osama bin Laden's Black Guard. Also, the U.S. recently deployed naval assets to the region, as well as Task Force 145, in the hunt for al-Qaeda and Islamic Courts leaders fleeing Somalia.
This guy has a very long record as a terrorist-financier and all-around scumbag.
Good Show!!
HT: The Fourth Rail
$EIGHT POINT EIGHT MILLION!!
That's what DarthDoyle spent to remain in office. About $2.2 million for each of his next 4 years.
(This is what politicians refer to as "economic development.")
About 200% of what Green spent.
(This is what politicians refer to as "economic development.")
About 200% of what Green spent.
"Green Acres" to be History? It's About Time
GWB's boyzzz came up with an entirely defensible (and sensible) idea here. Let's see how long it takes for an Army of well-funded tax lawyers, CPA's and Idle Rich to scream.
The Bush administration yesterday proposed ending farm subsidies for an estimated 80,000 wealthy individuals as part of a broad plan that would close loopholes and cut traditional farm programs by $4.5 billion over the next 10 years.
...The Post found, for example, that wealthy commercial farmers were easily able to legally avoid the limits on government subsidy payments. The Johanns plan would save $1.5 billion over 10 years by eliminating subsidies to people with adjusted gross incomes of more than $200,000 -- income after subtracting farm expenses and certain deductions. Deputy Agriculture Secretary Charles F. Conner said that if a farmer is at that level "you're the richest guy in the county."
The administration also promised to tighten rules that have enabled distant relatives of a farmer or a friend in a far-off city to collect payments on the farmer's behalf while doing little or no work.
The plan would close a major loophole highlighted by The Post that in 2005 allowed corn farmers to receive $3.8 billion more than needed to ensure they got the government-guaranteed price. Farmers would no longer be able to collect these "loan deficiency payments" when prices are low and then sell later when prices rise.
Johanns also proposed changes in a program that since 2000 has enabled some landowners who do not farm to still collect $1.3 billion in "direct" farm payments. The Post detailed how some Texas homeowners were drawing these payments on back yards once used as rice fields and known as "cowboy starter kits." The new plan reduces the amount of land eligible for the direct payments after farmland is sold.
These programs are rackets, to say the least. They've been abused since Day One, and trust me, they won't go away easily. The people who take this money are NOT 'the farmer in the dell' with hardscrabble land and 5 underfed/overworked children. They are 3-piece suits and system-gamers--aided and abetted by CPAs and lawyers.
HT: Right Off the Shore
The Bush administration yesterday proposed ending farm subsidies for an estimated 80,000 wealthy individuals as part of a broad plan that would close loopholes and cut traditional farm programs by $4.5 billion over the next 10 years.
...The Post found, for example, that wealthy commercial farmers were easily able to legally avoid the limits on government subsidy payments. The Johanns plan would save $1.5 billion over 10 years by eliminating subsidies to people with adjusted gross incomes of more than $200,000 -- income after subtracting farm expenses and certain deductions. Deputy Agriculture Secretary Charles F. Conner said that if a farmer is at that level "you're the richest guy in the county."
The administration also promised to tighten rules that have enabled distant relatives of a farmer or a friend in a far-off city to collect payments on the farmer's behalf while doing little or no work.
The plan would close a major loophole highlighted by The Post that in 2005 allowed corn farmers to receive $3.8 billion more than needed to ensure they got the government-guaranteed price. Farmers would no longer be able to collect these "loan deficiency payments" when prices are low and then sell later when prices rise.
Johanns also proposed changes in a program that since 2000 has enabled some landowners who do not farm to still collect $1.3 billion in "direct" farm payments. The Post detailed how some Texas homeowners were drawing these payments on back yards once used as rice fields and known as "cowboy starter kits." The new plan reduces the amount of land eligible for the direct payments after farmland is sold.
These programs are rackets, to say the least. They've been abused since Day One, and trust me, they won't go away easily. The people who take this money are NOT 'the farmer in the dell' with hardscrabble land and 5 underfed/overworked children. They are 3-piece suits and system-gamers--aided and abetted by CPAs and lawyers.
HT: Right Off the Shore
DarthDoyle Gets Religion?
P-Mac observes that DarthDoyle (D-ESCR/Abortion) is now quoting Saints and Scripture to, ah, lend authority to his wild spending and taxing schemes.
We kinda like this quote from Scripture:
"I call heaven and earth to witness this day, that I have set before you life and death, blessing and cursing. Choose therefore life, that both thou and thy seed may live..."
(Deuteronomy 30:19)
The Darth version of the cite is evidently translated thus:
"I call heaven and earth to witness this day, that I have set before you taxes and regulation, both being blessings. Choose therefore taxes and regulation, that both thou and thy Government shall live..."
Probably something about the Hebrew not translating well into Greek, then Latin, then English.
You know, nuance.
We kinda like this quote from Scripture:
"I call heaven and earth to witness this day, that I have set before you life and death, blessing and cursing. Choose therefore life, that both thou and thy seed may live..."
