Wednesday, March 21, 2007
On Gonzales
Despite the strained and silly yapping from the "right" radio folks, Tom Roeser also thinks that Gonzales should be cut loose:
To this old ex-federal bureaucrat who has just completed an inside look-see at the Justice Department through several past and present sources, there was something wrong with the appointment of Alberto Gonzales as AG in the first place. Close to George Bush he may be but the indistinct image coming through of a namby-pamby on abortion has bothered social conservatives from the outset. He doesn’t speak on the square; looks shifty-eyed; acts like a junior clerk. The frequent lying, misstatements and corrections shows an insecure man at the helm. My one fear was that Bush would name him to the Supreme Court for the next opening. This call for his resignation-which may very well happen-could be a godsend.
While GWB will not fire Gonzales (an honorable position to take,) Gonzales could still resign.
That would allow Bush to appoint an AG who actually has some curiosity about the dealings of Sandy "Hotpants" Burglar, the Border Patrol's supervisors, and like that, you know.
To this old ex-federal bureaucrat who has just completed an inside look-see at the Justice Department through several past and present sources, there was something wrong with the appointment of Alberto Gonzales as AG in the first place. Close to George Bush he may be but the indistinct image coming through of a namby-pamby on abortion has bothered social conservatives from the outset. He doesn’t speak on the square; looks shifty-eyed; acts like a junior clerk. The frequent lying, misstatements and corrections shows an insecure man at the helm. My one fear was that Bush would name him to the Supreme Court for the next opening. This call for his resignation-which may very well happen-could be a godsend.
While GWB will not fire Gonzales (an honorable position to take,) Gonzales could still resign.
That would allow Bush to appoint an AG who actually has some curiosity about the dealings of Sandy "Hotpants" Burglar, the Border Patrol's supervisors, and like that, you know.
Extraordinary Ministers to Disappear?
Well, it would be a good thing, considering the nature of the Sacrament (thus, its administration.) Benedict XVI understands that, and apparently is insisting on making EEMs (EHMCs) an extinct species, with very few exceptions.
Karl Keating's periodical has an article, here partially excerpted by Phil Blosser:
The discussion of EMHCs [Extraordinary Ministers of Holy Communion] in the Catholic Answers Report comes under the subtitle: "Role of Extraordinary Ministers Trimmed."
"Rome has been concerned about the widespread overuse of extraordinary ministers of Holy Communion in many countries and particularly in the U.S., where extraordinary ministers are often treated as an ordinary part of Mass," states the article.
The ordinary ministers, of course, are "priests, deacons, and instituted acolytes." (What's the last time you've spotted an instituted acolyte around your suburban parish?) Canon law permits the use of EMHCs when there are too many communicants present to be served in a "reasonable period of time" by the ordinary ministers. To its credit, the Report is straight up about this:
But in recent years, many liturgists adopted an ideology that tries to blur the line between clergy and laity at Mass, and extraordinary ministers became one of the key ways used to advance their agenda. Large numbers of extraordinary ministers were used on a regular basis -- far more than were actually needed. In some places, extraordinary ministers were used to distribute Communion while a perfectly healthy priest simply sat down and waited out the Communion rite.
An attempt was also made to gloss over the extraordinary character of their service. In many places they came to be referred to as simply "special ministers" or even "eucharistic ministers" -- hiding the fact that they are to be used only in extraordinary circumstances.
The good news is that the Holy See appears to be reining in these abuses. In a series of recent documents, the Vatican has emphasized that EMHCs should be used only when there are too many communicants for the ordinary ministers to "reasonably serve." There is some evidence that the Vatican is going beyond repeating earlier instructions with their implicit escape clauses, however. In October 2006 it was announced that Pope Benedict had decided not to renew the United States indult that allowed EMHCs to purify the vessels after Mass. From now on, Americans will have the same rule that applies throughout the world, and vessels are to be purified only by ordinary ministers -- "priests, deacons, and instituted acolytes."
Going back to the 'alter Christi' nature of the ordained priest, this is not real difficult to place in context. Christ fed the 12 at the Last Supper; with his Apostles He fed the 5,000. This "feeding" was a corporeal symbol for spiritual nourishment. If the command "Feed my lambs..." has any meaning, it should be most evident at Communion.
And, as Blosser points out, if it is to be demeaned, this is the very best place to start.
Karl Keating's periodical has an article, here partially excerpted by Phil Blosser:
The discussion of EMHCs [Extraordinary Ministers of Holy Communion] in the Catholic Answers Report comes under the subtitle: "Role of Extraordinary Ministers Trimmed."
"Rome has been concerned about the widespread overuse of extraordinary ministers of Holy Communion in many countries and particularly in the U.S., where extraordinary ministers are often treated as an ordinary part of Mass," states the article.
