Tuesday, August 07, 2007

What About Those "Parish Life Coordinators"?

While HE Bp. Sklba of Milwaukee ruminates* about how to fit the foot into the shoe, some thoughts on 'consequences' from a Dominican priest in Texas:

1) Without a priest in charge of the parish, young men won't have a model of priesthood to aspire to; no fault accrues to Sister for this, of course, but we know young men need male leadership in order to be properly challenged to sacrifice secular enticements. Sister's appointment is one more example of the feminization of the Church and another nail in the coffin of priestly vocations.

While this is a problem, it's not necessarily insuperable.

2) Once Sister and other PLC's (no doubt there will be huge pressure to appoint women in most of these positions) are appointed, it will take an Act of God to move them out when priests become available. Make no mistake: the PLC is not a temporary canonical solution to a temporary vocational problem. This is a move (sideways and under the guise of an "emergent crisis") to undermine presbyteral authority in the parish by emptying the role of pastor of its orders. IOW, this is a move to make it possible to be appointed Pastor (even if not in name) w/o being an ordained priest. Priests will simply become traveling Sacrament Machines. The office of Priest Director will fade as demand for priests grows. Interesting side note: priests now are starting to look a whole like bishops in the Patristic period!

Personally, I think that this is the most significant difficulty with the concept. And there is no question that women are being "primed" for these roles--Milwaukee's Seminary has a number of degree-programs which are populated with women, specifically recruited to those programs...

3). This is the first step in a long series of steps leading us to the "inevitability" of women being ordained priests. (Maybe. Times have changed in the last, oh, 2 years.) Think: altar girls and the arguments used post facto to defend against attempts to suppress the practice: "But we've been using altar girls for years!" Some predictions:

a). even with the availability of newly ordained priests, PLC's will continue to "pastor" their parishes with Fr. Newbie hanging around for "mentoring." He will be graduated to a staff position and made a "member of the team."

b). Within five years (but before the Fr. Newbies arrive) PLC's will demand the right to preach at Mass since Fr. Sacramental Minister isn't in residence and doesn't know the parish. How can he possibly preach to us when he doesn't know us?

In a lot of cases, they are not "demanding" a thing. Rather, they arrogate the function without asking...

c). Look for a new book of ceremonies to appear from The Liturgical Press, Liturgies for Pastoral Life Coordinators quite soon. It will be argued that since PLC's play a special role in the life of the parish, the church needs liturgies designed to celebrate their unique ministry. Translation: we need liturgical validation for the invention of the PLC so that the concept of the PLC is more easily tolerated over time. Liturgies bestow legitimacy and normalize innovation.

Entirely likely, as the Liturgeist Establishment harbors the largest population of lefties and non-orthodox "RC's" in the structure of the Church in the US.

d). Parishes administered by female PLC's will produce far fewer priestly vocations than parishes run by priest-pastors. This NOT b/c women intentionally deter vocations or somehow jinx boys into believing that the priesthood is bad--how many priests today trace their vocations back to a religious sister? My point is that w/o active, visible, and regular priestly leadership in a parish, a boy or young man cannot "see" the priesthood in action.

See my first comment above. As Father indicates below, it remains to be seen. And of course, the work of the Holy Spirit is ongoing...

I desperately want to be wrong about these predictions. Especially the last one. And here's a promise: if it can be proven over time that parishes with PLC's (lay men, women, or female religious) produce equivalent or more vocations to the ordained priesthood than parishes lead by priests, I will be the first to volunteer myself as a sacramental minister to work on a team under the leadership of a PLC. My objections to PLC's here are not about the loss of priestly power...

*Since Bp. Sklba's foot-fitting ruminations are not available online, see Diogenes' column remarking on the Bishop's thoughts here.

For Tax Purposes...

Christian Schneider writes an essay which is humorous, if you like dark and foreboding humor.

After the birth of our children, my wife was itching to get back to work. In order to accommodate our new schedules, we decided to hire a UW-Madison student to babysit our kids for 10 hours a week.

...Yet when it came time to hire our own babysitter, it quickly became evident there was more to it than just paying out of pocket. For tax purposes, my wife and I had to register and get both state and federal business identification numbers.

From there, we had to pay income taxes, social security taxes, and unemployment taxes on our babysitter (as well as some back taxes, as it took a few months to figure this all out). We had to register with the Department of Workforce development to set up quarterly unemployment insurance payments – despite the fact that if our babysitter were to quit working, she wouldn’t be collecting unemployment. We had to file all the W-2 and W-3 forms with federal and state government to report her income. If you decide to pay the babysitter’s portion of the income tax, naturally that gets taxed too, since it is considered income to the sitter. Despite my wife and I both having master’s degrees (although, admittedly, mine came with the purchase of my 20th case of Miller Lite), we had to hire a professional tax preparer to sort the whole mess out. And this was for someone watching our kids for 10 hours a week.

Of course, the important phrase is "for tax purposes." Had the Schneiders not wanted the deduction, nobody would have cared. Or--maybe more focused--had the Gummints simply believed that they were paying (say) $100./week to Suzy Q to watch the kids, instead of demanding documentation, ...

You get the picture.

Once it has been determined that every single nickel of a taxpayer's cashflow is subject to Gummint audit and cross-checking, the taxpayer's costs rise dramatically--not to mention the costs now incurred by the babysitter, (aka taxes.)

Next time, Chris, don't write it off.

And by the way, my kids take cash for those services. Less than $10/hour. You want to withhold? Find the next competent kid. Maybe they'll take your deal.

HT: Sykes

Jim Cramer in Perspective

We are reminded that Jim Cramer, the 'screamer' of yesterday's Belling show, is entertainment, not wisdom:

On July 16th, as the Dow was setting new record highs, Cramer declared, "Subprime...is totally meaningless. I am now saying that if every loan in 2006 that was subprime blew up – $500 billion – if they all blew up, you would still not notice...It has no relevance whatsoever."

"The trancheing [sic] of this stuff is the reason why there's no impact," he continued, "because it's been divided and split among so many entities that no ONE entity is really being hurt, other than the dumb guy who ran Bear Stearns."


On July 16th, most of the investment world agreed with Cramer's benign assessment.
But just 18 days later – and 900 Dow points lower – Cramer offered a dramatically different assessment.

"The Fed is asleep...We have Armageddon!"
he screamed on the air. "In the fixed-income markets we have Armageddon!!" And so it seemed to the majority of investors on that day. The Dow tumbled nearly 300 points, while the price of protecting against falling share prices soared to multi-year highs.


I suppose that Armageddon can occur in less than 18 days, Jim.

How're the ratings?

(Source: The Rude Awakening Newsletter)

Kagen's Health Care Opening Essay

Heh.

Here's what Rep. Kagen (NutJob/WI) has to say in his opening essay on healthcare:

Open disclosure is common sense. It will require the real cost of all health care services and products to always be visible and openly disclosed to customers. And it will make certain that everyone knows the price of a pill before they swallow it, the true lowest-cost of insurance policies, and all products or services provided by physicians, nurse practitioners, physician assistants, medical technologists, dentists, chiropractors, and all other recognized health professionals.

Somehow, Rep. Kagen avoids mention of 'the source of medications.' Like, for example, if the allergist is 'mixing his own' meds.

(Wisconsin State) Fair? or Partly Cloudy?

Kevin acts like the journalist he really is.

The local MSM? Still testing creampuffs, I guess.

I have to wonder if the Wisconsin State Fair is having disappointing attendance figures this year.

Through the years, the Fair has always announced its daily attendance numbers to the media, and to workers and vendors in a daily newsletter. This year, I am told, no such daily figures are being announced.

Could it be Fair officials are embarrassed and are trying to hide the dismal news?

Veteran Fair observers have seen some strange and rare goings-on.

For example, unusually small crowds at night this past weekend. How about the Budweiser stage and concession area closing at 9:30 one night. I’m told that simply never happens.

Other vendors have also been shutting down earlier than the 11:00 closing time on non-weekend nights.

The bonehead move of the Fair thus far was the booking of Lupillo Rivera and Ana Barbara on the Miller Lite Main Stage this past Saturday, neither one of whom sang a word in English.