(Deuteronomy 30:19)
The Darth version of the cite is evidently translated thus:
"I call heaven and earth to witness this day, that I have set before you taxes and regulation, both being blessings. Choose therefore taxes and regulation, that both thou and thy Government shall live..."
Probably something about the Hebrew not translating well into Greek, then Latin, then English.
You know, nuance.
YourGrannyNan Wants the Military--Just for Her!
Although it's not without precedent, YourGrannyNan is pushing the envelope harder than did Hastert.
The office of House Speaker Nancy Pelosi is pressing the Bush administration for routine access to military aircraft for domestic flights, such as trips back to her San Francisco district, according to sources familiar with the discussions.
Mrs. Pelosi’s request is not new for a speaker, who is second-in-line in presidential succession. A defense source said the speaker’s regular access to a military plane began after the September 11, 2001, attacks. Rep. J. Dennis Hastert, Illinois Republican, who was speaker at the time, started using U.S. Air Force planes for domestic travel to and from his district for security reasons. A former Hastert aide said the congressman did not use military planes for political trips or regularly transport his family.
The defense source said Mr. Hastert requested a plane with good communications so he could conduct legislative business. The military flights increased to the point the speaker used a military plane for many, if not all, flights to his Illinois district, the former aide said.
Sources said Mrs. Pelosi’s request goes beyond what Mr. Hastert received.
Obviously, the question is "What does 'going beyond' really mean?" If YourGrannyNan wants to fly her family around, that's over the line.
Source: the Washington Times, HT: Lakeshore.
The office of House Speaker Nancy Pelosi is pressing the Bush administration for routine access to military aircraft for domestic flights, such as trips back to her San Francisco district, according to sources familiar with the discussions.
Mrs. Pelosi’s request is not new for a speaker, who is second-in-line in presidential succession. A defense source said the speaker’s regular access to a military plane began after the September 11, 2001, attacks. Rep. J. Dennis Hastert, Illinois Republican, who was speaker at the time, started using U.S. Air Force planes for domestic travel to and from his district for security reasons. A former Hastert aide said the congressman did not use military planes for political trips or regularly transport his family.
The defense source said Mr. Hastert requested a plane with good communications so he could conduct legislative business. The military flights increased to the point the speaker used a military plane for many, if not all, flights to his Illinois district, the former aide said.
Sources said Mrs. Pelosi’s request goes beyond what Mr. Hastert received.
Obviously, the question is "What does 'going beyond' really mean?" If YourGrannyNan wants to fly her family around, that's over the line.
Source: the Washington Times, HT: Lakeshore.
Mortgages Gone Bad--From "S&D" to "Nuclear Waste"
Some interesting stuff from an investments professional--but it's not cheery stuff.
Quoting from an industry newsletter written by an admitted bear, he posts:
Turning to the subprime industry, once again I heard from my friend who has been staggeringly accurate. He continues to feel that things are about to really get worse. In an email to me, he wrote: "Scratch and dent loans are killing everybody. Bids that were 92 or 93 are now low to mid-80s. It is a bloodbath, and is pressuring even strong companies to buckle. NO ONE is making any money in the market right now. We are at a point of no return for many. The next two weeks will be wild."
Another industry insider comments on the above:
“Scratch and Dent” is a real industry term. The approximate meaning is “loan with incurable defect.”
...[X's] informant is saying that scratch & dent is getting nuclear waste bids. This implies that nuclear waste is probably heading for “no bid.” [Nuclear Waste is the term covering loans in foreclosure, or where the owner is bankrupt.]
How bad is it? We don't know yet.
One reason it’s so hard to tell at the moment how bad this might get is that it’s hard to tell how many more “pending” repurchases we have out there. ...The current one seems to be more like “close the gates of mercy, shoot the wounded, and sink the lifeboats.” That does imply—as JPMorgan also implies—that the Big Dogs have more cooties on the balance sheet than they’re prepared to tolerate. Looks like total war to me.
A word to the wise.
Quoting from an industry newsletter written by an admitted bear, he posts:
Turning to the subprime industry, once again I heard from my friend who has been staggeringly accurate. He continues to feel that things are about to really get worse. In an email to me, he wrote: "Scratch and dent loans are killing everybody. Bids that were 92 or 93 are now low to mid-80s. It is a bloodbath, and is pressuring even strong companies to buckle. NO ONE is making any money in the market right now. We are at a point of no return for many. The next two weeks will be wild."
Another industry insider comments on the above:
“Scratch and Dent” is a real industry term. The approximate meaning is “loan with incurable defect.”
...[X's] informant is saying that scratch & dent is getting nuclear waste bids. This implies that nuclear waste is probably heading for “no bid.” [Nuclear Waste is the term covering loans in foreclosure, or where the owner is bankrupt.]
How bad is it? We don't know yet.
