Thursday, July 19, 2007

Bp. Morlino (Madison) on the Motu Proprio

The Bishop of Madison wrote on the recent Motu Proprio allowing the laity to request the celebration of the Joannine Use (Missal of 1962) Mass.

I do wish to make three very important points...

In the first place, the more widespread use of the Missal of Blessed Pope John XXIII should in no way cause further disunity within our diocesan Church or the Church in the United States. As I have said repeatedly, everything that we do at the liturgy and everything that we don't do at the liturgy teaches something. The liturgy is meant to embody and teach the authentic faith of the Catholic Church.

...Because these various usages of the Roman Rite embody the same faith, there should be no disunity caused by this particular diversity. The only way in which division or disunity might be deepened through the more widespread use of the Missal of Blessed Pope John XXIII would be if the faith of the Church, embodied by more recent usages, was somehow misunderstood, and in certain cases this has been the reality and I have spoken to this situation before, which brings me to the second point.

...It is a complete misunderstanding of the liturgical renewal according to the Second Vatican Council and the Missal of Pope Paul VI to see this post-Vatican II usage as, in any way, shape, or form, a rejection of the pre-Vatican II usage.

What was sacred and brought many people to holiness for so many years cannot all of a sudden be justifiably forbidden or even seen as harmful.

...We still need to be healed in our Church of the unfortunate effects of the discontinuity hermeneutic which sees the life of the Church prior to Vatican II as somehow mistaken and regrettable, and the post-Vatican II approaches, whatever they may have been, as the reliable corrective. Pope Benedict makes very clear that the liturgical rites after the council were sometimes mistakenly construed as inviting or even requiring creativity, and he indicates that this has caused certain "deformations" in the way liturgy is actually celebrated in certain venues.

Thirdly, you are probably aware that the Diocese of Madison is the only diocese in the State of Wisconsin where I, as bishop, still have never permitted the celebration of Mass according to the Missal of Blessed Pope John XXIII.

I have done so not because of any distaste whatsoever for that particular usage.

My reason for not permitting the celebration of Mass according to this Missal of Blessed Pope John XXIII in the Diocese of Madison has simply been that a certain catechetical support is necessary because those who are attached to this form of celebration for many years have often forgotten or gotten "rusty" with regard to what a full and active and fruitful participation would involve...

As a sign of my obedience to the Holy Father I do intend to celebrate Mass according to the Missal of Blessed John XXIII on occasion as soon as this is feasible. I say "as soon as this is feasible" because I do not have certain of the vestments that are necessary for the bishop to celebrate according to this particular usage, nor have I ever done so as a bishop.

Thus, it will be necessary for me to educate myself in these matters and obtain the proper vestments. It will also be necessary to see which of our priests might be in a position to celebrate Mass according to this usage. The document of Pope Benedict makes clear that if the priest is not trained to do so, that he should not attempt to do so without such training.

And then there will be the matter of training a limited number of servers who are alert liturgically and who know some Latin.

...I do urge those who are attracted to worship according to the Missal of Blessed Pope John XXIII to express yourselves to me and to your pastors in the days ahead so that we can do our very best to serve you in a reasonable amount of time as we make the necessary preparations.

An altogether reasonable reaction and a VERY compliant response.

Ut Unam Sint

Yah, it's Latin.

(That they may be one..)

The KC Catholic has a lot of fun with those church-sign-lettering thingies you get on the 'net.

This is an example.

People who Sexually Molest Children

Want to know who they are?

Easy.

A forthcoming study by the Federal Bureau of Prisons will point toward a "startlingly high" correlation between child pornography and the sexual abuse of children, the New York Times reports. In other words, the people who enjoy looking at sexual images involving children are likely to be the same people who molest children.

Once that study is released, you can expect all the usual "well, but...." crap from 1) porn-makers and their allies (see ACLU in the dictionary); 2) "First-Amendment" defenders who confuse 'free speech' with porn; and 3) porn-consumers who are offended by the study's results, or the pshrinks who are concerned that we don't mis-understand these poor folks.

For example:

"The results could have tremendous implications for community safety and for individual liberties," said Dr. Fred Berlin, founder of the Johns Hopkins Sexual Disorders Clinic. "If people we thought were not dangerous are more so, then we need to know that and we should treat them that way. But if we’re wrong, then their liberties aren’t going to be fairly addressed."

Right-o!! Nothing like the "liberty" to fuel up before assaulting a 6-year-old.

HT: CWN

On Building Inspectors

The Mattress Police encounters a Building Inspector.

If you think I.R.S. agents are mean, you should try getting a building inspection some time.

You know what happens to someone who is too much of a jerkwad to work for the I.R.S.? He gets fired and fed to a rabid crocodile, which is then mated with that bitch from The Weakest Link, and then their unholy offspring is raised by hyenas until it's old enough to become a building inspector. That's what happens.

Hmmmnnnn....

And in regards the required "Continuity Test,"

No longer was he the construction expert barking to the naive amateur about Special Equipment. Suddenly I was the Jedi Master of the Magical Tampon Flashlight and he was the guy who was desperate to conceal the fact that he had no f---ing clue what a continuity test was. I could have clipped the alligator clip to his nose and shoved the prong up his ass and called it continuity. And I'm willing to bet good money the light would have gone on, because that guy had excellent continuity between his head and his ass.

We've encountered Pompous Ass inspectors, too. But never quite as bad as the MP's pal.

Myths and Realities on Taxes and Population

The Folkbum folk(s) have apparently decided that P-Mac will be a perma-target. Fred Thompson gets the same treatment from both Dems and Pubbies; the consensus is that the "target" designation is awarded to folks who are feared.

While P-Mac never struck me as "fearsome," I've also never engaged him in combat.

But when a poster is irrational, it can be fun to joust a bit.

Here, Folkie attempts to demonstrate that Scott Walker's tax freeze is somehow connected to a reduction in Milwaukee County's population, using P-Mac as a foil:

Then McIlheran goes on to show that the bustling metropolis of Mequon is looking at another tax freeze and links to the U.S. Census Bureau's website regarding that fine city to show that people want to move there. That made me wonder, how did Milwaukee County size up while under Scott "I should have been governor" Walker. The results weren't as pretty, with a loss of 25,000 people.

In the real world, tax "freezes" have little or nothing to do with the desirability of a home's location, nor with population gains and losses. Tax freezes have to do with the perception (and often, the reality) that there's too much spendin' goin' on out there--and too much taxing to support the sailor's habit.

REAL people often purchase a "first house" in the City of Milwaukee and have a family. As that family grows, the 'city house' becomes less accomodating to the family; or the investment required to install 21st century amenities (air, cable, dishwashers, etc.) becomes problematic; or the yard or garage is too small, or the school system is not what they'd like it to be.

Sometimes, REAL people get a job in a distant suburb (like Germantown, Sussex, or Pewaukee) and decide that reducing commute-time/expense (in combination to the other items above) is worth a move out of the County.

Conversely, REAL people are moving into the City of Milwaukee's river-front apartment/condo complexes at a rapid rate. These are (likely) people who do not have a need for yard-space, or who find that the amenities provided at the price represent a value which cannot be matched in a detached suburban home. (These people pay large tax dollars relative to the value of the property, by the way.)

Summarily, it ain't the taxes which drive these decisions, if all other things are equal. Anyone who thinks so is not living in the real world.

Why did Milwaukee County lose population? Who knows?

But it is not simply "taxes."

Wolf-Shooting Restrictions

Didn't know this:

Currently Federal Rule 10-J allows commercially licensed OUTFITTERS only to shoot wolves that attacking their horses, we non-outfitter licensed horsemen must simply sit and watch the wolves eat our horses.

The excerpted email concerns a USFish and Wildlife Service meeting to be held in Idaho discussing changing the cited rule to allow NON-'outfitter' folks to shoot predators.

And those non-outfitters include more than horse-owners. Your friendly neighborhood wolf is ALSO more valuable to USFWS than your pooch.

HT: Clay Cramer

The UAW Faces Health-Care Cost, Maybe

Apparently, the current GM/UAW negotiations are hung up over retiree-health-care cost questions.