The ordinary ministers, of course, are "priests, deacons, and instituted acolytes." (What's the last time you've spotted an instituted acolyte around your suburban parish?) Canon law permits the use of EMHCs when there are too many communicants present to be served in a "reasonable period of time" by the ordinary ministers. To its credit, the Report is straight up about this:
But in recent years, many liturgists adopted an ideology that tries to blur the line between clergy and laity at Mass, and extraordinary ministers became one of the key ways used to advance their agenda. Large numbers of extraordinary ministers were used on a regular basis -- far more than were actually needed. In some places, extraordinary ministers were used to distribute Communion while a perfectly healthy priest simply sat down and waited out the Communion rite.
An attempt was also made to gloss over the extraordinary character of their service. In many places they came to be referred to as simply "special ministers" or even "eucharistic ministers" -- hiding the fact that they are to be used only in extraordinary circumstances.
The good news is that the Holy See appears to be reining in these abuses. In a series of recent documents, the Vatican has emphasized that EMHCs should be used only when there are too many communicants for the ordinary ministers to "reasonably serve." There is some evidence that the Vatican is going beyond repeating earlier instructions with their implicit escape clauses, however. In October 2006 it was announced that Pope Benedict had decided not to renew the United States indult that allowed EMHCs to purify the vessels after Mass. From now on, Americans will have the same rule that applies throughout the world, and vessels are to be purified only by ordinary ministers -- "priests, deacons, and instituted acolytes."
Going back to the 'alter Christi' nature of the ordained priest, this is not real difficult to place in context. Christ fed the 12 at the Last Supper; with his Apostles He fed the 5,000. This "feeding" was a corporeal symbol for spiritual nourishment. If the command "Feed my lambs..." has any meaning, it should be most evident at Communion.
And, as Blosser points out, if it is to be demeaned, this is the very best place to start.
Taxpayers' Bill of Rights
Short and sweet:
1. Taxpayers have a right to have a federal government that does not grow beyond their ability to pay for it.
2. Taxpayers have a right to receive back each dollar that they entrust to the government for their retirement.
3. Taxpayers have a right to expect the government to balance the budget without having their taxes raised.
4. Taxpayers have a right to a simple, fair tax code that they can understand.
Republican Study Committee put this out, with good reason.
Naturally, with the exception of #2, this applies perforce to Madistan. Of course, we'd have to get rid of a few "Republicans" before it could occur there, too.
Got that, Luther and Carol?
1. Taxpayers have a right to have a federal government that does not grow beyond their ability to pay for it.
2. Taxpayers have a right to receive back each dollar that they entrust to the government for their retirement.
3. Taxpayers have a right to expect the government to balance the budget without having their taxes raised.
4. Taxpayers have a right to a simple, fair tax code that they can understand.
Republican Study Committee put this out, with good reason.
Naturally, with the exception of #2, this applies perforce to Madistan. Of course, we'd have to get rid of a few "Republicans" before it could occur there, too.
Got that, Luther and Carol?
Tuesday, March 20, 2007
Blogroll Addition
Atomic Trousers, who is the re-incarnation of York, has begun Blog #2. Link at the sidebar.
He's good. Really good.
He's good. Really good.
R. Miller (First Things) Takes on the Cardinal, Badly
Robert Miller, an attorney, thinks that Cdl. Crepaldi is ...inaccurate.
Crepaldi: “Public reason is not possible in a culture that is dominated by the ‘dictatorship of relativism’ [a phrase from Benedict XVI], for a very simple reason: Relativism is a dogma and therefore it a priori rejects rational argumentation, even toward itself. . . . Relativism [denies] a capability of reason to argue truth . . . [and so] prevents the use of public reason.”
Miller: Just as a sociological matter, this should give us pause. Generally speaking, our society is more concerned with producing and responding to arguments than probably any other in the history of the world. Whether the issue is abortion or gay rights, tax policy or the trade deficit, global warming or third-world debt, everyone seems ready to adduce arguments in support of some position or other.
We suppose that Mr. Miller, an eminento in the constellation of First Things, is attached to 'argumentation-American-style.' But he chooses to miss the point of the Cardinal's discussion.
Of course, that has to do with the Cardinal's ignorance and/or blindness: The answer is that Crepaldi is in the grip of a serious misconception about the modern world common among Catholic thinkers.
Actually, Mr. Miller, the Catholic weltaunschuung is more comprehensive than your Positivist/Calvinist one, but...
That is, Crepaldi thinks it’s a foundational (and mistaken) premise of modern culture that the province of reason comprises natural science and mathematics, with everything else—including normative disciplines like morals or politics—being the province of subjective opinion, a realm in which no statement is objectively true or false.