One reason it’s so hard to tell at the moment how bad this might get is that it’s hard to tell how many more “pending” repurchases we have out there. ...The current one seems to be more like “close the gates of mercy, shoot the wounded, and sink the lifeboats.” That does imply—as JPMorgan also implies—that the Big Dogs have more cooties on the balance sheet than they’re prepared to tolerate. Looks like total war to me.
A word to the wise.
BlameBush Strikes Again
This guy is a scream. In discussion of the 'peace protest' in DC over the weekend, he observes:
...it was in that spirit that thousands of peace activists converged on the nation’s capitol last weekend in what future poets will one day describe as an "overflowing septic tank of love". In contrast, about three counter-protesters showed up to antagonize the crowd by making disparaging remarks about the beautiful and talented Jane Fonda.
...The nimble-footed protester had already vanished in a cloud of marijuana smoke and patchouli, perhaps off to graffiti the Washington Monument in the hopes of beefing up his arrest record for a future teaching job at Berkeley.
Those credentials would serve him well at UW-Madistan, too...
...it was in that spirit that thousands of peace activists converged on the nation’s capitol last weekend in what future poets will one day describe as an "overflowing septic tank of love". In contrast, about three counter-protesters showed up to antagonize the crowd by making disparaging remarks about the beautiful and talented Jane Fonda.
...The nimble-footed protester had already vanished in a cloud of marijuana smoke and patchouli, perhaps off to graffiti the Washington Monument in the hopes of beefing up his arrest record for a future teaching job at Berkeley.
Those credentials would serve him well at UW-Madistan, too...
Pizza Man Trial: Test of Wisconsin Constitution?
A pizza deliveryman shot two would-be robbers in Milwaukee. The DA's office agrees that the shootings were justified (there were no fatalities) but will try the pizza man for carrying a concealed weapon, which is against the law in Wisconsin.
According to the criminal complaint, Vegas, of Cudahy, was making a delivery in the 2800 block of N. 22nd St. on the evening of Jan. 4 for Mona Lisa Pizza, 4831 W. North Ave. As he got out of his car, he was approached by an armed assailant. Vegas then reached into his car's passenger seat, got his .32 semi-automatic pistol and shot his assailant, the complaint says; he then waited for police.
The complaint says the suspect admitted trying to rob Vegas, who prosecutors then determined was justified in the shooting. But because Vegas' gun had been on "the front passenger seat beside the pizzas," it met the definition of a concealed weapon.
But here's a case where the law may be un-Constitutional. The Wisconsin constitution allows possession of a weapon for "any lawful purpose," and a Milwaukee store-owner was found NOT guilty of violating the law when he used a concealed weapon to shoot robbers a few years ago.
The pizza man may well argue that like the store-owner, his on-the-job circumstances were so dangerous that the "lawful purpose" of self-defense compelled him to carry a weapon.
When DarthDoyle (D-ESCR/Abortion) vetoed Concealed Carry licensing, he risked creating a patchwork of gray-area "lawful purposes" which would be adjudicated by the Wisconsin Supremes. Last time around, Screechin'Shirley's Court made it clear that they would run a "Mommy, May I?" test for self-defense--the worst possible outcome for law enforcement and law-abiding citizens.
It will cost this pizza man a considerable sum to defend his right to live and work in Milwaukee. Let's hope that it will NOT cost Milwaukee residents the right to defend themselves, too.
MUCH more useful reference-stuff at Jessica's entry.
According to the criminal complaint, Vegas, of Cudahy, was making a delivery in the 2800 block of N. 22nd St. on the evening of Jan. 4 for Mona Lisa Pizza, 4831 W. North Ave. As he got out of his car, he was approached by an armed assailant. Vegas then reached into his car's passenger seat, got his .32 semi-automatic pistol and shot his assailant, the complaint says; he then waited for police.
The complaint says the suspect admitted trying to rob Vegas, who prosecutors then determined was justified in the shooting. But because Vegas' gun had been on "the front passenger seat beside the pizzas," it met the definition of a concealed weapon.
But here's a case where the law may be un-Constitutional. The Wisconsin constitution allows possession of a weapon for "any lawful purpose," and a Milwaukee store-owner was found NOT guilty of violating the law when he used a concealed weapon to shoot robbers a few years ago.
The pizza man may well argue that like the store-owner, his on-the-job circumstances were so dangerous that the "lawful purpose" of self-defense compelled him to carry a weapon.
When DarthDoyle (D-ESCR/Abortion) vetoed Concealed Carry licensing, he risked creating a patchwork of gray-area "lawful purposes" which would be adjudicated by the Wisconsin Supremes. Last time around, Screechin'Shirley's Court made it clear that they would run a "Mommy, May I?" test for self-defense--the worst possible outcome for law enforcement and law-abiding citizens.
It will cost this pizza man a considerable sum to defend his right to live and work in Milwaukee. Let's hope that it will NOT cost Milwaukee residents the right to defend themselves, too.
MUCH more useful reference-stuff at Jessica's entry.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)