Unfortunately for many retired auto workers, the golden goose has been strangled to death and auto companies can no longer afford the gold-plated “free” lifetime health care benefits they were promised.

And now the day of reckoning that everyone knew was coming - except maybe the car companies and the unions who negotiated this and other unsustainable benefits - is at hand. And it’s not going to be pretty, as current workers are likely going to be forced to accept an agreement to cut the benefits of those who came before them.

The reason? Simple math. There are not more retirees than there are workers, and neither the car companies nor the workers can fit the bill any longer, especially with legacy costs adding anywhere between $1,000 to $1,500 for each vehicle.

The union says it won’t cave on the issue of health care any more than it already has, but in reality if nothing is done then the car manufacturers will eventually go the route of many air carriers and parts suppliers and simply declare bankruptcy, allowing them to shed the crippling costs of their pensions, and more worrisome for former workers, drastically scale back, or totally abandon, their retiree health care payments. Of course, the US taxpayer, through programs like the PBGC and Medicaid would left holding the bag for the costs.

Hmmmmmmmm.

HT: Ankle-Biting Pundits

Use Yahoo/SBC Email? What a Load of...

Over the last few weeks, Yahoo!! server-side email has been more and more glitchy.

Recently, that "glitchiness" has included simply freezing IE.

It's apparently Yahoo's Need for Revenues; their recently-introduced partial-screen advertisements are causing the problems.

Don't call customer service. It's night-time over there.

Another $32MM Down the State IT Hole

Here we go again.

A $32.3 million overhaul of the state's computer system that handles Medicaid health claims for the poor will be delayed by at least 10 months, a state health department official said.

The lagging project means taxpayers could be missing out on administrative cost savings from the new system, which is supposed to replace the 30-year-old current model. It also opens the possibility that Wisconsin might run afoul of a federal deadline to change the way some Medicaid data is reported.

Different contractor, same ....ah....results.

The state's contractor, EDS Corp., of Plano, Texas, missed its May deadline and is now aiming for a March 2008 target date, said health department spokeswoman Stephanie Marquis.

Oh, yeah, there's a running total of State of Wisconsin IT down-the-dumper-dollars:

The Wisconsin State Journal reported in March that the state has spent more than $170 million in state and federal money on other troubled computer projects designed to register voters, process unemployment benefits and handle payroll and benefits for university employees. A blistering state audit released the following month also documented widespread mismanagement on information technology.

As we've said before, the State's IT systems are "fiefdoms." DOT has one, DOA has another, the UW has its own--and God help the legislator, Governor, or taxpayer who gets in there and asks common-sense questions.

So You Want Government Health Coverage?

Sure.

Besides the blatant lying about the "number of un-insured" (the number is actually about 10 million nationally who 1) are US citizens and are 2) actually unable to afford health insurance)...

And the utterly irrational "plan" of the Wisconsin Democratic proposal...

There's this "database" problem.

Ives is one of about 138,000 seniors nationwide who are stuck in bureaucratic gridlock as Medicare Part D premiums are erroneously deducted from their Social Security checks. An additional 141,000 owe money, and can't get the money to be deducted from their checks.

The problem stems from a longstanding computer glitch between the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services and the Social Security Administration

No--this specific "glitch" is not the one which will occur when the State of Wisconsin (or the Feds) implement a Hillarycare System.

But I'll be willing to take large-denomination wagers that there will be at least ONE "database glitch" which will be excruciating for lots of people.

Takers?

Wednesday, July 18, 2007

National "Catholic" Reporter Demographic

This is far, far worse than the demographics of the Milwaukee JS:

...Let me share with you a little more about NCR readers, which I suspect will surprise many of you. The average age of an NCR reader is about 68. This average has been on a continual rise since the late '60s, when the average age was about 36.

(Quoted from "The Editor's Desk" by Gerald Augustus/Cafeteria Is Closed)

The NCR is the flagship of the Lefties of the American Catholic Church--it's the 'Catholic' version of the NYTimes, mutatis mutandis.

And the revelation above is not really a surprise. Some will argue that this is related to the recent survey demonstrating that 'the yout' do not read newspapers. I doubt it. Even the Milwaukee JS has better demographics than the above.

What is REALLY the case here is the even more remarkable renaissance of Tradition and its values, which are eschewed regularly and vigorously by the NCR. Even its own writer, John Allen, sees this.

So one wonders why any Catholic parish would waste its money advertising in the NCR's "Help Wanted" section--I mean, what are you going to do when the youngest applicant for your Church Musician position is 76?

The Lawyer on Lawyers

St. Thomas More, in his work Utopia:

They have very few laws because very few are needed for persons so educated. The chief fault they find with other peoples is that almost innumerable books of laws and commentaries are not sufficient. They themselves think it most unfair that any group of men should be bound by laws which are either too numerous to be read through or too obscure to be understood by anyone.

Moreover, they absolutely banish from their country all lawyers, who cleverly manipulate cases and cunningly argue legal points. They consider it a good thing that every man should plead his own cause and say the same to the judge as he would tell his counsel. Thus there is less ambiguity and the truth is more easily elicited when a man, uncoached in deception by a lawyer, conducts his own case and the judge skillfully weighs each statement and helps untu­tored minds to defeat the false accusations of the crafty. To secure these advantages in other countries is difficult, owing to the immense mass of extremely complicated laws.

...for all three of you barristers who read this--it's entirely possible that the foregoing was penned tongue-in-cheek.

HT: Laudator Temporis Actae

Tyranny from the Greenies

Not here...yet.

But in England, they're rather blatant about it.

...the British group The Optimum Population Trust....is demanding that parents in the United Kingdom limit family size. If they won’t do so voluntarily, the organization says coercive measures will be necessary

The Optimum Population Trust’s hysteria is occasioned by a recent blip in British child-bearing, which rose from 1.8 children per woman in 2005 to 1.87 in 2006. Demographers attribute the increase to more career women having children later in life.

This is still far below the post-World War II high for Britain, 2.93 in 1964. More significantly, it’s well below replacement level of 2.11. Even if the current rate is maintained, the United Kingdom will still see its population decline in every generation, absent massive immigration.

“The Optimum Population Trust is composed of radical environmentalists,” [Allen] Carlson charges. “They want the British to commit demographic suicide to reduce the global consumption of resources and set an example to the Third World. The group has actually calculated that the average British child born today will have the ‘environmental impact’ of 620 round-trip trans-Atlantic flights in the course of his or her lifetime.”

Yah...and the "third world" is really likely to follow the example of the Brits. (/sarcasm)

Source: World Congress of Families

Cdl. Mahony Points the Finger

Now that the spectre of testifying at a trial is removed from Cdl. Mahony's horizon, he's free to cast blame and point fingers.

Weinkopf: What about the charge that the problem is a lack of discipline and orthodoxy in the seminaries?

Mahony: Well, first of all that's one of the things that we still are studying. As you know, the bishops are conducting a study of causes.... In our case, many of the priests came out of the "good old days" -- Latin-only, cassocks-only.... Most of our cases did not come out of post-Vatican II, they came out of pre-Vatican II.

(Weinkopf is the editorial-page editor of the Los Angeles Daily News.)

The word "homosexual" does NOT appear in the linked interview.

The Cardinal's timeline is likely correct. However, he's careful not to deal with the real problem.

That's his history, and he's sticking to it.

But it's not just Cdl. Mahony's story. Here we find a similar "thought:"

We learn from The Reverend Susan Brooks Thistlethwaite (I'm not making it up, that's her name) of the United Church of Christ (one of the one zillion, one hundred and thirty million, four hundred and twenty five and one half point two six Protestant denominations...give or take):

To me, the symbol of the Latin Mass being reintroduced in this time when the struggle to stop child sexual abuse in the Catholic Church is still going on is very instructive. The Latin Mass was a product of a reactionary time in the Catholic Church where it rejected many very necessary reforms and consolidated its power in the hierarchy. Today the re-introduction of the Latin Mass signals to me that far from becoming open to the kinds of changes needed to protect children from abuse, the Catholic Church is once again circling the wagons, rejecting necessary reforms and consolidating its power in the hierarchy.