Unhhh....not really. The "dictatorship" to which the Cardinal refers is 'relativistic' insofar as it acknowledges no Authority--and certainly not an Authority who was crucified; rather, it worships (or at least give fealty) to Positivist make-do, not eternal realities. (Shall we discuss the Relativist Judiciary of Roe? Or the Relativist regency of Economics?)
You'll have to do better in your next, promised, installment.
Crepaldi: “Public reason is not possible in a culture that is dominated by the ‘dictatorship of relativism’ [a phrase from Benedict XVI], for a very simple reason: Relativism is a dogma and therefore it a priori rejects rational argumentation, even toward itself. . . . Relativism [denies] a capability of reason to argue truth . . . [and so] prevents the use of public reason.”
Miller: Just as a sociological matter, this should give us pause. Generally speaking, our society is more concerned with producing and responding to arguments than probably any other in the history of the world. Whether the issue is abortion or gay rights, tax policy or the trade deficit, global warming or third-world debt, everyone seems ready to adduce arguments in support of some position or other.
We suppose that Mr. Miller, an eminento in the constellation of First Things, is attached to 'argumentation-American-style.' But he chooses to miss the point of the Cardinal's discussion.
Of course, that has to do with the Cardinal's ignorance and/or blindness: The answer is that Crepaldi is in the grip of a serious misconception about the modern world common among Catholic thinkers.
Actually, Mr. Miller, the Catholic weltaunschuung is more comprehensive than your Positivist/Calvinist one, but...
That is, Crepaldi thinks it’s a foundational (and mistaken) premise of modern culture that the province of reason comprises natural science and mathematics, with everything else—including normative disciplines like morals or politics—being the province of subjective opinion, a realm in which no statement is objectively true or false.
Unhhh....not really. The "dictatorship" to which the Cardinal refers is 'relativistic' insofar as it acknowledges no Authority--and certainly not an Authority who was crucified; rather, it worships (or at least give fealty) to Positivist make-do, not eternal realities. (Shall we discuss the Relativist Judiciary of Roe? Or the Relativist regency of Economics?)
You'll have to do better in your next, promised, installment.
Monday, March 19, 2007
Spend More, Borrow More, Screw the Children!
That's the Doylie philosophy.
...officials with the state Department of Natural Resources as they push for reauthorization of the state's land- buying Knowles-Nelson Stewardship Fund and for a substantial increase in the amount of money the agency would be allowed to borrow to buy land under the program.
Scott Hassett, DNR secretary, argued before the state Legislature's Joint Finance Committee last week that an increase in borrowing authority from $60 million to $105 million a year is necessary because of soaring land prices.
Joint Finance Committee co-chair Kitty Rhoades, R-Hudson, said the DNR may be interested in protecting the land but that the committee has to consider the financial implications, especially when the state is spending more than it is taking in.
"We are also leaving our grandchildren a legacy of debt," said Rhoades of continued land purchases.
Joe Polasek, director of management and budget for the DNR, said that since the fund's inception in 1989, it has cost about $1.2 billion to repay, with interest, the $803 million that has been borrowed for land purchases.
Paying off loans of $105 million a year between 2010 and 2020 will cost about $1.6 billion, Polasek said. [In other words, the State will borrow $1.05 billion and pay $1.6 billion.]
Obviously, buying a bunch of land is really, really, really important, no matter WHAT the cost.
...officials with the state Department of Natural Resources as they push for reauthorization of the state's land- buying Knowles-Nelson Stewardship Fund and for a substantial increase in the amount of money the agency would be allowed to borrow to buy land under the program.
Scott Hassett, DNR secretary, argued before the state Legislature's Joint Finance Committee last week that an increase in borrowing authority from $60 million to $105 million a year is necessary because of soaring land prices.
Joint Finance Committee co-chair Kitty Rhoades, R-Hudson, said the DNR may be interested in protecting the land but that the committee has to consider the financial implications, especially when the state is spending more than it is taking in.
"We are also leaving our grandchildren a legacy of debt," said Rhoades of continued land purchases.
Joe Polasek, director of management and budget for the DNR, said that since the fund's inception in 1989, it has cost about $1.2 billion to repay, with interest, the $803 million that has been borrowed for land purchases.
Paying off loans of $105 million a year between 2010 and 2020 will cost about $1.6 billion, Polasek said. [In other words, the State will borrow $1.05 billion and pay $1.6 billion.]
Obviously, buying a bunch of land is really, really, really important, no matter WHAT the cost.
DNR Mandates Nuke Power for Wisconsin
Don't you wish?
Actually, that may be the result of their latest move:
Proposed regulations to reduce mercury emissions from electric generating plants by 90 percent by 2020 are stirring debate about pollution, utility costs and nuclear power.
On Thursday, the state Department of Natural Resources, responding to a request by Gov. Jim Doyle, proposed rules that would exceed those of the federal government and remove Wisconsin from a national program which would allow utilities to buy credits for out-of-compliance plants.