Thursday night, attendance at the Main Stage was 7,000; Friday night, 4900.Saturday night’s concert, the attempt to bring diversity to the fair, brought in a whopping 840 fans. The concert ended around midnight, right about the time the Fair was closing. That, too, shouldn’t make Fair management very happy. The idea on the weekends is to bring in big names on the Main Stage who will draw big crowds. You then get those concert fans back into the park after the show to eat, drink, and spend more money. That didn’t come close to happening Saturday.

Perhaps it's just co-incidence that the Fair management issued a press release to the effect that 'this is one of the top State Fairs in the USA,' and was dutifully read by one of the local TV stations last night.

Don't recall hearing any data to support that contention.

Barf-Beam Next Defensive Weapon?

Just after you see the light, you barf.

It looks like a big flashlight — but it's really a nonlethal weapon designed to make you sick.
Intelligent Optical Systems, Inc., of Torrance, Calif., has been granted a contract by the Department of Homeland Security to develop what it calls the "LED Incapacitator," according to a DHS online newsletter.

The handheld device using light-emitting diodes to emit super-bright pulses of light at rapidly changing wavelengths, causing disorientation, nausea and even vomiting in whomever it's pointed at.

The handheld device using light-emitting diodes to emit super-bright pulses of light at rapidly changing wavelengths, causing disorientation, nausea and even vomiting in whomever it's pointed at.

• Click here to read the newsletter writeup.

"There's one wavelength that gets everybody," says IOS President Bob Lieberman. "Vlad [IOS top scientist Vladimir Rubtsov] calls it 'the evil color.'"

This is not likely to be a popular home-defense weapon where there is white carpeting.

Monday, August 06, 2007

Arlen Specter's Decline Into "Certifiably Psychotic"

He was always a suspect. Until Arlen opened his flap, nobody in this country really gave a drat for "Scottish Laws" vis-a-vis our Constitution.

Now he's drawn back the curtain.

...Senator Arlen Specter is providing covering fire for these partisan Democrats by announcing his intention to "review" the judicial opinions of Chief Justice Roberts and Justice Alito to see if they have "complied with" promises he believes they gave in their Senate testimony as to how they would rule on the bench.

The word "astonishing" is inadequate for the level of hubris Specter demonstrates.

HT: Pro Ecclesia

"Free Love"?

G K Chesterton on that topic:

They have invented a phrase, a phrase that is a black and white contradiction in two words -- "free love" -- as if a lover ever had been, or ever could be, free. It is the nature of love to bind itself, and the institution of marriage merely paid the average man the compliment of taking him at his word.

HT: Happy Catholic

Signs of Disease: "Show Up or Pay More"

At St. Jerome's in Oconomowoc, Fr. Yockey, the pastor, offers a deal:

Show up at Mass 70% of the time, and you get a tuition break for the chilluns you send to the parish grade school.

Really.

Here's another deal:

281. Which are the chief commandments, or laws, of the Church?

The chief commandments, or laws, of the Church are these six:

1) To assist at Mass on all Sundays and holydays of obligation

The penalty for disregarding this particular law is most assuredly NOT financial.

Fr. Yockey explains:

"It was my decision. I'm calling it the expectation model. What this means is that parents who are registered as parishioners of St. Jerome are expected to live up to the teachings of the Catholic Church, and the official teaching reminds parents that they are the primary educators of their children in the ways of faith."

Well, doh. The Church does tell parents that they are 'the primary educators of their children.' But the far more grave expectation is "To assist...on ALL Sundays and holydays..." Why doesn't Fr. Yockey put THAT in the bulletin? Or on the schoolhouse door?

The disease is worldliness. I am not convinced that the cure is more of the same.

Terry has more here.

Sunday, August 05, 2007

As To That Proposal of the Bishops...

Chironomo speculates that the USCC's draft proposal for "liturgical music" was both mis-directed AND has been sorta kinda buried.

Moreover, that the response from Rome was not direct, but indirect.

Michael McMahon, President of NPM, pens a curious look at the Directory for Music suggested by the Bishops in November of 2006 in “Establishing Criteria for Liturgical Songs”. From the outset, he misses the point entirely…. Liturgiam Authenticam doesn’t call for establishing criteria for liturgical songs… it calls for establishing a fixed repertoire of liturgical texts to be used for singing. There is a huge difference, which apparently the Bishops missed as well. Giving him his due, however, he does point out that the Bishop’s document has been submitted for recognitio as required, but that “as of July 1st, the U.S Bishops were still waiting to hear back from Rome.” I think this silence from Rome speaks volumes.

(Faithful readers recall that NAPM is more accurately referred to as NAP(AL)M; the organization spent about 40 years attempting to incinerate any clear and reality-based understanding of the term musica sacra, not to mention putting the publishers of that stuff out of business.)

Anyhoo,

I would suggest that they have heard back from Rome already, in both Sacramentum Caritatis ...and in the letter to Bishops accompanying Summorum Pontificam

Both of these documents were issued this year, following the Bishops submission of the Directory, and both set forth a vision of what the music in the liturgy should be (in the case of summorum pontificam, the vision is to enact what was intended in Musicam Sacram).

Not a bad thesis. Given the inclinations of the current Pope, NAP(AL)M might be ceding membership to the Church Music Association of America over the next 10 years, because CMAA actually gets it.

Good News for Midwestern Church Musicians

Nah--I don't call them "ministers of music," sorry.

The Church Music Association of America has announced that its next Colloquium for study of Catholic Church music will be held in CHICAGO, instead of D.C.

June 16-21, 2008 (Monday noon through Saturday evening) Loyola University, Chicago, Illinois

Gregorian Chant has been called the most beautiful music this side of Heaven. But as Pope Benedict XVI and the Second Vatican Council have emphasized, it is also integral to Catholic liturgical life and should be heard and experienced with wide participation in every parish. The Church Music Association of America is working to bring about this ideal with its Sacred Music Colloquium.

...The primary focus of the Colloquium is instruction in chant and the Catholic sacred music tradition, participation in chant and polyphonic choirs, nightly lectures and performances, along with daily celebrations of liturgies in both English and Latin.

Attendance is open to anyone interested in improving the quality of music in Catholic worship. Professional musicians will appreciate the rigor, while enthusiastic volunteer singers will enjoy the opportunity to study under an expert faculty. If you have never sung chant before, the colloquium will open a new world of beautiful sacred music to you, so you too are encouraged to attend.

Attendees also benefit from camaraderie with like-minded musicians who share their love of the liturgy of the Church. Growing awareness and appreciation of chant and its solemnity has generated particular excitement about the conference this year.

The cost is reasonable (this is almost a full week of instruction, demonstration, and implementation)

$675 for single room/full program including meals, and materials,
$575 for double room/full program, including meals and materials
$360 tuition only, including materials (you can pay per meal as you choose)

A deposit to reserve your spot is $75, with full payment due by May 15, 2008. Register first and then make your deposit. .... You can also mail this registration form that includes your check or credit card number to: CMAA Colloquium Registration, 920 Sanders St., Auburn, AL, 36830.

“The greatest need of liturgy today is the restoration of the sense of the sacred,” writes CMAA President William Mahrt of Stanford University. “Music has a principal role, since it expresses that sense of the sacred and sustains it through time.”

Musicians from SE Wisconsin and NE Illinois are well-positioned to 'commute' the event.

Info, including a full schedule and the registration form (PDF), can be found here.

These are outstanding 'working' seminars. I've attended a couple of them in the past and the music, the instructors, and the other attendees are worth FAR more than the posted prices.

Get this into your budget!

Saturday, August 04, 2007

Bp. Sklba and Fr. Reese Join Hands. Trouble Afoot!

It doesn't take too long for The Usual Suspects to emerge. This time, they tag-team a recent statement from the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith which concerned the Catholic Church's self-definition.

Milwaukee's auxiliary, Bp. Sklba, leads off with an innocuous-sounding statement describing what he will say to the ELCA Convention in Chicago. (The Evangelical Lutheran Church in America is the 'far-left' Lutheran wing, not to be confused with the Missouri Synod or the Wisconsin Synod.)

He starts off:

"I certainly have to address the issues we struggle with. I don't want it to be bland. I don't want it to be just fluff. I want it to be a contribution. It has to at least recognize the (Vatican's) recent statement. I have to allude to that, to offer some assurance that this is not any rejection of dialogue partners or a lessening of commitment."