HT: CWN, and the Lady in the Pew

Prevent Gun Violence

Here's how Mayor Tommy will handle the situation.

If Tommy were AlGore, he'd own the franchise...

(HT: John Lott.)

Coming Soon: Offshore Tobacco Retailers

For the adventurous entrepreneur, the Democrat Congress opens a new door.

The Democrat controlled Congress has sought an extra $35-billion to $50-billion for the state children's health insurance program. The program distributes payments to the states to help buy coverage for kids not poor enough for Medicaid.

Cigarettes, which accounted for more than 95 percent of tobacco tax collections last year, are the main focus of the bill. Federal taxes on a pack would jump from 39 cents to $1.
But the legislation has dragged cigars along for the ride. The industry operates under a 4.8 cents-per-cigar tax cap.


Under the proposed bill, taxes on "large cigars," a category that includes all but the tiny cigars sold in 20 packs like cigarettes, would rise to 53 percent.

A U.S. Senate version of the bill under consideration today in the Finance Committee sets the maximum tax per cigar at $10.

So the Feds will add 61 cents/pack in costs, and the Wisconsin Wizards (Senate) would add another $1.00 or so.

All of a sudden, there's a marketplace for another Kennedy family-type business! A couple of boats, a few trucks, and voila! Profit potential in excess of $5 million/year in Wisconsin alone!

HT: Captain's Quarters

What's Wrong with Fred? His Wife!

Susan Estrich complains that Fred Thompson married a younger woman.

What does it say that he'd rather be with someone who wasn't even alive when JFK was shot, or at least was too young to remember where she was? What does it say that he doesn't care that she doesn't remember the songs and the history and the fears we grew up with?

Estrich is a "go-to" feminist for the MSM, and her concerns are that a candidate's wife didn't faint at a Beatles concert? Or was not alive when Kennedy was shot?

THIS is important? Germane?

HT: Betsy

Tuesday, July 17, 2007

Education: How Bad IS It?

T Berres delivers news which is not really news for most of us.

The record of public education in Wisconsin is impressive relative to the national average.

...The problem, however, is that the current national average grossly underestimates the potential performance of American students. The difference between the relative and absolute performance of a school system is illustrated by the new Cato Index of Education Market Performance; Wisconsin has the highest score of any state on this index but with an absolute score of 26 on a 100 point scale. Professor Caroline Hoxby of Harvard has estimated that the average productivity of American schools declined by around 55% (based on math tests for nine-year-olds) or 73% (based on reading tests for seventeen-year-olds) between the 1970–1971 and 1998–1999 school years. The average seventeen-year-old in the 1970–1971 school year had a score that fewer than 5% of American seventeen-year-olds now attain.

Someplace around here there's an article from a Wall Street Journal of about 20 years ago. That article reprinted a graduation-test for grade-schoolers in the early 1800's--which test would force most of today's HS juniors to start HS all over again.

The Traddies and the Motu Proprio

David Alexander mentions the 'professional ululator-class': the "traddies" who now insist that there should be dozens of Old Rite Masses offered every Sunday in every Diocese in the land.

...These malcontents can be found in blogs and their comments boxes throughout the Catholic blogosphere. To read some of the whining going on, they genuinely expect every diocese in the known world to completely arrange their schedules and priestly resources, in the space of two months, on the possibility that enough of them will grace with their presence, a location other than their home parish. Oh, and that they'll stop complaining.

Actually, David, they won't stop complaining.

They'll talk about the "requirement" for three steps leading to the altar, the requirement for a Communion rail, the requirement that there be a suitable (read: loft) position for the choir...

It goes on and on....

The "Jewish Question" in the Tridentine Rite

Arguably the best essay on the faux-problem raised by Boston College.

...If Catholicism were Judaism, official Catholicism would be neither Orthodox nor Reform. It would be Conservative. (Like all analogies, this one will eventually break down, but I trust it’s sturdy enough to take me from here to where I’m going.)

I mean that the Roman curia and most bishops since Vatican II are committed to the preservation of tradition but also to the delicate business of adapting that tradition to contemporary contexts.

...In my experience, Catholics who have an affinity for the particularly Judaic character of their Christian faith are more likely to be drawn to the Tridentine Mass than are Catholics for whom Judaism is a category on the other side of a boundary they would consider it bad manners to try to cross.

(Which explains the horror expressed at praying 'for the conversion of the Jews.')

...Protestants were correct that the Mass, in its aspect as a sacrifice, could not be fully understood outside the framework of pre-rabbinic Judaism.

The author gets to this line of thought via a short meditation on the affirmation of 'the old things.'

An understanding of history is critical to understanding the present.

GWB's Iraq Policy

Dreher highlights a quote from GWB taken from an interview by David Brooks in the NYTimes:

"It's more of a theological perspective. I do believe there is an Almighty, and I believe a gift of that Almighty to all is freedom. And I will tell you that is a principle that no one can convince me that doesn’t exist."

Bush said this to explain why he has not lost his optimism about the (political) situation in Iraq.

While Dreher's column then wanders off-topic a bit, this quote from Andrew Sullivan in the essay is pertinent:

There is a dstinction between theology and politics, a distinction between theory and practice: a distinction at the core of the very meaning of conservatism.

Sullivan also promptly meanders away from the core of the thought above.

The gift of the Almighty was, accurately, free will, not "freedom." Free Will does not presuppose a political environment of any sort, nor is its exercise dependent on ANY political system. While one can strenuously and correctly argue that a democracy of some sort is a Good Government for exercising Free Will, it is also arguably true that an enlightened monarchy is sufficient for that purpose (not that there are many of them around these days.)

The difference between "freedom" and Free Will is substantial. One can only hope that GWB was misquoted.

P-Mac's New Clothes

McIlheran's now posting on a spiffy new site which includes a comments section.

He told No Runny Eggs about it.

No, you can't get there from the old site. No, there's no notification on the old site.

Still worth the read, though.

Monday, July 16, 2007

DC to Appeal Parker, File w/SCOTUS by 9/7

Here we go, folks!

Local government officials in Washington, D.C., announced Monday they will appeal to the Supreme Court in a major test case on the meaning of the Second Amendment. The key issue in the coming petition will be whether the Amendment protects an individual right to have guns in one's home -- an issue on which there is now a clear conflict among federal Circuit Courts. The city will be defending the constitutionality of a local handgun control law that is regarded as the strictest in the nation.

The petition would have been due Aug. 7, but city officials said Monday that they would ask Chief Justice John G. Roberts, Jr., for a 30-day extension of time to file the case. Mayor Adrian M. Fenty and city Attorney General Linda Singer disclosed the appeal plan at a press conference, along with local Police Chief Cathy Lanier. (A news release announcing the action can be found here ) The Mayor said: "We have made the determination that this law can and should be defended and we are willing to take our case to the highest court in the land to protect the city's residents. Our handgun law has saved countless lives -- keeping guns out of the hands of those who would hurt others or themselves.

"The D.C. Circuit Court ruled on March 9 that the Second Amendment does guarantee an individual right to possess a gun -- at least within one's own home. The ruling was the first by a federal appeals court to strike down a gun control law based on that view of the Amendment's reach. The case is Parker, et al., v. District of Columbia (Circuit docket 04-7041). On May 8, the Circuit Court refused by a 6-4 vote to rehear the case en banc. The mandate is scheduled to be issued Aug. 7, but will be withheld after the city files its Supreme Court petition. Thus, the existing gun law would remain in effect temporarily.

In an earlier filling in the D.C. Circuit, city officials said their appeal to the Supreme Court would present some variation of these questions: "(1) whether the panel majority's decision conflicts with the Supreme Court's decision in United States v. Miller, 307 U.S. 174 (1939), as Judge [Karen LeCraft] Henderson concluded in dissenting from the panel majority's decision; (2) whether the Second Amendment protects firearms possession or use that is not associated with service in a State militia; (3) whether the Amendment applies differently to the District because of its constitutional status, as Judge Henderson also concluded; and (4) whether the challenged laws represent reasonable regulation of whatever rights the Amendment protects." The city noted that the panel had acknowledged that its ruling conflicts with decisions "of most other federal courts of appeals, many State courts, and the highest local court in this jurisdiction, the District of Columbia Court of Appeals."