Lawniczak [Director, Enviro Services, Wisconsin Public Service] said no technology now exists to allow plants to achieve a 90 percent reduction.
Which leaves two options: 1) Simply shut down the coal plants. 2) Go Nuke!
Actually, that may be the result of their latest move:
Proposed regulations to reduce mercury emissions from electric generating plants by 90 percent by 2020 are stirring debate about pollution, utility costs and nuclear power.
On Thursday, the state Department of Natural Resources, responding to a request by Gov. Jim Doyle, proposed rules that would exceed those of the federal government and remove Wisconsin from a national program which would allow utilities to buy credits for out-of-compliance plants.
Lawniczak [Director, Enviro Services, Wisconsin Public Service] said no technology now exists to allow plants to achieve a 90 percent reduction.
Which leaves two options: 1) Simply shut down the coal plants. 2) Go Nuke!
Tool Dictionary
Stolen from Clay Cramer. Accurate, concise, comprehensive.
DRILL PRESS: A tall upright machine useful for suddenly snatching flat metal bar stock out of your hands so that it smacks you in the chest and flings your beer across the room, splattering it against that freshly-stained heirloom piece you were drying.
WIRE WHEEL: Cleans paint off bolts and then throws them somewhere under the workbench at the speed of light. Also removes fingerprints and hard-earned guitar calluses from fingers in about the time it takes you to say, "Son of aĆ¢?¦.."
ELECTRIC HAND DRILL: Normally used for spinning pop rivets in their holes until you die of old age.
SKIL SAW: A portable cutting tool used to make studs too short.
PLIERS: Used to round off bolt heads. Sometimes used in the creation of blood-blisters. The most often used tool by all women.
BELT SANDER: An electric sanding tool commonly used to convert minor touch-up jobs into major refinishing jobs.
HACKSAW: One of a family of cutting tools built on the Ouija board principle. It transforms human energy into a crooked, unpredictable motion, and the more you attempt to influence its course, the more dismal your future becomes.
VISE-GRIPS: Generally used after pliers to completely round off bolt heads. If nothing else is available, they can also be used to transfer intense welding heat to the palm of your hand.
WELDING GLOVES: Heavy duty leather gloves used to prolong the conduction of intense welding heat to the palm of your hand.
OXYACETYLENE TORCH: Used almost entirely for lighting various flammable objects in your shop on fire. Also handy for igniting the grease inside the wheel hub you want the bearing race out of.
WHITWORTH SOCKETS: Once used for working on older British cars and motorcycles, they are now used mainly for impersonating that 9/16 or 1/2 inch socket you've been searching for the last 45 minutes.
TABLE SAW: A large stationary power tool commonly used to launch wood projectiles for testing wall integrity.
HYDRAULIC FLOOR JACK: Used for lowering an automobile to the ground after you have installed your new brake hose, trapping the jack handle firmly under the bumper.
EIGHT-FOOT LONG YELLOW PINE 2X4: Used for levering an automobile upward off of a trapped hydraulic jack handle.
TWEEZERS: A tool for removing wood splinters and wire wheel wires.
E-Z OUT BOLT AND STUD EXTRACTOR: A tool ten times harder than any known drill bit that snaps neatly off in bolt holes thereby ending any possible future use.
RADIAL ARM SAW: A large stationary power saw primarily used by most shops to scare neophytes into choosing another line of work.
TWO-TON ENGINE HOIST: A tool for testing the maximum tensile strength of everything you forgot to disconnect.
CRAFTSMAN 1/2 x 24-INCH SCREWDRIVER: A very large pry bar that inexplicably has an accurately machined screwdriver tip on the end opposite the handle.
AVIATION METAL SNIPS: See hacksaw.
TROUBLE LIGHT: The home mechanic's own tanning booth. Sometimes called a drop light, it is a good source of vitamin D, "the sunshine vitamin," which is not otherwise found under cars at night. Health benefits aside, its main purpose to consume 40-watt light bulbs at about thesame rate that 105mm howitzer shells might be used during, say, the first few hours of the Battle of the Bulge. More often dark than light, its name is somewhat misleading.
PHILLIPS SCREWDRIVER: Normally used to stab the vacuum seals under lids and for opening old-style paper-and-tin oil cans and splashing oil on your shirt; but can also be used, as the name implies, to strip out Phillips screw heads. Women excel at using this tool.
STRAIGHT SCREWDRIVER: A tool for opening paint cans. Sometimes used to convert common slotted screws into non-removable screws.
AIR COMPRESSOR: A machine that takes energy produced in a coal-burning power plant 200 miles away and ransforms it into compressed air that travels by hose to a Chicago Pneumatic impact wrench that grips rusty bolts which were last overtightened 30 years ago by someone at Ford, and instantly rounds off their heads. Also used to quickly snap off lug nuts.