Of course the statement did not 'reject....partners' nor 'lessen commitment.' Those are straw-men. All the statement did is affirm what the Catholic Church teaches about itself and the logical consequences of those teachings.

Sklba said the document was aimed at Catholic theologians and their interpretations of Vatican II documents and papal encyclicals. It was drafted by the Vatican's Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith and approved by the pope, but he did not craft every word, Sklba said.

The 'he did not craft every word' clause is added to insinuate that the document lacks the 'finality' of a Papal proclamation; Sklba's wording is designed to intone the "It's Not Infallible!!" tune in the background. Cute. But irrelevant; he also (adroitly) acknowledged that the document was "approved by the Pope" which is all that's needed.

Enter Fr. Reese (SJ). It is rumored that Fr. Reese was removed from his position as editor of the Jesuits' America magazine because the magazine was having trouble presenting orthodox doctrine consistently and thoroughly. Fr. Reese begins with a True Fact:

"This wasn't a grenade aimed at Protestants," said Father Thomas Reese, a senior fellow at Georgetown University's Woodstock Theological Center. Benedict favors ecumenical dialogue but worries that it "is making Catholics think that as long as we all love Jesus and do good, it doesn't matter what church we belong to.

In Reese's view, ambiguous terms added in drafting Second Vatican Council documents to achieve near unanimous approval are being given specific interpretations by Vatican conservatives.

Well, maybe. Fr. Reese is correct that "specific interpretations" are being made, but these "specific interpretations" re-state exactly what the Church has said for 2,000 years or so. Fr. Reese would have us believe that the Second Vatican Council "changed stuff"--which is the motto of the "1960's Man." Unfortunately for Fr. Reese, the Council did not change one single teaching of the Church (although it did use different words and approaches to reaffirm Church teachings.) Fr. Reese also artfully inserts the BugBearTerm "Vatican conservatives." This reduces theology to partisan politics and implies that, were a "conservative" to state that "The sky is blue" that the truth of that statement hinges on political analysis.

Now the fun really begins.

A biblical scholar and theologian, Sklba focused on a word that has caused debate among theologians - what Vatican II meant by saying "the Church of Christ subsists in the Catholic Church" instead of already "is" that church. The document says the Catholic Church is the one true church, and Sklba agrees. But he interprets "subsists" as meaning the Catholic Church is not yet the church that Christ intended, that it has flaws and needs continuing reform.

"There's something in that 'subsists' which recognizes that we clearly have not fully complied with the mind of Christ," Sklba said.


The Catechism of the Catholic Church (search on 'subsists') presents the thing this way:

"The sole Church of Christ which in the Creed we profess to be one, holy, catholic, and apostolic, . . . subsists in the Catholic Church, which is governed by the successor of Peter and by the bishops in communion with him. (870)

And further:

In her [the Catholic Church] subsists the fullness of Christ's body united with its head; this implies that she receives from him "the fullness of the means of salvation" which he has willed: correct and complete confession of faith, full sacramental life, and ordained ministry in apostolic succession. (830)

From the use of the term in those teachings we can infer the meaning of the term "subsists," also given in Lewis & Short as: to stay, continue, remain or to stay, tarry, abide, remain.

But we can also read the document over which Bp. Sklba wrings his hands for a definition:

"Christ 'established here on earth' only one Church and instituted it as a 'visible and spiritual community' that from its beginning and throughout the centuries has always existed and will always exist, and in which alone are found all the elements that Christ himself instituted. ... ‘subsistence’ means this perduring, historical continuity and the permanence of all the elements instituted by Christ in the Catholic Church. ... the word 'subsists' can only be attributed to the Catholic Church alone ..."

(It does help to understand Latin when defining the term. It IS, after all, derived from Latin. Think 'underlying' or 'underpinning' or 'substrate' to get a better sense of the meaning of the term.)

Why was the expression "subsists in" adopted instead of the simple word "is"?

Response: This "does not change the doctrine on the Church," but only elucidates "the fact that there are 'numerous elements of sanctification and of truth.'"

This is not hard to figure out. While there are 'numerous elements of sanctification and truth' which exist, only the Catholic Church has ALL of them, and has HAD all of them from the day of Pentecost. While ELCA Lutherans have some of them (as do Methodists, Baptists, etc.,), none of those sects have Apostolic Succession, nor do they have ALL the elements which the Church does. And by the way, the document states just that.

But the Bishop utilizes the height of spin when he tries using the words of Cdl. Ratzinger against the words of the Congregation for Doctrine:

Sklba also points to earlier statements by Ratzinger.

When the National Evangelical Lutheran/Catholic Dialogue ended its 10th round of talks in Milwaukee in 2004, its report said that Catholic judgment on the authenticity of Lutheran ministry need not be all or nothing.


The report quotes a 1993 letter from Ratzinger: "I count among the most important results of the ecumenical dialogues the insight that the issue of the Eucharist cannot be narrowed to the problem of validity. Even a theology oriented to the concept of succession . . . need not in any way deny the salvation granting presence of the Lord in the Lutheran Lord's Supper."

Of course, the entire letter (and context) is not quoted. But the first thing that I recalled when reading the last phrase in the quote was the text "Where two or three are gathered in My name, there I am." That's one way to look at Cdl. Ratzinger's statement, and it fits precisely into the general thoughts of the CDW document. Here's why:

The Lutherans do not believe that their minister effects Transubstantiation--that is, they do not believe that the Body and Blood of Christ are literally and truly present under the appearance of bread and wine after their minister offers the gifts to God; on the other hand, the Catholics DO believe that the priest, acting in the Person of Christ, effects Transubstantiation at the Consecration of the Mass. (See "full sacramental life" in Catechism #830 above.)

What's key here is not "the presence" of the Lord. He told us that He would be 'present' along with two or three (or more) others gathered in his name. And the Lord can grant salvation despite 'non-succession' theological disputes. That's not in question.

What's key is Transubstantiation, which Bp. Sklba kinda-sorta elided from the discussion.

Further, Bp. Sklba

interprets "subsists" as meaning the Catholic Church is not yet the church that Christ intended, that it has flaws and needs continuing reform.

Umnnnnhhh....let's be precise, here, Your Excellency. The Church is also indefectible. Fr. Hardon's dictionary tells us the meaning of the term "indefectible" which also says a good deal about this "subsists" thing:

"Imperishable duration of the Church and her immutability until the end of time. The First Vatican Council declared that the Church possesses 'an unconquered stability' and that, 'built on a rock, she will continue to stand until the end of time.' (Denzinger 3013, 3056.) The Church's indefectibility, therefore, means that she now is and will always remain the institution of salvation, founded by Christ. This affirms that the Church is essentially unchangeable in her teaching, her constitution, and her liturgy...."

So the 'flaws' are not in the Church's teaching (doctrine and dogma.) They may exist in some other areas which are non-dogmatic or non-doctrinal. They may be flaws of 'accident,' but not of 'substance.'

What does Sklba mean by Catholic reform?

"Clarification, deepening," he said. "It's the same element of development of doctrine referred to in the Second Vatican Council's decree on divine revelation, where then-Father Ratzinger 40 years ago underscored the fact that doctrine developed and continues to develop and deepen understanding of revelation through the prayer and study of Christians, through the religious experience of Christians, and, only finally he pointed out, through the formal teaching ministry of the church.

"So, he was fascinated by the recognition of the development of doctrine, which has been part of Catholic tradition. It might take us yet in another direction.


The old 'switcheroo' here. Bp. Sklba implies that 'clarification' and 'deepening' will 'take us ...in another direction' and so, after all, nothing's permanent. Of course he did not SAY that--it would cost him his job to state that the Church would "un-truth" a truth. So he sorta-kinda implies it...

After all, "What is truth?"

Don't buy that line!! Clarification means that truth can be better-apprehended with another approach to the truth, or through different expression of that truth. It does NOT mean that "truth changes."

See, truth subsists.

Terry has more here.

Friday, August 03, 2007

From North Dakota, an Essay on the Motu Proprio

Hat tip to Fr. Z for this wonderful re-post:

In the past few weeks, two important documents were presented to the universal church by the Holy See.The first document, “Summorum Pontificum,” was released July 7 by Pope Benedict XVI as an apostolic letter in the form of a motu proprio. It relaxes the restrictions on the celebration of the Mass and other sacraments using the forms that were present before the Second Vatican Council.