The Circuit Court majority found that one of the six Washington residents who filed the challenge to the local gun control law had a right to bring the lawsuit. That individual is Dick Anthony Heller, a special police officer who works at the Federal Judicial Center (home of the Administrative Office of U.S. Courts) near Capitol Hill in Washington. He is licensed to carry a handgun on his job, but he applied for permission to have a pistol in his home; he was denied a license under the local law. Heller has said in court papers that he lives in a high-crime neighborhood in the city.

Heller, according to the Circuit Court, had standing to sue to challenge the gun registration provisions of the local law, as well as the clause that bars anyone from carrying a pistol without a license and a provision requiring all owners of licensed guns to keep them disassembled or with a trigger lock engaged when not in use.

The D.C. law has been in effect for nearly 31 years -- since September 1976. The lawsuit to strike it down was filed in February 2003.

Appealing Parker is very dicey for DC; many commentators suggest that the case could be a genuine landmark if SCOTUS affirms the 2nd Circuit's decision in whole. While it would not technically "overturn" Miller, it would lay out clear definitions of the 2nd's language. Although the precis given in the first paragraph states that Parker is about "keeping guns in one's home," the enumerated questions in the 4th graf of the article suggest that the case is far more important than "house-kept weapons."

It would also have an effect in Wisconsin, but for Screechin'Shirley's dogged insistence on her personal 'federalism.'

The Anti-Catholics--and Those Who Regret It

As Kevin points out obliquely, there's more than a little anti-Catholicism goin' around. The last installment was delivered when Pope Benedict XVI had the temerity to declare that Catholicism is the true religion, and that other religions, while having some very positive elements, were not precisely "churches" by definition.

But B-16's declaration did not (yet) draw the "highbrow" nastiness which the partial-birth abortion decision of the Supreme Court did.

The neo-Blanshardite reaction to the Supreme Court’s partial-birth abortion ruling was led by former University of Chicago Provost Geoff Stone, who in condemning the decision as upholding what he ludicrously regarded as a an imposition of the Catholic religion pointedly called attention to the fact that the five justices forming the majority are members of the Catholic Church, and the Philadelphia Inquirer, which published a despicable cartoon depicting the five wearing the mitres of Catholic bishops.

(The essay reminds us that Blanshard founded the organization now known as "Americans United for Separation of Church & State, headed by Barry Lynn.)

Those who don't have a problem with anti-Catholicism are mentioned.

No condemnations of the rank anti-Catholicism on display were forthcoming from the American Civil Liberties Union, People for the American Way, or Americans United for Separation of Church and State. Nor was anything heard from the mainline Protestant denominations that are regarded by many Catholic liberals as Catholicism’s true friends and ecumenical conversation partners. Leaders of the Presbyterian Church U.S.A., the Episcopal Church, the United Methodist Church, the United Church of Christ, etc. were silent.

Then there are those who are NOT "mainstream" and who DID object:

...the leaders of the Evangelical movement. And they came with a powerful and, indeed, remarkable statement. Led by Chuck Colson, many of the most influential leaders of contemporary Evangelicalism joined together to condemn anti-Catholicism. And they did not stop there. They went on to acknowledge and express remorse for the involvement of American Evangelicals in anti-Catholic prejudice in the past.

More at the link. And, by the way, Thanks!! Chuck!

The Cynic's "Con Law in One Easy Lesson"

Via Arms and the Law, a credible (?) humorous (?) (pick one) take on Constitutional Lawyering:

"First, draw the desired curve. Then, plot the data. If time permits, do the experiment."

The author of the piece (found here) is a Con Law prof. He continues:

I used it as a parable about how not to do constitutional interpretation -- and as a description of how some interpreters (courts, law professors, certainly many first year law students) seem actually to do Constitutional Law, at least from time to time: Pick the desired result, choose an interpretive methodology to match, and then, time permitting, do some research to find supporting evidence.

Hell, if that's all it takes, why spend 3 years paying folks like Esenberg?

Thinking His Way to Jail

This one raises a lot of questions. Looks like the prosecutors disagree with the shrink, but in order to "fix" the shrink's action, the prosecutors are pushing an envelope.

When Michael Monyelle stands trial next month, prosecutors aim to show that he is among the state's most dangerous sexual predators and should be committed - perhaps for the rest of his life - for treatment as a "sexually violent person."

But what landed Monyelle in hot water wasn't anything he did.

It was what he thought.

He told his parole agent that he was having deviant thoughts about children, and his disclosures are being used against him by prosecutors who contend he is apt to act on his thoughts.

The guy has a past:

...consensual sexual contact with two underage girls when he was 19 and 20, and [sexual contact] with a 9-year-old boy when he was 16

...for which he spent time in prison. He was released, with supervision.

Linda Morrison, executive director of the Wisconsin Coalition Against Sexual Assault, termed the decision to seek a commitment under such circumstances "a judgment call."

"These cases are very complicated," Morrison said. "You've got to start somewhere to look for markers that are indicators of possible future violence.

"The judgment here is that the thoughts he is expressing are indicating what is in his head and what could lead to violence."

OK.

At the same time, Monyelle did not 'do the crime:'

"I see kids on the street and I look and I have (deviant) thoughts. But I keep on going to where I was going."

The first question, of course, is 'if this guy is a danger, why was he released?'

...court records indicate that a psychologist retained by the defense, Luis Rosell, has concluded that Monyelle "does not pose a serious risk for sexual violence" and can be safely returned to Waukesha on parole...

The second question is 'whether incarceration for thoughts?'

Monyelle also skipped a number of scheduled meetings with his parole officer, which presumably contributed to the case for prosecuting.

Hmmmm.

Sunday, July 15, 2007

The Illegals--A View from Tennessee

Here's an article with a perspective which is rare--and non-polemic.

Fortunately, no "crimes" except those of the owner(s) of "Big Billy's" in Nashville.

Hildebeeste's "Fairness Doctrine"

There's some confusion over the "fairness doctrine" yammering going on.

In general terms, bringing back the "fairness doctrine" is a differently-angled "campaign finance reform" tactic; it's meant, at root, to ensure the continuation of the Party In Government.

Some characterize the "fairness doctrine" as a Liberal vs. Conservative thing. That's not accurate. It has to do with jamming "mainstream" into the eardrums of whomever listens.

The Hildebeeste's conversation with Silky Pony should make that clear. Scroll down on this site and read the transcript/watch the video.

More on The Hildebeeste's campaign to squash Free Speech can be found here.

Saturday, July 14, 2007

GKChesterton on the Fall of the Bastille

As usual, the incisive thought:

THE destruction of the Bastille was not a reform it was something more important than a reform. It was an iconoclasm; it was the breaking of a stone image. The people saw the building like a giant looking at them with a score of eyes, and they struck at it as at a carved face. For of all the shapes in which that immense illusion called Materialism can terrify the soul, perhaps the most oppressive is that of the big building. Man feels like a fly, an accident in the thing he has himself made. It requires a violent effort of the spirit to remember that man made this confounding thing and man could unmake it. Therefore the mere act of the ragged people in the street taking and destroying a huge public building has a spiritual, and a ritual, meaning far beyond its immediate political results. It is a religious service. If, for instance, the Socialists were numerous or courageous enough to capture and smash up the Bank of England you might argue for ever about the inutility of the act, and how it really did not touch the root of the economic problem in the correct manner. But mankind would never forget it. It would change the world.

Now and then it crosses one's mind....

Never mind.

"Learn to Live With Them"--PishPosh, Lady!

Don't like coyotes eating your cats and smaller dogs?

Jeannie Lords, who runs the Pine View Wildlife Rehabilitation Center, says humans will have to learn to live with the pests. "We have to find means of peaceful co-existence," she told a crowd gathered at [Franklin] City Hall to discuss the topic.