PRY BAR: A tool used to crumple the metal surrounding that clip or bracket you needed to remove in order to replace a 50 cent part.
HOSE CUTTER: A tool used to make hoses too short.
HAMMER: Originally employed as a weapon of war, the hammer nowadays is used as a kind of divining rod to locate the most expensive parts adjacent the object we are trying to hit. Women primarily use it to make gaping holes in walls when hanging pictures.
MECHANIC'S KNIFE: Used to open and slice through the contents of cardboard cartons delivered to your front door; works particularly well on contents such as seats, vinyl records, liquids in plastic bottles, collector magazines, refund checks, and rubber or plastic parts. Especially useful for slicing work clothes, but only while in use.
DAMMIT TOOL: Any handy tool that you grab and throw across the garage while yelling "DAMMIT" at the top of your lungs. It is also, most often, the next tool that you will need.
CONSTRUCTION AND HOME WORKSHOP TOOL DEFINITIONS
DRILL PRESS: A tall upright machine useful for suddenly snatching flat metal bar stock out of your hands so that it smacks you in the chest and flings your beer across the room, splattering it against that freshly-stained heirloom piece you were drying.
WIRE WHEEL: Cleans paint off bolts and then throws them somewhere under the workbench at the speed of light. Also removes fingerprints and hard-earned guitar calluses from fingers in about the time it takes you to say, "Son of aĆ¢?¦.."
ELECTRIC HAND DRILL: Normally used for spinning pop rivets in their holes until you die of old age.
SKIL SAW: A portable cutting tool used to make studs too short.
PLIERS: Used to round off bolt heads. Sometimes used in the creation of blood-blisters. The most often used tool by all women.
BELT SANDER: An electric sanding tool commonly used to convert minor touch-up jobs into major refinishing jobs.
HACKSAW: One of a family of cutting tools built on the Ouija board principle. It transforms human energy into a crooked, unpredictable motion, and the more you attempt to influence its course, the more dismal your future becomes.
VISE-GRIPS: Generally used after pliers to completely round off bolt heads. If nothing else is available, they can also be used to transfer intense welding heat to the palm of your hand.
WELDING GLOVES: Heavy duty leather gloves used to prolong the conduction of intense welding heat to the palm of your hand.
OXYACETYLENE TORCH: Used almost entirely for lighting various flammable objects in your shop on fire. Also handy for igniting the grease inside the wheel hub you want the bearing race out of.
WHITWORTH SOCKETS: Once used for working on older British cars and motorcycles, they are now used mainly for impersonating that 9/16 or 1/2 inch socket you've been searching for the last 45 minutes.
TABLE SAW: A large stationary power tool commonly used to launch wood projectiles for testing wall integrity.
HYDRAULIC FLOOR JACK: Used for lowering an automobile to the ground after you have installed your new brake hose, trapping the jack handle firmly under the bumper.
EIGHT-FOOT LONG YELLOW PINE 2X4: Used for levering an automobile upward off of a trapped hydraulic jack handle.
TWEEZERS: A tool for removing wood splinters and wire wheel wires.
E-Z OUT BOLT AND STUD EXTRACTOR: A tool ten times harder than any known drill bit that snaps neatly off in bolt holes thereby ending any possible future use.
RADIAL ARM SAW: A large stationary power saw primarily used by most shops to scare neophytes into choosing another line of work.
TWO-TON ENGINE HOIST: A tool for testing the maximum tensile strength of everything you forgot to disconnect.
CRAFTSMAN 1/2 x 24-INCH SCREWDRIVER: A very large pry bar that inexplicably has an accurately machined screwdriver tip on the end opposite the handle.
AVIATION METAL SNIPS: See hacksaw.
TROUBLE LIGHT: The home mechanic's own tanning booth. Sometimes called a drop light, it is a good source of vitamin D, "the sunshine vitamin," which is not otherwise found under cars at night. Health benefits aside, its main purpose to consume 40-watt light bulbs at about thesame rate that 105mm howitzer shells might be used during, say, the first few hours of the Battle of the Bulge. More often dark than light, its name is somewhat misleading.
PHILLIPS SCREWDRIVER: Normally used to stab the vacuum seals under lids and for opening old-style paper-and-tin oil cans and splashing oil on your shirt; but can also be used, as the name implies, to strip out Phillips screw heads. Women excel at using this tool.
STRAIGHT SCREWDRIVER: A tool for opening paint cans. Sometimes used to convert common slotted screws into non-removable screws.
AIR COMPRESSOR: A machine that takes energy produced in a coal-burning power plant 200 miles away and ransforms it into compressed air that travels by hose to a Chicago Pneumatic impact wrench that grips rusty bolts which were last overtightened 30 years ago by someone at Ford, and instantly rounds off their heads. Also used to quickly snap off lug nuts.