...the faithful who read the document will see that, rather than positioning one version of the Roman Missal against another, the Holy Father declares, “They are, in fact, two usages of the one Roman Rite.” The document explains that there are two forms for celebrating the Holy Mass: the ordinary form of the Mass, currently celebrated in our parishes, according to the Roman Missal of Paul VI from 1970, and the extraordinary form of the Mass celebrated according to the Roman Missal from 1962, commonly known as the Tridentine Mass.

...The renewed attention to celebrating either form of the Mass with greater reverence will lead us to a deeper love for our Eucharistic Lord. One way in which our current missal will be improved in the coming years is with updated translations from the official Latin texts. Sadly, our current English translation is not as theologically rich or linguistically beautiful as comparable translations

The Holy Father’s desire, and my own, is that all of us develop a deeper love and reverence for the great treasure we receive from Christ, himself, in every Mass.

His Excellency Most Reverend Samuel Aquila, Fargo, ND.

WSJ/NBC Poll Disputes "Pollyanna" Pubbie View

Well, maybe everything's coming up roses.

And maybe not.

Most interesting is the poll's finding that "Jobs Going Overseas" is the #2 concern of those polled. And that ain't good news for the Pubbie Pollyannas.

At the same time, BLS reports 92K new jobs last month, (non-farm private employment) while ADP (a payroll processor) has reported only 48K. The BLS stat is WAY under 'consensus,' which expected 127K.

Merely keeping up with population growth requires about 125-140K jobs/month.

First "Sub-Prime," Now "Alt-A"

In the home mortgage market, "sub-prime" loans were the first to blow up, leading to some major problems for Bear, Stearns (and others, like American Home Mortgage, which closed its doors yesterday.)

Now the "Alt-A" loans are on the block, too. "Alt-A" loans are 'pretty good' stuff; not "prime," but better than "sub-prime." "Alt-A" is as much as 20% of originations in 2006.

... Wachovia, the seventh largest home lender, discontinued making Alt A mortgages through brokers because ``it's becoming more difficult to sell these mortgages in the secondary market as the financial markets continue to tighten,'' spokeswoman Christy Phillips-Brown said.

... SunTrust Banks Inc., the 14th largest home lender, has ``pretty much gotten out of Alt A'' for now, said Sterling Edmunds, who heads its mortgage unit.

It's RUMORED that Washington Mutual is also getting out of "Alt-A."

Mattera Speaks Clearly

Y.A.F.'s response to CAIR's threatening letter:

GO TO HELL AND TAKE YOUR 72 VIRGINS WITH YOU
That from Jason Mattera, of Young Americans for Freedom, after the Council for Kissing the Ass of Terrorists' lawyers sent a nastygram to YAF over hosting Robert Spencer as a speaker.
I like Mattera's brevity and clarity.

Kohl, Feingold Foul Selves on S.1 "Ethics" Bill

Following the unconscionable vote of Cong. Ryan and Sensenbrenner (and lots of other Members of the Party In Government), Sens. Kohl and Feingold also voted for the "Ethics" bill, S.1.

It's possible that GWB will veto it. Don't hold your breath.

Despite the spinning done by the MSM on the bill, the AP/JS account revealed the real reason this piece of crap passed:

Lawrimore [a White House spokesman] called the travel provision unworkable because a first-term president seeking re-election would have to pay extremely high sums to cover the full cost of using Air Force One on political trips. Campaign committees for presidents, who always fly on military craft for security reasons, pay the government the cost of a first-class ticket when using Air Force One, Lawrimore said.

Note the term "unworkable."

This is Step 2 in the long-term plan for Federally-financed elections, which is also Step 2 in the plan to remove "the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the government for a redress of grievances" from the 1st Amendment.

The bill's "unworkability" does not stem solely from restrictions on Presidential campaign flights. It is loaded with incomprehensible language affecting ALL Federal campaign activity--precisely because, when the Bill is declared un-Constitutional, the next "logical" step will be to ban ALL private contributions.

That's why the utterly depraved Sen. Slimegold voted for it.

Don't ask me about the excuse that Sensenbrenner and Ryan will use. There IS none.

Thursday, August 02, 2007

Death in the Milwaukee Blogger Family

Karen Marie, who posted here occasionally, has died.

In paradisum deducant te angeli; in tuo adventu suscipant te martyres; et perducant te in civitatem sanctam Ierusalem.

Always a lady.

Apocalypse Soon?

The link to Family Security is provided. Read into it what you want.

Given that, here's a piece of very practical (and easy-to-implement) advice from the article:

...if we are traveling by public transportation, we should equip ourselves with a bottle of water, a hand towel and a flashlight. He reminds us that many fatalities in the London tube and Madrid train attacks occurred from victims who breathed in the lethal fumes from bomb components and burning gasoline. Had these people had wet towels to cover their mouths and noses, they would have had a much better chance of survival.

Actually that's useful advice for 'just getting around' no matter what.

Sensenbrenner, Ryan Fail A Test

Sadly and inexplicably, both Jim Sensenbrenner (R WI/5) and Paul Ryan (R WI/1) voted for the Sleaze-and-Piggy Ethics "Reform" act of Harry (Land Office) Reid.

These men deserve scorn and derision for their act.

Sorry to say so, but that's a fact.

How bad IS this Bill? Go here for the quick-facts version.

Monomania

The Dims display their maturity:

Huebsch is wondering why the Dems aren't addressing the GOP offer, and instead offering health care items.

Decker said, "Mr. Speaker, we're going to talk about health care every day that we're at this table."

Does Decker's state-paid health insurance plan include meds which assure graduation from childhood?

Safe Squirrel Zone in Germantown

Squirrels are moving to Germantown to take advantage of the free food.

It's a Safe Squirrel Zone now:

Police last week issued a $172 ticket to a 73-year-old man who had been warned three times about shooting squirrels at his home.

The ticket was given July 22 to Ronald E. Riemer after a neighbor told police he had heard gunfire and saw two squirrels that had been killed in Riemer's yard.


According to a police report, Riemer acknowledged shooting squirrels, saying they damage his garden and eat bird food.

The article does not state whether the neighbor gave the squirrels a proper burial.

Wednesday, August 01, 2007

Subsidiarity, and the 9th and 10th

Yesterday, I opined that while Shel Lubar's concerns about fiscal responsibility in the Greater Milwaukee area are licit and compelling, that his proposal for a 'super-board' of fiscal control is not the right solution.

My line of argument was that the Principle of Subsidiarity should be respected and applied, and that the Founders, in their wisdom, wrote the 9th and 10th Amendments with that principle in mind.

A friendly interlocutor/attorney/blogger suggested (see combox in the link) that while he agrees that a "super-Board" may not be the solution, he does not think that the 9th/10th have all that much to do with "subsidiarity."

OK. Let's start by defining the terms.

Subsidiarity is the principle which states that matters ought to be handled by the smallest (or, the lowest) competent authority. The Oxford English Dictionary defines subsidiarity as the idea that a central authority should have a subsidiary function, performing only those tasks which cannot be performed effectively at a more immediate or local level. The concept is applicable in the fields of government, political science, cybernetics and management. Subsidiarity is, ideally or in principle, one of the features of federalism. (Wikipedia)

Amendment IX
The enumeration in the Constitution, of certain rights, shall not be construed to deny or disparage others retained by the people.
Amendment X
The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the states, are reserved to the states respectively, or to the people.

(Kinda convenient that Wiki even mentioned "federalism" for this discussion, no?)

Obviously, we're merely converting the Amendments to the State level--or more accurately, to the sub-State level of 'regions' and 'localities.' Resemblance to actual sub-State regions may be accidental. Names are withheld to protect the innocent. All the usual jibberish from the lottery tickets and credit card agreements apply.

Many interpreters of the Constitution begin with the understanding that the Bill of Rights 'speaks directly to the Federal Government;' that is, that the BoR expressly limits the Feds. Both the 9th and the 10th show that clearly. The 9th protects "other" individual rights not already named in the Constitution and the BoR (e.g, assembly, bearing arms, property, etc.) and the 10th protects the rights of States, 'empowering' them with what was not explicitly granted to the Feds.