None of that "trapping and euthanizing" stuff, either:

So far four coyotes have been trapped and euthanized. That plan is being called into question by wildlife experts and residents who say it's ineffective and inhumane

In the alternative, the coyotes could "learn to live with" .270Win rounds approaching at 2800 feet per second. Humane, and very effective.

Cheaper than trapping/euthanizing, too, assuming a halfway decent shot placement.

HT: Kevin Fischer

The Portland Model: It Failed, Mayor Tom

Earlier this week, Mayor Tom and County Exec Walker were guests of Mike Cudahy, visiting Denver and Portland to eyeball the choo-choos.

Mike likes choo-choos. So does Mayor Tom. Walker is less enthused.

And for good reason, as Random 10 points out:

Problems with Portland’s Plans: The previous discussion has already hinted at some of the major drawbacks of Portland’s integrated land-use and transportation planning. These include the following: 1. increasingly unaffordable housing prices. 2. Increased traffic congestion. 3. Higher taxes or reduced urban services as tax revenues are diverted to rail transit and transit-oriented development. 4. A reputation for having an unfriendly business environment, leading to higher unemployment.

Noteworthy, by the way, that Random did the homework because two OTHER notorious State Lefties (Cieslewicz and Falk) want choo-choos for Madistan.

Buy Mike and the Mayor a Lionel set for their homes.

Leave the driving to Scott.

Fear THIS, Sen. Vitter

Mrs. Vitter:

"I'm a lot more like Lorena Bobbitt than Hillary," Wendy Vitter told Newhouse News. "If he does something like that, I'm walking away with one thing, and it's not alimony, trust me."

HT: Of Arms and the Law

Does Bush Understand "Commander-in-Chief"?

Serious concerns and criticism of the President from serious conservatives:

...I was struck by his reluctance, as America's leader, to accept full responsibility for Iraq policy. Instead, he seems to hide behind his commanders, as in these remarks:

"I have an obligation, a sincere and serious obligation, to hear out my commander on the ground. And I will take his recommendation."


"I'm going to wait for David to come back -- David Petraeus to come back and give us the report on what he sees."


When later asked about if more troops should have been used from the outset, he commented:

"I mean, one of the questions is, should we have sent more in the beginning? Well, I asked that question, do you need more, to General Tommy Franks....My primary question to General Franks was, do you have what it takes to succeed? And do you have what it takes to succeed after you succeed in removing Saddam Hussein? And his answer was, yes."


In the case of Petraeus, he gives the impression that he's expecting the general to be his miracle worker or at least someone who'll buy him some time. In the case of Franks, the president clearly implied that if anyone should be blamed it's Franks and not he. Bush himself is now said to welcome being compared to Harry Truman, whom history has treated much better than his contemporaries did. If so, when do we see the Bush version of the buck stops here?


--"Wlady", the publisher of the American Spectator.

A later entry in the same blog amplifies:

....I would have criticized most strongly is the one you highlighted, namely the answer about Tommy Franks. When the question was asked, I started talking out loud to my TV set, saying, "PLEASE answer this right, please do it right, please..."-- and then found myself getting angry when he again refused to acknowledge that no matter where the advice came from about troop levels, the advice was wrong, wrong, wrong, dead freaking WRONG. He would gain so much politically if he would ever, directly and unambiguously, admit that he personally has made an error in decisionmaking, and that he has LEARNED from it. The extreme lack of confidence so many people have (concerning Bush and his judgment and competence) stems in large part from the sense that he never learns, never adjusts (or unless not until WAY too late), never even admits to himself that he can possibly be or have been wrong, and therefore doesn't ever IMPROVE on bad performance. It drives me nuts. One letter writer today said Bush's mind seems "hermetically sealed," and her impression is definitely understandable.

That from Quin Hillyer.

Tavern League Loses, Legislator Makes No Sense

The Republican version of the State budget contains a provision which indicates that the Tavern League's death-grip on Wisconsin may be broken.

The wording, inserted into the budget bill at the urging of Rep. Mark Gottlieb (R-Port Washington), would provide an exemption from every community's liquor license quota for new full-service restaurants.

..."Communities around the state are finding that this anachronistic quota system that goes back to the 1930s is really cutting into economic development opportunities."

Got that? The current system is 'anachronistic' and cuts into 'economic development.'

The following which explains the law:

State law regulates the number of Class B combination liquor licenses a community can issue. With some exceptions, the liquor license quota law restricts the number of such licenses to one per every 500 residents. Class B combination licenses allow establishments to serve liquor, beer and wine and commonly are granted to full-service restaurants.

Of course, we can't have TOO much of that 'economic development' because we really DO like 'anachronistic' laws--or more important, State control of everything:

In addition, holders of existing Class B licenses would be prohibited from giving up those licenses and applying for new licenses under the full-service restaurant exemption. This is designed to prevent an existing license from being converted to a new full-service restaurant license, thus freeing up the former license to be granted to a business that is not a full-service restaurant, such as a tavern.

Seems to me that a municipality, village, or township is perfectly capable of determining how many restaurants and/or taverns they want.

What's the matter with THAT concept?

Hint: use the word 'power' in any sentence you like.

The 'Company Line' on the Motu Proprio--And Signs of the Times

Some themes emerge from this well-constructed but brief article in the Milwaukee JS regarding the Motu Proprio.

1) The "Middle Ages" canard. (Codification date is not the same as origination date.)

The Tridentine Mass, which reaches back to the Middle Ages and was last modified in 1962, is not easy to master.

2) The "hard to learn" thing--always accompanied by the "nobody knows Latin" thing.

Its rubrics, or instructions, are complex. [Frs.] Cunningham and Sherman [celebrants of the Old Rite Indult Mass] estimate that it can take six months for a priest to learn to do it properly, which is a requirement of the pope.

Once the high school seminaries had closed and a majority of men coming to the seminary had already completed college, it became difficult to squeeze Latin into the curriculum, said Father Michael Witczak, who is leaving as rector of St. Francis Seminary here to teach at Catholic University of America. Younger men study some Latin, but it's optional for post-college seminarians.

(Fr. Witczak evidently ignored Papal guidelines on teaching Latin in the seminary--but never mind.)

3) The "back-to-the-past" bodyslam.

...the pope's letter made some Catholics concerned that it might signal a broader reversal of the Second Vatican Council's reforms of the 1960s.

4) The "nobody wants it" pre-emptive spike:

...the Director of the archdiocese's office for prayer and worship, said late this week, "I haven't received a single inquiry from a priest yet" about the pope's letter.

5) The "Jewish Question" silliness:

Milwaukee Archbishop Timothy M. Dolan stated in an e-mail message to priests that the pope's letter "should not affect us too much here." His message also says that there should be no concern about Jewish-Catholic relations because the pope states that priests should not celebrate the Tridentine Mass during the Easter Triduum - the three-day period that includes Good Friday.

(Here, the reporter deserves a good deal of credit for reading the MP more carefully than the Archbishop or his 'advisers'--the reporter gets the facts straight):

However, that requirement comes in a paragraph that deals with priests saying the Mass alone, without other people. It is not repeated in a paragraph that says pastors should willingly accept requests to say the Mass if it comes from "a stable group of faithful who adhere to the earlier liturgical traditions."

(Which means that some Catholics will continue to pray for the conversion of the Jews.)

Perhaps the most interesting portion of the article, however, was this sign of the times:

Witczak noted that many of the young seminarians tend to be more attracted than the older priests to traditional devotional practices.

"There's actually been an increase in the number of college-age young men who are starting to pursue an interest in seminary, and all of those guys are taking Latin in college," he added.

The reporter did not interview the Holy Spirit for his article. Based on the remarks above, that might have been interesting copy.

(To keep track of the Company Line, go to "The Top 10 Things They'll Say" at this site.)

Friday, July 13, 2007

Stupid Questions and a Gunshot

Many people understand that "calling 9-1-1" is not real useful during a crisis.

This lady found out the hard way.

Too bad for the home invader, who found out that the homeowner does NOT rely on 9-1-1.