PRY BAR: A tool used to crumple the metal surrounding that clip or bracket you needed to remove in order to replace a 50 cent part.
HOSE CUTTER: A tool used to make hoses too short.
HAMMER: Originally employed as a weapon of war, the hammer nowadays is used as a kind of divining rod to locate the most expensive parts adjacent the object we are trying to hit. Women primarily use it to make gaping holes in walls when hanging pictures.
MECHANIC'S KNIFE: Used to open and slice through the contents of cardboard cartons delivered to your front door; works particularly well on contents such as seats, vinyl records, liquids in plastic bottles, collector magazines, refund checks, and rubber or plastic parts. Especially useful for slicing work clothes, but only while in use.
DAMMIT TOOL: Any handy tool that you grab and throw across the garage while yelling "DAMMIT" at the top of your lungs. It is also, most often, the next tool that you will need.
Sunday, March 18, 2007
Counter-Protest? WHAT Counter-Protest?
As usual, the MSM doesn't get it:
Yup, the journalistic standard-bearers of the NYTimes relied on "several veterans of the antiwar movement" to give them crowd estimates of the Gathering of Eagles. It's the domestic equivalent of MSMers relying on dubious Iraqi stringers to provide them with war coverage while they sit in their comfy Green Zone offices in D.C. and Manhattan.
...when stating that "several hundred" counter-protesters showed up in D.C.
In reality, (not where the MSM lives), the National Park Service estimated 30,000 "Gathering of Eagles" counter-protesters.
TWO local MSM outlets (Channels 6 & 4) mentioned "counter-protesters." Damn nice of them.
A pure, grass-roots effort, the Gathering of Eagles' volunteers matched the massive Soros-funded anti-war machine sign for sign, chant for chant, and marcher for marcher. The contrast was most stark right before the entrance to the Memorial Bridge, where Eagles gathered with a field of American flags--while anti-Bush, 9/11 conspiracy nuts wrapped themselves in a figurative blanket of yellow "Out of Iraq" placards.
Somehow the locals were not able to provide numbers for EITHER group, although Moonbattery suggests that the Eagles OUTNUMBERED the wackos 3 to 1.
HT: Malkin
Yup, the journalistic standard-bearers of the NYTimes relied on "several veterans of the antiwar movement" to give them crowd estimates of the Gathering of Eagles. It's the domestic equivalent of MSMers relying on dubious Iraqi stringers to provide them with war coverage while they sit in their comfy Green Zone offices in D.C. and Manhattan.
...when stating that "several hundred" counter-protesters showed up in D.C.
In reality, (not where the MSM lives), the National Park Service estimated 30,000 "Gathering of Eagles" counter-protesters.
TWO local MSM outlets (Channels 6 & 4) mentioned "counter-protesters." Damn nice of them.
A pure, grass-roots effort, the Gathering of Eagles' volunteers matched the massive Soros-funded anti-war machine sign for sign, chant for chant, and marcher for marcher. The contrast was most stark right before the entrance to the Memorial Bridge, where Eagles gathered with a field of American flags--while anti-Bush, 9/11 conspiracy nuts wrapped themselves in a figurative blanket of yellow "Out of Iraq" placards.
Somehow the locals were not able to provide numbers for EITHER group, although Moonbattery suggests that the Eagles OUTNUMBERED the wackos 3 to 1.
HT: Malkin
Angels--A Primer, Humorous
When this guy is 'on', he's really 'ON.'
So go here and learn a few facts, and get some farce, as well.
I'll just give you the last line, which is a touch sardonic:
I, for one, find it quite odd that the western world is fixated on little small floating half-naked little children. But what do I know?
So go here and learn a few facts, and get some farce, as well.
I'll just give you the last line, which is a touch sardonic:
I, for one, find it quite odd that the western world is fixated on little small floating half-naked little children. But what do I know?
Saturday, March 17, 2007
Who ARE These Jerks?
"One Wisconsin Now" seems to have a pathological problem with nosiness.
...One Wisconsin Now Action asked for a listing of all phone calls made from Ziegler's office phone in the Washington County courthouse from June 2005 through January 2007.
...Washington County Finance Director Susan Haag released 37 pages of records listing 1,184 phone calls, both incoming and outgoing, with all the phone numbers blacked out. Haag is the legal custodian of the records since her office pays the phone bills, she said.
"This delayed and incomplete response is unacceptable," One Wisconsin Now Action spokesman Cory Liebmann wrote in a news release Friday. "It raises serious questions about Annette Ziegler's respect for and commitment to our Wisconsin tradition of fair and open government."
Of course, Liebmann is lying. Ziegler had no input into the release (or non-release.) It was handled by Ms. Haag; the phone utilization and records are Washington County's, not Ziegler's.
Might be interesting to get the complete phone records (in- and out-bound) from "One Wisconsin Now," no?