Thus, early on, some States maintained a State religion (Maryland was Catholic). Other States did not. Each State must govern elections as it sees fit (subject to the 14th,) etc., etc.

With these in mind, the combox is open to Reaganite.

Defendant: Bear, Stearns

Not surprising, but another straw in the wind:

Investors in two Bear Stearns Cos. hedge funds took action against the company Wednesday for allegedly misleading them about the extent of the investment bank's exposure to risky mortgage-backed securities, a lawyer for the plaintiffs said.

The move comes as the two funds filed for bankruptcy protection, two weeks after the company told investors one was essentially worthless and the other had lost more than 90 percent of its value.

As the fate of those two funds moves into court, Bear Stearns said it moved late Tuesday to prevent investors from pulling money out of a third hedge fund, which had $850 million invested in highly rated mortgage-backed securities.

The company told investors the Asset-Backed Securities fund was not near collapse, but that it froze redemptions to prevent from being forced to sell assets to a market with little appetite for mortgage-related securities.

The 'nuclear waste' begins to spread.

We Call Them "Liturgeists" For a Reason

Although this poor young thing may be vying for an "Onion" prize, we have to take her scribblings at face value, no? On the Motu Proprio...(N.B. ("please note well" to you, Peg) her text is blue, and Fr Z's is red.)

By Peggy Lovrien, Diocesan Director of Liturgy [Winona, MN]

The vernacular text evolved as the result of careful research and scholarly work by church clergy prior to the Second Vatican Council. [WHAT!? How could dozens of vernacular translations evolve before the Latin text existed? What a mess.] The Constitution on the Sacred Liturgy (CSL), the first document of the council, articulated the result of their scholarly work and called for the use of the people’s language in the liturgy. [Noooo…. the text of Sacrosanctum Concilium did not call for the vernacular. It called for Latin to be preserved as the language of the liturgy while opening the possibility that the vernacular could be used for some parts of the Mass in some occasions.] Use of the people’s language was a value because it allowed people to knowledgeably participate in the liturgy through full, conscious, and active participation. [This is very narrow. It suggests that people cannot participate at Mass if the Mass is not in the vernacular.] The Constitution on the Sacred Liturgy laid the groundwork for the New Mass of 1969 (Novus Ordo).

For the rest of Ms. Lovrein's fantastical journey into the unknown (which in her case would be the Roman Catholic liturgy and its history) follow the link. There are several more paragraphs of sidesplitting humor available there.

The UN: Anti-Woman

When you read or hear UN propaganda, you hear about "rights of women."

Then you read about the actualities.

...international institutions like UNFPA, [UN Population Fund] created after World War II to foster development, are key drivers of the unfolding tragedy through their promotion of fertility decline as a prerequisite for human development, and fertility control as an international human right.

How does that work?

Throughout human history, demographers tell us, nature has provided about 105 male births for every 100 females. This “sex ratio at birth”—stable across generations and ethnic boundaries—may range from 103 to as high as 106 boys for every 100 girls. In only one generation, that ratio has come unglued.

A Chinese census reports ratios as high as 120–136 boys born for every 100 girls; in Taiwan, ratios of 119 boys to 100 girls; in Singapore 118 boys per 100 girls; South Korea 112 boys per 100 girls; and in India, where the practice was outlawed in 1994, the ratio continues to exceed 120 boys for every 100 girls in some areas. Countries such as Greece, Luxembourg, El Salvador, the Philippines, Cape Verde, and Egypt, even among some ethnic groups in the United States (Chinese, Japanese, and Filipino), are showing the same deadly discrimination against daughters.


What is the cause of the crisis? Experts point to a recent confluence of four main factors: rising access to sonogram technology, increased access to abortion, a preference for sons, and fertility decline.


And who, exactly, provides 'sonograms..abortion access..and fertility decline?

UNFPA,

whose latest update to its report on member-state contributions shows that eight wealthy European countries, along with Canada and Japan, pay 86% of the $389 million bill to fund that agency, which aggressively promotes population control.

And who set "population control" as a priority?

From the time Robert McNamara took the reins of the World Bank in 1968 to the latest Bank health, nutrition, and population strategy released in April, successive Bank presidents have pursued an aggressive population-control agenda, targeting developing countries.

None other than the "boy genius" of the Vietnam War. Obviously, screwing up the US military and Vietnam was hardly enough of an accomplishment for this creature.

Now that women are becoming an endangered species,

UNFPA executive director Thoraya Obaid still thinks global contraceptive use is too low and told the press in March that the world needs a “wake up call to the urgency of giving couples the means to exercise their human right to freely determine the sizes of their families.” Obaid’s remark gives us a window into the tight collaboration between U.N. development, health, and human rights officials in promoting reproductive rights. In recent years, this has included UNICEF as well

Who's next on the elimination-parade-hit-list?

...the next victims of the trend will be Africa’s baby girls. With all the other evils facing them, so far they have largely avoided the deadly violence of sex selection due to that region’s relatively high fertility rates. International organizations like UNFPA are engaging in a full-court press to increase contraceptive prevalence in Africa (now the world’s lowest at 27%) and to liberalize abortion laws by several means, including a controversial continent-wide framework called the Maputo Protocol.

Sure happy that the US helps out with UN finances.

HT: First Things

The FBI's Little Problem With Criminals

Seems that the FBI is not exactly pure as the driven snow.

Representative Delahunt: I'm not talking about the Attorney General guidelines. Do they [FBI agents] have a legal responsibility, currently, to report evidence, both exculpatory, or evidence of a crime, when a homicide is being investigated?"

Murphy: If you will indulge me Congressman, I'd like the opportunity to answer that question offline because there are various circumstances under which that question might be answered differently that would include some of the aspects about how we manage sources, how we make decisions about the management of sources. And I would appreciate the opportunity to answer that question for the record offline.


What is that all about?

The FBI does not always tell the locals that an FBI confidential informant has murdered someone while working for the FBI.

AND the FBI has 'buried' exculpatory information (thus sending the wrong people to prison) when that information suits FBI purposes.

What's it mean to you?

About $100 million in damages in the last reported settlement.

HT: Balko

"Proceed in Piggery, Peacefully"

That's the gist of the Senate's watered-down "ethics" reform bill, which seems to have the support of all the usual suspects.

And earns the disdain of Tom Coburn, who actually understands ethics (he's an MD.)

Sen. Tom Coburn, R-Okla., said he will fight the bill because it ``guts key earmark reforms.'' He noted that, unlike a previously adopted version, it would allow the majority party's leaders - not the Senate parliamentarian- to rule on whether earmark disclosure requirements have been met in bills reaching the Senate floor.

Yah--'party leaders' like Harry (Land-Office) Reid, or Helmet-Hair Lott. That inspires confidence, no?

HT: Captain's Quarters

Tuesday, July 31, 2007

News Control, Belling's Way

Heh.

Belling is fond of ranting that the MSM often "controls" the news by NOT reporting some things.

So today, he begins his show with 'the three biggest stories' in the news, telling us that they are both "business news" stories.

First he yaps about Midwest Air going bye-bye. (Scroll)

Then he yaps about Aurora purchasing a physicians' group. (Scroll)

Then he mentions that Murdoch will buy the Wall Street Journal.

What's missing?

How about a local firm writing off up to ONE BILLION DOLLARS on the subprime mortgage market?

Well, it can't be a big story if one still peddles the "everything's rosy" line...

Definition: Liberal

Tom Roeser's work:

[W]hat liberalism really is: a love of means without appreciation of ends.

Found in his essay defining Fitzgerald as a Liberal (and writing off Fred!!!)

A Curious Historical Fact

Man With a Black Hat has an interesting and curious fact about the old "People's Mass Book."

Read it here.

What bothers me is that I did not recall this...

The Motu Proprio "Won't Make a Difference Here"--Really?

A number of US Bishops have commented that the Motu Proprio allowing the 1962 Missal (the Old Rite, or Joannine Rite) will 'not make a difference' in the way things are, because 'nobody has brought it up.'

Well, "nobody" except young priests.

Two traditional priestly societies dedicated to the rite report that priests from all over the country are signing up in droves for weeklong classes to learn the rituals and language of the Mass, named after the 16th-century Council of Trent.