The best stupidity from 9-1-1 happens AFTER the perp assumes room temperature...

HT: Of Arms and the Law

John Allen on B-16's Pronouncements; The '60's Are Over

John Allen is the "Roman" reporter for the National Catholic Reporter, which is one of the more anti-Roman "Catholic" newspapers in the USA.

While one may argue that Allen's affiliation taints his reporting, others argue that as a reporter, Allen is outstanding. Either way, one pays attention to his writings.

This week he excerpts a bit from his forthcoming book on the Church; the excerpt is pertinent to the Pope's recent actions.

In 21st century Europe, Catholicism perceives itself as an embattled minority. The same sensation obtains to varying degrees in other parts of the developed world, such as Australia and New Zealand, Canada, and the United States. In response, Catholicism in these zones is doing what embattled minorities always do, practicing what sociologists call the "politics of identity" -- aggressively reinforcing traditional markers of thought, language, dress, and behavior, in order to resist assimilation to what Benedict XVI calls this "dictatorship of relativism."

New translations of the rites and rituals of the Catholic church which are closer to Roman patterns, and dusting off the pre-Vatican II Mass, illustrate the trend, along with a growing emphasis on individual confession and Eucharistic adoration. Marian devotion is also staging a strong comeback, measured in part by the success of pilgrimage sites such as Lourdes, Fatima and Medjugorje. In the priesthood and religious life, one finds a return to habits and Roman collars, especially among younger priests, deacons, brothers, and sisters. Debates in Catholic universities and hospitals about what makes them "Catholic," as well as efforts to tighten up on admissions and curricula in Catholic seminaries, are also part of this picture. Bishops insisting that Catholic politicians cannot defy church teaching and still wear the label "Catholic" likewise expresses the identity impulse

This should come as no surprise to anyone who has kept their eyes and ears open in the last 5-10 years; I would add that the appearances of JPII and Benedict XVI at "Youth Days", with milllions of under-25's cheering in mud-flat fields around the world adds wieght to Allen's thesis.

In other words, the 1960's Revolution, personified by such as Bp. Rembert Weakland, John Cdl. Dearden (RIP), Roger Cdl. Mahoney, Sr. Joan Chittister, and Jos. Cdl. Bernardin (RIP) in the US, not to mention dozens of others worldwide, is OVER, albeit that there are some old, tired, (and tiresome) relics and practitioners who are still trying to peddle their beads, tie-dyed Levi's, rock'n'roll, secular/non-denominational "theology-of-Mazes", architecture-of-circuses and Pete Seeger/Broadway "music-for-worship".

They are the ones who don't get it. They are, truly, the Past.

Someone should send them the memo.

Archdiocese Liable for Fraud? And More News, Maybe

The story, of course, is that while the Archdiocese of Milwaukee is not liable for the execrable "supervision" it performed on its homosexual-pervert-child-rapist priests, it may well be liable for fraud--because the Archdiocese (really, a few higher-ups) mis-represented the priests' backgrounds to parishes here and elsewhere.

Naturally, if (a VERY big if) the plaintiffs are able to demonstrate fraud and pursue damages, no insurance company will ante up Big Bucks. Only the Archdiocese will be liable.

The "will-not-BE-a-story" is whether the 'higher-ups' involved in this deception can be prosecuted individually for criminal fraud.

They can't. The Statute of Limitations prohibits it.

By the way--look for ANOTHER decision from the Supremes today which may set the Archdiocese back about $20 million. The case results from an auto accident in which an Archdiocesan volunteer was at fault and the victim sued the Archdiocese under its auto policy

$239 MILLION Last Year Alone: The State's Gift to Milwaukee

Were it not for the indefatigable Eggster, who would have guessed that the State of Wisconsin shipped $239 MILLION to the City of Milwaukee in 2006?

Geez. Now the City's being asked to live with only $211 million in State taxpayer transfers.

Truly, it's the End of the World.

Immigrants Sue; The Rest of the Story

Recently, the Feds decided to cut off 'green card' applications, announcing that all available quotas were filled for this year. It was a surprise action, reversing an announcement earlier this year.

This created a few problems for H1B workers who were 'on track' to become citizens.

One of them, who works for Compuware Corp, a 'body shop' IT consulting firm headquartered in Detroit, is profiled in today's Milwaukee JS.

You can also learn a bit from this source which details his employer's H1B requests.

The key information is found when you scroll to the right--look for the columns which are headed "wage rate" and "prevailing wage."

You'll find that the immigrant in question is being paid somewhere between $46K-$50K as a programmer-analyst, and that the "prevailing wage" is somewhere between $45.8K-$49.2K.

On the other hand, the BLS' tables for Milwaukee tell us that in September, 2005, private industry-employed Computer Systems Analysts and Scientists earned an AVERAGE wage of $57,387./year.

That was two years ago.

On this page, BLS gives a more extensive breakdown of job categories, but it's for the entire Eastern North Central region of the USA, and dated July 2006.

There we find that full-time computer programmers earn an average of $69,209/year (hourly wage times 2,080 hours/year)

Immigrant's salary: $50K, at most, according to his employer's filing.
BLS 2005 average, Milwaukee/Racine: $57, 387.
BLS 2006 average, E. NorthCentral US: $69,209.

"Prevailing Wage" ~$47K.

How does THAT work, Feds?

Oh, PuhLEEEEZZZZE!!

Talk about throwing it against the wall and hoping some of it....

Just before The End of the World As We Know It (HT: Charlie) we will have The End of The Amber Alert.

Thus sayeth the Sybillitic headline in the Milwaukee JS:

GOP budget said to weaken Amber Alert

Fortunately, the reporters provide what the Headline Editor taketh away (reality...)

The Republican version of the budget would end virtually all tax support for public broadcasting by mid-2008, a move that would erase more than a third of its budget,

The clear reading here is that the PBS Peabrains cannot re-allocate dollars for what's important.

Somehow, that is not a surprise.

Earth to Barrett: It's Not YOUR Entitlement

Mayor Tom and DarthDoyle have a 'vision' for the City of Milwaukee.

The most important part of that 'vision' is that the rest of the State pays for it.

How much?

The facts from Republican Mike Huebsch:

Huebsch noted that the city includes about one-tenth of the state's population, yet receives about one-third of all shared revenue

Then Huebsch phrased it another way:

"This is not the Milwaukee and Madison budget. This is the state budget."

The only question that one should ask is how Henry Maier's scheming has lasted THIS long.

"Prince of Darkness"--the Must-Read

PJB advises that the political junkies absolutely must read Bob Novak's new book, "Prince of Darkness."

Along the way, he has some fun with Novak.

At the party in his Pennsylvania Avenue apartment to celebrate [Novak's] baptism as a Catholic, Pat Moynihan said to me, among others, "Pat, now that we have made Novak a Catholic, do you think we can make him a Christian?"

Should give you the flavor of the book's contents, eh?

No Babies and Androgenous Fish: The Success of The Pill

Been fishing lately? Pulled up some really wierd-looking specimens?

You're lucky you got any at all--boy fishies are becoming rare, but sorta-kinda-girly-boy fishies are beginning to....ah....surface:

EPA-funded scientists at the University of Colorado studied fish in a mountain stream near Boulder, Colo., two years ago.

When they netted 123 trout and other fish downstream from the city's sewer plant, they found 101 were female, 12 were male, and 10 were strange "intersex" fish with male and female features.


This is not exactly "news;" we've mentioned it before. But somehow, it's escaped the attention of the MSM, whose worship of stunted families is even more serious than their worship of the environment. In other words, given the choice between free sex and a healthy fish population....

Just sayin'.

For you trial attorneys out there, here's a hint: it's J&J's fault.

The main culprits were found to be estrogens and other steroid hormones from birth-control pills and patches that ultimately ended up in the creek after being excreted in urine into the city's sewers.

The reaction from one natural sciences researcher is telling:

It's "the first thing that I've seen as a scientist that really scared me," university biologist John Woodling told the Denver Post.

Proving he doesn't watch too much 'Hollywood Insider' TV.