Or would that be called chutzpah?
...One Wisconsin Now Action asked for a listing of all phone calls made from Ziegler's office phone in the Washington County courthouse from June 2005 through January 2007.
...Washington County Finance Director Susan Haag released 37 pages of records listing 1,184 phone calls, both incoming and outgoing, with all the phone numbers blacked out. Haag is the legal custodian of the records since her office pays the phone bills, she said.
"This delayed and incomplete response is unacceptable," One Wisconsin Now Action spokesman Cory Liebmann wrote in a news release Friday. "It raises serious questions about Annette Ziegler's respect for and commitment to our Wisconsin tradition of fair and open government."
Of course, Liebmann is lying. Ziegler had no input into the release (or non-release.) It was handled by Ms. Haag; the phone utilization and records are Washington County's, not Ziegler's.
Might be interesting to get the complete phone records (in- and out-bound) from "One Wisconsin Now," no?
Or would that be called chutzpah?
DarthDoyle Goes National
Heh.
Our Governor, Darth ("Killing Embryos Is a Cure") has a reputation which extends to the east. In the State of Virginia, one finds a gun shop, and in the gun shop:
Bloomberg's face graces a poster taped to a shotgun rack at Bob Moates, under the words "Here are our worst enemy." Sarah Brady, of the Brady Campaign to Prevent Gun Violence, and Wisconsin Gov. Jim Doyle are also pictured, though Bloomberg's face is circled in bright pink highlighter.
Those guys don't know the HALF of it...
Our Governor, Darth ("Killing Embryos Is a Cure") has a reputation which extends to the east. In the State of Virginia, one finds a gun shop, and in the gun shop:
Bloomberg's face graces a poster taped to a shotgun rack at Bob Moates, under the words "Here are our worst enemy." Sarah Brady, of the Brady Campaign to Prevent Gun Violence, and Wisconsin Gov. Jim Doyle are also pictured, though Bloomberg's face is circled in bright pink highlighter.
Those guys don't know the HALF of it...
Friday, March 16, 2007
Stanley Hauerwas on "Rights"
Here's something to think about. Hauerwas is a well-known and respected theologian, published frequently in First Things.
...Indeed I want to argue that America is the only country that has the misfortune of being founded on a philosophical mistake--namely, the notion of inalienable rights. We Christians do not believe that we have inalienable rights. That is the false presumption of Enlightenment individualism, and it opposes everything that Christians believe about what it means to be a creature. Notice that the issue is inalienable rights. Rights make a certain sense as correlative to duties and goods, but they are not inalienable. For example, when the lords protested against the king in the Magna Charta, they did so in the name of their duties to their underlings. Duties, not rights, were primary. The rights were simply ways of remembering what the duties were.
Christians, to be more specific, do not believe that we have a right to do with our bodies whatever we want. We do not believe that we have a right to our bodies because when we are baptized we become members of one another; then we can tell one another what it is that we should, and should not, do with our bodies. I had a colleague at the University of Notre Dame who taught Judaica. He was Jewish and always said that any religion that does not tell you what to do with your genitals and pots and pans cannot be interesting. That is exactly true. In the church we tell you what you can and cannot do with your genitals. They are not your own. They are not private. That means that you cannot commit adultery. If you do, you are no longer a member of "us."
Under the veil of American privatization, we are encouraging people to believe in the same way that Andrew Carnegie believed. He thought that he had a right to his steel mills. In the same sense, people think that they have a right to their bodies The body is then a piece of property in a capitalist sense. Unfortunately, that is antithetical to the way we Christians think that we have to share as members of the same body of Christ.
So, you cannot separate these issues. If you think that you can be very concerned about abortion and not concerned about the privatization of American life generally, you are making a mistake. So the problem is: how, as Christians, should we think about abortion without the rights rhetoric that we have been given--right to my body, right to life, pro-choice, pro-life, and so on? In this respect, we Christians must try to make the abortion issue our issue.
This is particularly clear when listening to Walter Williams' facile (and erroneous) Explanation of All Living in terms of Economics. It's a simple-minded (and wrong-headed) approach, which taken to its logical conclusion, would tell us that raising children is utterly devoid of value.
It also has an impact on the "right to privacy" debate. Not only is that phrase NOT found in the Constitution (and thus had to be put there, emanating-wise, by a creative group of Supremes in Griswold)--it is irreconcilable with a Christian notion of society, as Hauerwas shows above.
More curious: one wonders why the "right to privacy" was NOT present. Was this a case of the Homeric Nod by the authors of the Constitution and Bill of Rights?