Monsignor Michael Schmitz, vicar-general of the Florence, Italy-based Institute of Christ the King, said he has received hundreds of calls from interested clergy.

"This is a nationwide phenomenon," he said. "Many more parish priests and younger priests are interested in learning to celebrate the Latin Mass.

"Whenever the Latin rite is celebrated, you get many young people," he added. "They are looking for something that speaks to the soul, and the beauty of the liturgy is awe-inspiring. The heartfelt presence of God really affects them."

The Elmhurst, Pa.-based Priestly Fraternity of St. Peter trained 50 priests on performing the rite this summer at its Our Lady of Guadalupe seminary in Denton, Neb.

Its September session is already full and its Elmhurst bookstore got a "big upsurge" in demand for priestly training materials within two days of the announcement, said the Rev. Carl Gismondi, a Fraternity priest studying theology at the Dominican House in the District.

Yah, hey. Try to order a Vademecum from the FSSP and you discover that it is out-of-stock. (The Vademecum contains the calendar and order-of-celebration (ordo) for every day of the Church year.)

While I agree with the Bishops that the MP will not cause some massive flight to the Joannine Rite, it ought to be clear from the above that it is certainly not another "dead letter from Rome" in the minds of young priests.

Straws In The Wind!!

HT: LACatholic

Canon 767 and Bp. Sklba

In a column which intends to make a spoonful of "lay administrators" go down one way or the other, Bp. Sklba writes the following:

The importance of preaching in the pastoral shaping of a parish community is a given for anyone who has ever filled that role. This poses challenges, given our present liturgical laws.

The "liturgical law" happens to be Canon 767. Diogenes mentions that little 'challenge':

Notice the little zinger in the last line? The "present liturgical laws" the bishop refers to is, in reality, Canon 767, by which the homily is reserved to a priest or a deacon, which in turn reflects an unbroken Catholic practice with theological roots in Romans 10 ("How shall men believe him, of whom they have not heard? And how shall they hear, without a preacher? And how shall they preach unless they be sent?" vv 14f). Clearly Sklba feels the "challenges" posed by the doctrine of Holy Orders can be overcome with a little pastoral creativity.

The Bishop gets to the edge and looks over...

We do not see that "creative" implementations of C.767 are easily found.

Good Questions on Police Procedures

Balko has a few interesting observations on a Florida case.

Singletary, you'll remember, is the elderly man in Florida who, upon seeing drug dealers on his lawn, came out with a gun to scare them off.

Unfortunately, they weren't drug dealers, but undercover cops posing as drug dealers. They shot Singletary dead. Even the police and town officials concede that Singletary was involved in no criminal activity, and was merely attempting to protect his property from what he thought were criminals.

It now looks like the cops who killed Singletary won't face criminal charges. I'm a bit conflicted on this one. But if there are no criminal charges, there should at least be some disciplinary action, at least if that "new professionalism" Justice Scalia was telling us about means anything at all.

The disturbing parts of this case:

The undercover narcotics officers were trespassing on Singletary's private property. And they were doing so to engage in drug activity. I doubt this is legal. And if it is, it shouldn't be. Unless they have a warrant, and are investigating Singletary himself (they weren't).

The state's attorney investigation found the police actions justified because Singletary "was an armed civilian who refused orders to drop his gun." But the same report criticized the police for not announcing themselves as police before they fired on Singletary. If both of these things are true, then the state's attorney is saying Singletary should have obeyed orders to drop his gun from armed men he understandably believed were dangerous, and trespassing on his property. If Florida's
new home defense law means anything at all, one would think it would mean the right to hold your ground when armed men are on your property.

Singletary was shot four times. Once in the back.


The state's attorney chose to believe police accounts of who fired first (they say Singletary) over the account of a witness who says the police fired first, because the witness is a convicted drug dealer. Seems reasonable. Except when you consider that (a) one of the police investigators changed his story about who fired first, (b) attorneys for Singletary's family have found four other witnesses who contradict the police account (why didn't the investigator talk to these people?), and (c) police take the word of convicted drug dealers as gold all the time when it comes to securing warrants for drug raids, or to prosecute other drug dealers.


Just as an aside, why isn't the National Rifle Association all over this case? I've been told they won't get involved in the Cory Maye case because of the minuscule amount of marijuana (a burnt roach) found in Maye's apartment. But Singletary was an innocent man gunned down for defending his home from what he thought were criminal trespassers. Isn't what he did what the NRA is all about?


Balko holds the Libertarian position that the "War on Drugs" is inane and silly. I don't share that view.

But they're interesting questions, anyway.

The Shark Favors Impeachment of GWB!!

Heh.

The Shark puts the spotlight on Feingold's hypocrisy:

...actually, if the President and Vice President lied their way into a war, an impeachment trial is precisely what is required. Heck, I'd support it. Feingold wants to accuse Bush and Cheney of treason without having to do anything about it. He wants to brand the President of the United States a criminal without being bothered to prove it. By divorcing accusations from consequence, his call for censure is nothing but a political trick.

Shocked!!! Shocked, I say, Rick!

Charlie Likes Lubar's Idea; Right Start, Wrong End

Charlie likes Shel Lubar's thoughts on 'the problem with Milwaukee.' (Note the endorsement of a sister-concept discussed here on Jay's blog, which should be a warning...)

After Lubar makes the obvious point--that education is important and that it ain't happening here--he goes on to ask for another layer of bureaucracy:

"...Something that I do believe is a solution, and I'm bringing this out for the first time . . . a Milwaukee metropolitan fiscal control board. A board that would have as its purpose the final approval of annual budgets of these entities: No. 1, the Milwaukee Public Schools. No. 2, MATC, or if this board didn't govern it, you could at least delegate it to the board of regents. They already make 30% or 35% more than the people at the University of Wisconsin who do have higher degrees.

The Milwaukee sewerage commission. The Wisconsin Center. The Miller Park stadium authority. . . . We've got to revise this whole governance system, and I don't think you'll find an elected person that will disagree."


Shel Lubar's been around for a long time, and is a Democrat Party regular, having been part of the Kennedy/Johnson Administration at FHA. He's a very smart guy (I met him once in the late 1960's/early 1970's and he's smart enough to have stayed away from me ever since...)

But that doesn't make him right on this suggestion.

Lubar begins with the premise that there's a lot of fiscal stupidity being practiced out there by various Gummints in the metro area. Who could disagree?

However, what Lubar SEEMS to be proposing is an un-elected Board which will (effectively) have the power to tax, or at least to control spending. The Board, as he described it, will have authority over multi-municipality and multi-county fiscal issues.

While I am certain that the idea is well-intentioned, it is, nonetheless, a shocking rejection of the principle of subsidiarity which was enshrined in the 9th/10th Amendments to the Constitution.

In brief, the principle states that 'problems should be resolved at the lowest possible level of governance.' In theory and application, 'governance' is not even required--neighbors should resolve barking-dog and lot-line disputes between themselves, if at all possible, and only after that has failed should the dispute be escalated--but then only to the next-highest level, which might be either the local cops or alderman.

You get the idea.

Lubar's 'corporate' background and methods shows here. In many (not all) successful corporate enterprises, there are lots of subsidiary businesses, but all of them get their major spending requests approved by the Big Guy CFO over at HQ. It's a model which works because the Corporate biggies are then all on the same page regarding revenue/spending/ROI, etc.

The problem is that Gummints are not 'corporate entities.' Gummints should be efficient at what they do, similar to corporations--but that's a matter of the honor and integrity of elected officials. Many Gummint operations are simply not "ROI"-measured in the strict sense.

(There's plenty of room for argument and for more precise definitions of the terms but this is a blog, not a dissertation...........)

Lubar proposes to place a group of un-elected people as more-or-less 'watchdogs' over elected people, which is precisely the BEST way to encourage more irresponsibility from the elected officials. ("It's not our call/fault/problem: it's the Board's!!") The State of Wisconsin's Legislature has a penchant for mucking around in local issues (see, e.g., the whole labrynth of "aid to schools" for an example) and has thus fostered the growth and sophistication of the "pass-the-buck" memo to unimagined heights.

Shel and Charlie want MORE of this?

Sorry, Charlie--I can't buy it, despite the goodwill and the temptation to choke the living s&^% out of those elected bozos.....