Motu Proprio Gets Reaction in Milwaukee 'burbs

Sometimes, even though it's not a surprise, it IS a disappointment.

For at least one suburban parish in Milwaukee, the reaction of the clergy to the Motu Proprio is telling. A correspondent writes as follows:

Fr. XX had a string of thoughts. He seemed very conflicted. He questioned if this document would hold much weight. Then he wondered how and when priests would learn to say this [Joannine Use] mass.

Then he again [questioned] the "weight" and seriousness of the document. 'Is this being said infallibly'.....or is it worth as much as if it were written on toilet paper?

Then he [wondered] how is he supposed to reconcile what the Holy Father is saying and what people might want, the holiness, the history, the tradition, [vs.] what [some activist parish] folks are saying and asking for [which is] the "vibrant and caring community" [and] the participation and inclusion of the members in the liturgy.

First of all, the Motu Proprio is not "infallible." The document does not deal with doctrine, nor dogma--so it's astounding that any priest would use that term to describe it. However, there IS such a thing as "obedience," (believe it or not) and there can be no doubt that "obedience" is what the Pope expects.

Secondly, (and more important), this priest doesn't yet seem to have the understanding that the "activists" mentioned are going in the wrong direction. (They seek 'greeters,' and 'praise band' music, inter alia, mimicking a large non-denominational community down the street from the parish.) While he seems to understand that the Joannine Use delivers "holiness, history, [and] tradition," he does not understand that the Joannine Use Mass also provides for "participation and inclusion" in the Mass. He should read the 1958 Instruction on liturgy from the Congregation for Divine Worship to get up to speed. (Neither form of celebration will make the "community" more or less "caring and vibrant.")

In other words, he has an opportunity here. Let's hope that he takes it.

Finally, Father's concern about "how to learn" is understandable. However, that's the responsibility of the Archbishop of Milwaukee, who will (no doubt) provide whatever is necessary for his priests to serve all the members of their flocks.

Thursday, July 12, 2007

The Motu Proprio's Indult Ancestor in Milwaukee

The Catholic Herald has a story about the existing Joannine Use Mass (Old Rite) in Milwaukee.

Nearly three months before Pope Benedict XVI issued his “motu proprio” on the use of the Roman liturgy prior to the reform of 1970, Archbishop Timothy M. Dolan touched upon the importance of unity when he welcomed the Tridentine community to its new home — St. Stanislaus Parish on Milwaukee’s south side.

“We’re all one — one in our faith in our Lord and Savior, Jesus Christ; one holy, catholic, apostolic, Catholic faith, and one in unity with our Holy Father,” he said April 15.

Mass in the Tridentine Rite had been said in Mater Christi Chapel at the Cousins Center from 1985-1995. For the last 12 years, the community worshipped at St. Mary Help of Christians, but the move to St. Stanislaus, with a capacity of 800, was necessitated by the closing of the West Allis parish in February of this year.

In an interview with your Catholic Herald in April, Fr. Robert Skeris, who serves as chaplain to the Tridentine community and says the Latin Mass at St. Stanislaus, noted that the historic church is a fitting location for the Mass.

“It was left as (Msgr. Raymond) Punda had it in 1968,” Fr. Skeris said. “What’s there is what it was.”

The church building has not gone through many of the extensive "renovations" which have afllicted a number of other churches in the Milwaukee area. The choir loft is extremely large and the church has a serviceable, if slightly old, pipe organ; a good deal of parking is available both on the street and in a lot behind the building.

Regulatory Costs: You Pay in Many Ways

Yesterday the US 'cost of regulation' index became available. It's high and getting higher.

But besides forcing us to pay more for almost anything we buy, there are other more serious implications--far more serious.

Need copper?

Although we are blessed with abundant mineral deposits and have developed many of the world’s innovative mining technologies, we have become dangerously dependent on foreign sources. The U.S. Geological Survey reported in 2005 that “U.S. manufacturers and consumers of mineral products that are critical to the U.S. economy depended on other countries for 100 percent of 17 mineral commodities (an increase of 6 percent over 2003) and for more than 50 percent of 42 mineral commodities (an increase of 8 percent over 2003).” Between 1997 and 2002, there was a 66-percent decline in U.S. mining exploration spending. One reason for this is the lengthy permit process. Obtaining a permit for copper mining in the United States, for instance, can take from 4-8 years compared with 18 months for Chile.

Need energy?

“If we look back to the mid-1990s,” the NAM points out, “the United States enjoyed a 30 percent cost advantage with regard to natural gas on a trade-weighted basis.” However, says the NAM 2006 report, The Escalating Cost Crisis, “the steady increase in U.S. prices since then is purely the result of policy decisions that have limited development of domestic reserves and Clean Air Act mandates that have increased demand” for natural gas.

According to the U.S. Minerals Management Service, areas of America’s outer continental shelf (OCS) currently banned from development likely contain a mean estimate of 18.92 billion barrels of oil and 85.79 trillion cubic feet of natural gas recoverable by current technical means. However, federal environmental policies are preventing us from accessing that treasure trove of desperately needed energy

Need food? Well, the corn's being fed to your CAR--increasing the prices of beef, milk, breakfast cereals, Coca-Cola, and beer.

Yes, it's a regulatory cost--driven by the GreenWeenies (and their willing running-dogs in Congress.) The ADM/Farm lobby inserted Corn-A-Hole as "the solution" to a largely vestigial and diminishing "air pollution problem."

Regulatory restrictions and harassing litigation by environmental radicals have prevented construction of a single nuclear power plant or oil refinery in the United States for the past three decades.

Need a job?

...as Paul Craig Roberts noted earlier this year, “The problem America faces is not a lack of educated people, but a lack of jobs for educated people. In the 21st century, the US economy has been able to create net new jobs only in domestic services, such as waitresses, bartenders and health and social services. The vast majority of these jobs do not require a college education, and they do not produce tradable goods and services that could be exported or substituted for imports.”

At least part of the reason for that little problem has to do with the cost of manufacturing 'stuff' in the USA--and regulatory cost plays a BIG part in that.

There's plenty for a new Congress and President to do.

God willing, there will be LESS for regulators to do. But that's OK. They can always get jobs in restaurants and hotels.

Wednesday, July 11, 2007

A Reflection on CDF's "Church" Document

From Cosmos-Liturgy, a very nice reflection on the statement from Cong. for Doctrine of the Faith regarding the Church and the 'other guys.'

...Theologians such as Francis J. Sullivan, (c.f e.g. “Quaestio Disputata: A Response to Karl Becker, S.J., On the Meaning of Subsistit In,” Theological Studies 67 (2006): 395-409) have spent a lot of time and effort trying to develop vast theories with detailed analyses of language, evolution of documents, etc. all with the aim of trying to show that the documents don’t really say what they say.

Setting motivation aside, it seems to me that these theologians possess a faulty philosophical foundation (apparently Ockhamist Nominalism) which allows them to conceive of a Church that can both have the fullness of Christ’s Church but not be equated with Christ’s Church at the same time. Christ has but one Mystical Body, one Church. It is the Catholic Church. This Mystical Body is hierarchically constituted with the Successor to St. Peter as its head. To rip the Catholic Church and place it on its own, in autonomy from the Church of Christ, renders the Church of Christ as an unrealized ideal that has no real ontology. This is an emaciated ecclesiology that also deprives humanity of it access to grace–understood as partaking in the divine nature (2 Pt 1:4). Thus we are left with a Reformed theology of grace as extrinsic favor rather than intrinsic, deifying communion. It is no coincidence that the Bologna school adopts a Protestant ecclesiology and is then driven also to a Protestant Sacramentology.

Adopting "the razor" of Ockham can, ah....cut the wrong way.

...Contra Cardinal Kasper, the particular Church cannot preexist the Universal Church. Thus, to the degree the Christian body is united with the fullness of the Church, these Churches and ecclesial communities share in Christ’s mediation of the Father’s grace to humanity…i.e. are united to the Catholic Church. But regardless of whether they are in visible communion or not, any and all grace they receive is mediated through Christ’s single Mystical Body, and so it is mediated by the Catholic Church.

(Cdl. Kasper was the "external relations" guy--the ecumenical point-man--of the Church for a few years. You can understand why he didn't like dogmatic stuff--although it's not so easy to excuse him.)

And, for my Protestant friend(s), a distinction which is worth recalling:

A major complaint is that this ecclesiology sounds so triumphalistic; thus it is arrogant. Proper distinctions need to be made to see the error in this. Any truth claim is what it is–it is either true or false. Arrogance/truimphalism is a subjective attitude and has nothing to do with truth claims. Truth can be presented in humility and falsehoods can be proclaimed with arrogance (the latter of which is more often the case I would argue). One cannot preemptively dismiss a truth claim as false simply because of fears about how it might be received. To do so is at root, succumbs to an emotivist relativism.

Cosmos-Liturgy also has some remarks for the Feeneyites who also remain standing...

Separately, Dreher observes:

I'm sure there'll be lots of howls over [the document from Rome], but you won't get them from me. Of course Benedict believes the fullness of the faith is denied to my church, the Orthodox Church, and to a greater degree the Protestant churches. He's the Pope of the Roman Catholic Church! If he believed anything else, he would be unfaithful to Church teaching and tradition. You can't believe what the Catholic Church teaches, and also affirm all of what Orthodoxy and/or Protestantism teach. I would expect a good Baptist to agree.

Yup.

"Guaranteed Student"?

P-Mac finds an interesting nugget.

Moss, a professor at Harvard's business school, tosses out a better idea: "Insuring students against losses on their educational investments, rather than guaranteeing lenders against bad loans.

"Specifically," he writes, "we should ensure that every American can finance college or graduate-school tuition (or the cost of job training) with a special income-contingent loan (ICL) from the federal government. The loan would have an extended term (up to 30 years, like a mortgage) and would defer or potentially forgive interest payments for any year in which the recipient's household income fell below a prespecified trigger.

"A federal ICL program would make certain that every American equipped to earn a college degree could get it, irrespective of need. Although participating students would still assume substantial levels of debt, they would have much less cause for worry, and thus much more reason to invest in higher education, since they would not have to pay when their income faltered."

A cynic might observe that a college prof makes the proposal, which is designed to continue the professional viability of college profs.

Another cynic might argue that this is a VERY thinly-veneered proposal for "free" college, financed by the taxpayers. After all, the 'income assumption' portion of the concept is malleable, allowing a vote-hungry Congress to hammer the trigger into whatever shape they like.

A third cynic might note that this does not particularly address 'needs;' it just addresses 'wants'--specifically, the 'want' of a college degree, which these days means almost as little as it buys.

Mayor Tom, You Should Quit, Too

NY Mayor Bloomberg formed a coalition of Mayors to "fight gun crime." Actually, their purpose is to disarm a lot of law-abiding Americans. Milk Carton Tommy joined up. He understands the agenda very well.

SOME Mayors have had second thoughts, based on Bloomberg's asinine antics.

According to ATF and the Department of Justice, your actions in having civilian private investigators conduct clandestine sting operations against federally licensed firearms dealers, without the knowledge of ATF or your own police department, actually interfered with ongoing criminal investigations, putting the lives of law enforcement officers and others at risk. The Department of Justice warned you to refrain from these actions because such efforts could "interrupt or jeopardize ongoing investigations." In response, your Deputy Mayor Ed Skyler stated that the operations would not necessarily stop. I do not want the blood of a police officer on my hands so that you can advance your anti-gun litigation campaign. I prefer instead to support the Fraternal Order of Police, a group that opposes your coalition's efforts to gain access to gun trace data for use in civil lawsuits."

--Mayor Harry Moore, of Oldmans Twnsp, NJ

It is possible that Milwaukee County DA Chisholm actually knows the law regarding "gun trace data." It's also possible that he knows Bloomberg's real agenda. Since that agenda is not good for living people--like the cops, for example--responsible Mayors have quit in disgust.

We know where Milk Carton Tommy stands.

Risser Hospital

Freddy Risser (D-Madistan) has a vision for Wisconsin hospitals. Fidel, Fred's mentor (and by the way, age-cohort mate) has pictures:



Nurse Judy (those are her tracks) is at her station in the next hospital--about 5 miles up the road. She's the Regional Nurse...

"Gnome" Cherthoff's New 'Do

At least it's not a $400.00 trim.




What'd you expect, after his cabbage-headed comments about those who opposed the "Amnesty Bill"? Love and kisses?
HT Malkin.

Free At Last!! Today You Paid Off the Government--for This Year

Today's "Cost of Government Day"-- as reported by the American Spectator.

According to a new report from Americans for Tax Reform (ATR), government effectively consumes 52.6 percent of national income.

Unfortunately, the Bush years have not been good ones for Americans tired of turning so much of their incomes over to government. Despite the Bush tax cuts, people are working several days longer for federal, state, and local governments now than in 2000, when George W. Bush was elected president. Cost of Government Day (COGD) rose two days from 2006 alone.

GWB is and always was a Big Spending, Big Gummint sorta guy.

Here's a familiar-sounding analysis:

The problem is largely one of spending. Writes Karasmeighan: "The average American worker will have to work an additional 6 days out of the year over 2000 to pay for government spending on all levels.

Our beloved State Piss-It-Away Party (led by the Governor and supported by the Legislature since ---oh----about the year 1968) ought to know about spelling "spending."

Outlandish outlays, not tax cuts, are responsible for today's deficits. Karasmeighan points out that 70 percent of the cumulative deficit since 2002 resulted because spending rose more quickly than national income. A simple "spend only what you can afford to pay policy" would have largely eliminated the deficit.

Oh, yeah--it ain't just the Feds:

State and local spending accounts for another 1.6 days of the COGD increase from 2000 to 2007. This year the average American will work nearly 46 days to fund state and local governments. Moreover, the future likely will be worse. Reports ATR: "Even with looming unfunded pension and health care liabilities, states are failing to reform their entitlement programs. On the contrary, many states used their 2007 sessions to discuss expanding health care programs and imposing health insurance mandates."

Uh-huh.

Don't you wish it were just taxes? HAH! SUCKER!!

The cost of regulation as a percent of national income remains at 16.9 percent for the fourth year. It is important to note, however, that revised data on regulatory costs reveal that COGD reports prior to 2006 were underestimating the cost of regulations. New regulations imposed following the War on Terrorism and corporate scandals significantly increased the regulatory burden in 2001 and 2002 in particular. Concurrently, the cost of tax compliance continues to grow. In 2007, the average American will work 61.8 days to pay for the regulatory costs, nearly 1 full day more than was required in 2006.

That's not all bad. In PRChina, there are NO regulatory costs, except for the occasional bullet necessary to execute regulators.

Compare one AK-47 slug (about $0.50) with THIS, suckah:

According to economist Mark Crain, regulatory compliance costs ran $1.142 trillion last year. By way of comparison, Crews points out that this number exceeds total income tax collections and accounts for about nine percent of GDP. But that's not the end: "The Weidenbaum Center and the Mercatus Center jointly estimate that agencies spent $41 billion to administer and police the regulatory state in 2006," writes Crews.

The problem is not that all regulations are unnecessary or badly designed or unduly costly. The problem is that we have trouble assessing the relative merits of various regulations, and, more important, policymakers usually have no interest in such assessments even if they exist.

How about closing WallyWorld every time there's a nearby thunderstorm? (See OSHA proposal.)

Mercifully, the article does not denote Wisconsin's ranking in Cost of Government.

HT: AnkleBiters

Bob Kasten Surfaces With Rudy

Noted by the American Spectator blogsite.

The Giuliani campaign announced today that Charles Hill, former aide to George P. Shultz when he was Reagan's secretary of state, and a lecturer in the International Security Studies program at Yale University, will serve as chairman of the campaign's foreign policy advisory board and chief foreign policy advisor.

Also: Senior foreign policy team members include Norman Podhoretz and Senator Bob Kasten.


Proves he's still alive and kicking, right? But "foreign policy?"