Eggster agrees, so it's unanimous.

Mind-Numbed-Robot Partisans

Uh, guys, we checked, and it ain't the Pubbies (with one exception...)

In fact, the Democrats take nine of the top ten partisan spots, as well as scoring 8 points higher in partisanship as a party. The lone Republican ties for first, though:

100% - Charlie Norwood (R-GA)100%
- Nancy Pelosi (D-CA) 99.7%
- Nita Lowey (D-NY)99.4%
- Juanita Millender-McDonald (D-CA)99.1%
- Carolyn Maloney (D-NY)98.9%
- Xavier Bacerra (D-CA)98.7%
- Diana DeGetter (D-CO)98.6%
- Gary Ackerman (D-NY)98.6%
- Hilda Solis (D-CA)98.6%
- Ellen Tauscher (D-CA)98.6%
- Al Wynn (D-MD)

And it gets even worse:

After Norwood, the next Republican comes in at 94.8%. JoAnn Davis (R-VA) ...comes in at #174 on the list of partisans -- which means that Democrats occupy all of the previous 173 slots, of those among the living, anyway.

Similarly, the Senate:

the Democrats sweep the Top Ten Partisans again:

97.8% - Dick Durbin (D-IL)
97.1% - Ben Cardin (D-MD)
97.1% - Daniel Inouye (D-HI)
97.1% - Frank Lautenberg (D-NJ)
97.0% - Joe Biden (D-DE)
97.0% - Sherrod Brown (D-OH)
96.7% - Jack Reed (D-RI)
96.7% - Sheldon Whitehouse (D-RI)
96.6% - Hillary Clinton (D-NY)
96.6% - Chuck Schumer (D-NY)

When all you can read without adult assistance is the talking points, whaddya expect?

HT: The Captain

The Reality of Che Guevara

Reality and myth are very different.

He was the chief executioner. He performed for the Cuban revolution what Heinrich Himmler performed for the Nazis. Everything Che Guevara did was directed by Fidel Castro. Early on, when they were in the mountains, Castro realized that Che seemed to relish executing little farm boys. There were executions carried out, carried out in the mountains, of so-called informers. I interviewed many people who witnessed those executions. There was no due process.

Che Guevara wrote a letter to his father in 1957 and to his abandoned wife. In the letter to her, he wrote, "I'm here in Cuba's hills, alive and thirsting for blood." Then, to his father, "I really like killing." The man was a clinical sadist, whereas Fidel Castro you could describe as a psychopath in that the murders did not affect him one way or the other. It was a means to an end - the consolidation of his one-man rule. Che has a famous quote, where he wrote, a revolutionary has to become "a cold killing machine." The thing was, Che Guevara was anything but cold. He was a warm killing machine. He relished the slaughter.

So much for the T-shirt idol...

HT: Betsy

Now, Children!! Into the Corner! Behave!!!

A newbie Milwaukee School Board member puts it in writing:

"Go to hell. . . . Don't fax me (expletive). Bruce, grow up, you stupid idiot. You are truly an arrogant (expletive). You didn't elect me and you are not my slave master."

Maybe a 'time-out' is required?

Massive Force Works

We'll give Nan and Tom some credit:

An anti-crime initiative that put Milwaukee police on patrol in some of the city's most dangerous neighborhoods this summer received credit on Monday for a nearly 22% drop in non-fatal shootings as well as a decrease in overall homicides during 2007.

Police noted that between Jan. 6 and July 29 this year, there have been 275 non-fatal shootings, down from 351 during the same period in 2006.

That is key.

Other figures included 110 firearms recovered, 50 of those involving felons possessing firearms.

"Felon-in-possession" can also be prosecuted at the Federal level, due to the hard work of the NRA. It's a Federal crime for a felon to have as little as one bullet in his possession, not to mention the weapon which fires it.

The neighborhood folks understand reality 101:

Residents in the latest targeted area said that although more patrols have put troublemakers on notice, consistency is needed in the program to keep the community safe.

That 'consistency' is also (generally) known as the Broken Windows Method. Now the question: can the MPD execute 'Broken Windows' for less than $2 million in extra spending?

Nuclear Waste Hits Milwaukee

The term "nuclear waste" is used to describe mortgages gone bad. It's now spread to the corner of Kilbourn and Water in Milwaukee.

The nation's subprime mortgage problems slammed into Milwaukee-based mortgage insurance giant MGIC Investment Corp. and its partner, which announced Monday they might have to write off their entire $1.03 billion investment in a company that backs such loans.

"MGIC has not determined the range of an impairment charge, although the upper boundary of the range could be MGIC's entire investment," the company said.

"I am not surprised that companies with subprime exposure, whether it be through an entity like this or a direct investment, are having trouble," said Terence Pavlic, president of Pavlic Investment Advisors Inc., Delafield. "When somebody is writing off up to $500 million, that is usually bad. It means something went wrong and value is being destroyed."

It doesn't take an investment advisor to point out that $500 million is a lotta bucks.

Monday, July 30, 2007

Rita Ferrone Rants on The Motu Proprio

Rita Ferrone is a resident of Mt. Vernon, N.Y., where she lives with her husband, Philip Swoboda, a professor of Russian history at Sarah Lawrence College. She is author of "Sourcebook for Sundays and Seasons, 2006," and the monograph "On the Rite of Election," and co-author of the "Foundations in Faith" series for RCIA teams. She is currently working on two new books, "Rediscovering Vatican II: The Liturgy" and a pastoral commentary on the Easter Vigil, and is a member of the faculty of the National Association of Pastoral Musicians. She is also a professor at Yale Divinity School.

With that out of the way, let's see what Ms. Ferrone has to say.

It was not the intention of Vatican II, or of the popes who implemented it, to create a situation in which two forms of the Roman rite would exist side by side.

Nor was their intention the 100% vernacular Mass, nor the dumping of all sacred music written before 1969, nor the bizarre 'on-the-fly' stuff we see far too often...

The liturgical reform of the council was intended as a true reform, addressing genuine problems of the old liturgy for the good of the church as a whole. Now, with the stroke of a pen, Pope Benedict has made that reform optional.

"Optional?" What's "ordinary" is "optional"? Right on, sistuh!

Individual priests may use the preconciliar rites at will, and groups of the faithful who ask for celebrations according to the preconciliar norms may not be refused them.

Accurate.

...A small but vocal group of Catholics began to call for a “reform of the reform” of the liturgy for the church across the board. They are not schismatics, like the Lefebvrites, but they are interested in the restoration of Tridentine liturgical forms and the marginalization of the reformed liturgy. They found a champion and supporter in the future Benedict XVI.

In fairness, only a "small but vocal" group was calling for vernacular, folk-music, and several hundred options/mutations/permutations of the Rite AFTER the Council. That "small but vocal" group was the Bugnini Consilium. Surprised Ms. Ferrone didn't mention that...

The most visible proponent of this agenda was Msgr. Klaus Gamber of the liturgical institute in Regensburg, Germany. He became known outside scholarly circles when he published a popular book in 1984, which appeared in English in 1993 under the title The Reform of the Roman Liturgy. Gamber did not reject the council. He regarded the liturgical movement leading up to the council as a generally positive phenomenon

Of course, there IS a "rest of the story" here, too. Regensburg just happens to be the location of the Liturgical Reform's home--the Reform movement which began in the late 1800's. So it's not as though Mgr Gamber was dropped into the controversy from Mars or someplace...

Gamber also expressed a definite view about the current Mass. He wanted it not to be considered the Roman rite, but merely retained as a rite ad experimentum until it dies out. Ratzinger found these extreme views congenial, and oddly enough, deemed them moderate

Really? I have read all of Cdl. R's writings on the topic of liturgy, and never have come across a statement that 'Mgr Gamber's motion to let the New Rite die out is moderate.' Never.

Another partisan of the “reform of the reform,” Alcuin Reid, OSB, of Farnborough, England, published The Organic Development of the Liturgy in 2004. In giving a positive review to Reid’s book, Ratzinger voiced some of his own views on liturgical reform. He opined that scholars and experts were heeded too much after the council,...

Look at the Consilium's roster of members. The Cardinal was correct.

Indeed, the traditionalists Benedict wants to conciliate do not simply reject the Mass of Paul VI-they reject the conciliar theology it embodies. The Society of St. Pius X published a defense of their position in 2001, ...

The invocation of SSPX is a red herring and a red-flag-before-the-bull device. Beyond that, Ms. Ferrone implies that there is some sort of "new" theology proposed by the Council's document. Of course, if one READS the Document on the Liturgy (SC), this "new" theo is not evident. Hmmmmmm.

All the rest of her flapjaw outlining the position of SSPX is irrelevant to the real discussion. She may as well be quoting the Dalai Lama.

...other core values of the council are called into question by the pope’s move to reestablish the Tridentine rites. The council emphasized the role of Scripture in the life of the church, and this value was richly reflected in the liturgical reform.

This is a valid point, to some extent. Ms Ferrone does not mention that the "translation" provided by ICEL is alternatively inaccurate, banal, childish, or exculpatory of non-PC thoughts. And that's just the easy part. She also fails to mention that the OT/NT/NT 3-year cycle used in the New Rite was not reconciled with the Propers of the Mass, nor is it necessarily "internally consistent"--that is, that the NT readings do not, consistently, reflect the OT readings. It would be very encouraging if Ms. Ferrone had endorsed a better translation, or a much-better-studied implementation of the new readings cycle.

Benedict XVI’s motu proprio implies that none of this, [expanded cycle of readings] in the end, is essential or even very important.

A ludicrous assertion, unless she actually knows the entire plan of the Pope. Which I doubt.

Before the council, women were forbidden to serve in liturgical ministries. They were kept outside the sanctuary-a very old taboo perceived by many today as sexist and out of keeping with our sense of the dignity of the baptized. This prohibition was ended after Vatican II. The third directive on the right implementation of the Constitution on the Sacred Liturgy (Liturgicae instaurationes, 1970), admitted women to various liturgical ministries which are exercised in the sanctuary-such as that of reader or musician

Not precisely true. Pius XII's legislation on the composition of church choirs (1955) paved the way for "ministries" which were not "ordained"--occupied by lay men OR women. But more to the point, Ms Ferrone attempts to conjure up the Spirits of Feminist Equality here. Like some other conjured spirits, they are out of place in a serious discussion of ecclesiology...

There was no catechumenate in the Tridentine church, despite a crying need around the world for this liturgical structure of evangelization and formation. How can we deprive adult converts of the catechumenate-which canon law now requires them to have?

So the book "Father Brown Instructs Jackson" was, what? Wallpaper? The Catechumenate was also called "adult instruction," Ms. Ferrone. Buy a clue.

The reformed liturgy embodies the values of the council in innumerable ways.

Actually, it embodies the values of a bunch of pointy-headed "experts," as the Pope remarked. And there's no need to enshrine such "values" should they differ markedly from SC (e.g., paras. 36 and 54, for openers...)

...it is difficult to believe that with Summorum pontificum a definitive compromise has been reached and the matter will end there. A more plausible understanding of the present moment is that it marks another step toward a goal that the vast majority of Catholics would not countenance if it were openly acknowledged-namely, the gradual dismantling of the liturgical reform in its entirety.

She's right--until the italicized portion begins. Ms. Ferrone thinks (with absolutely zero proof) that "the vast majority" of Catholics will agree with her. I doubt it, although it's possible that the "vast majority" of NAPM Directors, Catechetical Establishment rent-seekers/hangers-on, and members of the Yale Divinity School faculty do agree with her. So what?

I believe that the Second Vatican Council and its reforms were the work of the Spirit. Yet these reforms were also the work of human hands, and in this respect they are vulnerable. We do ourselves no favors by pretending otherwise.

Right on all counts, Ms. Ferrone. And the "work of human hands" occasionally needs correctives. CF: Summorum Pontificum.

(More, (and better-informed) commentary here from Fr. Z.)

A Look at the Inner City Forum on Crime (Etc.)

Not only a good look at the speakers, but an imaginative one--

James T.'s New Digs and Restaurant Reviews.

I hope he keeps this up because he is informed and informative.

Kevin Takes on the Priest

The Franklin Guy, aka Kevin Fisher, doesn't always like what he hears from the pulpit.

...the visiting priest during his homily suddenly launched into a loud dissertation about child abusers and the general attitude most people have towards them. He gestured with his hands and asked everyone in the pews if they wouldn’t like to warp their hands around the throat of a child abuser. The priest used similar rhetoric about identity thieves and illegal immigrants.

The rhetoric is inflammatory. This priest is either ignorant or deliberately provocative. I'd prefer that the former be the case; but then, we have to ask "who let him out without a complete education?" If it is the latter, he needs remedial work with someone who actually knows something about the world.

Because of this deliberately provocative and ignorant beginning, he manages to achieve exactly the wrong result:

I was not impressed or convinced.

[I find] it extremely difficult, if not damn near impossible to forgive vicious criminals or illegal immigrants, many of whom are vicious criminals, am I rejecting my faith, neglecting to follow its teachings?

Umnhnhhh... all that stuff about 'seventy times seven', Kevin...

Were the priest to have begun with that particular verse (70x7) and worked his way through, sympathetically speaking to those of us who 'find it extremely difficult' to forgive, one suspects that the result may have been different. It is our obligation to forgive, difficult as it may be.

But "forgiving" the trespass does not mean "forgetting" the punishment due the trespasser; nor does it imply that "forgivers" are idiots who will leave their children unattended around a convicted molester.

And just to show you how that works, I forgive the priest who made those asinine remarks.

Sunday, July 29, 2007

"Glory and Praise" In Perspective

Anthony Esolen, with bit HT to The Jester.

I've recently been strapping on the swamp boots to wade through something called Glory and Praise, perhaps the most commonly used Roman Catholic hymnal in the United States and Canada. Oh, it is sloppy and noisome work, logging the bathos, stupidity, banality, heresy, and textual vandalism. I've concluded, though, that there is one factor that touches every problem, something that helps explain these apparently disparate acts of mischief:

-- the neutering of old masculine language about mankind and even God

-- the heedless fouling up of the old poetry, to update a "thou" and a "thee"

-- the seizing of every chance to talk about dancing (not to be found in the New Testament, I suspect, unless it's Salome) and about the motherhood of God"

-- in general, the louche emphasis upon feelings, not repentance, but soft and syrupy feelings

-- the blithe arrogation of God's words to ourselves, speaking in the first person

-- the arrogation of God's grace and majesty to ourselves: "We are the Bread, we are the Body"-- the celebration of our own wonderfulness, and the decrying of sin-- that is, other people's sins

-- the abandonment of traditional liturgical forms, traditional poetry and song -- all relegated to the status of the "old fashioned," for trotting out, like Grandmama's silver, at certain feasts, and that's it

-- the passing along of counterfeit "folk" music, actually performance music, like "Do You Remember the Kind of September," only not nearly as good

-- the mincing baby-talk in the verses, along with a bogus primitivism, a la the Indians in Hollywood: "You are child of the universe."

It's narcissism, all of it. It's the pretty boy at the side of the pool, gazing upon his image in the water, ignoring his parents, the woman in love with him, the reality of the world around him. He wants to remain a pretty boy forever -- he wants a disembodied "union" with no ties to the past, no duties to his fellows, and no law to obey. It's music that encourages a choir full of American Idols, shimmying and shaking and calling attention to themselves, while envying one another (I'll bet some of our bloggers have stories about infighting among the twenty self-appointed soloists of a "Christian" choir).

What's missing from the hymnal? Oh, music, poetry -- and one thing above all: the Cross. The Cross sure does seem a fine cure for narcissism. In all our arguments about ordination and (in the Catholic church) lay "ministry," nobody ever says, "I want the right to be ordained a priest because I demand to be crucified!" Or, "I want to serve as a lector because I want to be crucified!" Hardly -- these things and many more are considered clerical plums that everybody ought to be able to pop in the mouth, if they choose. We are Church, don't you know, not to mention Bread and Body and God Almighty. If there is a single new "hymn" that is written in the shadow of the Cross, encouraging the taking up of what will leave your back stooped and your shoulders cut with splinters, I haven't seen it. Meanwhile, a part of my own crucifixion seems to be the necessity of listening to it all, and watching the performers. Silence would be infinitely better.

That sums it up well.