HT: Dreher
...Indeed I want to argue that America is the only country that has the misfortune of being founded on a philosophical mistake--namely, the notion of inalienable rights. We Christians do not believe that we have inalienable rights. That is the false presumption of Enlightenment individualism, and it opposes everything that Christians believe about what it means to be a creature. Notice that the issue is inalienable rights. Rights make a certain sense as correlative to duties and goods, but they are not inalienable. For example, when the lords protested against the king in the Magna Charta, they did so in the name of their duties to their underlings. Duties, not rights, were primary. The rights were simply ways of remembering what the duties were.
Christians, to be more specific, do not believe that we have a right to do with our bodies whatever we want. We do not believe that we have a right to our bodies because when we are baptized we become members of one another; then we can tell one another what it is that we should, and should not, do with our bodies. I had a colleague at the University of Notre Dame who taught Judaica. He was Jewish and always said that any religion that does not tell you what to do with your genitals and pots and pans cannot be interesting. That is exactly true. In the church we tell you what you can and cannot do with your genitals. They are not your own. They are not private. That means that you cannot commit adultery. If you do, you are no longer a member of "us."
Under the veil of American privatization, we are encouraging people to believe in the same way that Andrew Carnegie believed. He thought that he had a right to his steel mills. In the same sense, people think that they have a right to their bodies The body is then a piece of property in a capitalist sense. Unfortunately, that is antithetical to the way we Christians think that we have to share as members of the same body of Christ.
So, you cannot separate these issues. If you think that you can be very concerned about abortion and not concerned about the privatization of American life generally, you are making a mistake. So the problem is: how, as Christians, should we think about abortion without the rights rhetoric that we have been given--right to my body, right to life, pro-choice, pro-life, and so on? In this respect, we Christians must try to make the abortion issue our issue.
This is particularly clear when listening to Walter Williams' facile (and erroneous) Explanation of All Living in terms of Economics. It's a simple-minded (and wrong-headed) approach, which taken to its logical conclusion, would tell us that raising children is utterly devoid of value.
It also has an impact on the "right to privacy" debate. Not only is that phrase NOT found in the Constitution (and thus had to be put there, emanating-wise, by a creative group of Supremes in Griswold)--it is irreconcilable with a Christian notion of society, as Hauerwas shows above.
More curious: one wonders why the "right to privacy" was NOT present. Was this a case of the Homeric Nod by the authors of the Constitution and Bill of Rights?
HT: Dreher
Corn-A-Hole's Chickens Are Expensive!
The Corn-Whores ("Inserting a Cob Up Your A** Since 2005, With Glee and Profits") should begin to fear; the price-chickens are coming home to roost.
Consider that February prices for "crude foodstuffs and feedstuffs" were up 18.8% above year-ago levels, its no surprise that food companies are passing those higher costs to consumers. Wholesale consumer food prices are 6.8% above year-ago levels.
It ain't just tortillas any more, folks.
Corn is the base feedstuff for cattle and chickens, and is found in most breakfast cereal products--and is a major-league sweetener-ingredient, too.
I'm sure that Farmer Hahn is a happy camper.
Consider that February prices for "crude foodstuffs and feedstuffs" were up 18.8% above year-ago levels, its no surprise that food companies are passing those higher costs to consumers. Wholesale consumer food prices are 6.8% above year-ago levels.
It ain't just tortillas any more, folks.
Corn is the base feedstuff for cattle and chickens, and is found in most breakfast cereal products--and is a major-league sweetener-ingredient, too.
I'm sure that Farmer Hahn is a happy camper.
"Judicial Activism" Unvarnished
Following the Shark's paper on the question of "judicial activism," (referenced and linked in the post beneath this one,) he posts today a clearly "activist" statement made by a "non-partisan" candidate for the Wisconsin Supreme Court.
"Three hundred and fifty thousand dollars is an insufficient amount in this day and age,”she said. “Whether the cap was categorically unconstitutional or arbitrarily too low, I think the result was correct.”,”she said.
What she said was that in her (not-so-humble) opinion, the caps, which were legislated by the Legislature, should have been re-legislated by....(ta-da) the Court.
Esenberg comments:
These malpractice caps were enacted by the people's democratically chosen representatives. Unless they are, for some reason, "categorically unconstitutional" then the court has no business setting them aside - whether or not Linda Clifford or a majority of justices think they are "too low." While our state's constitution does place certain limits on the legislature, the policy preferences of a majority of justices on the state's supreme court are not among them.
It so happens that I decried the stubborn and politicized refusal of the Assembly Majority Leader to accept a compromise cap-limit (IIRC, $750K). He's no longer in any public office, perhaps because of his stances...
But stubborn, politicized Legislators are not an excuse for abrogation of Legislative prerogative by a Court which "feels like it" one morning.
Now we have the possibility that Ms. Clifford will win a seat on the Court and take her electoral victory as a mandate to Legislate rather than Adjudicate.
Egads. Or, more elegantly:
Some of you might wonder why we should care. Isn't this just geeky lawyer stuff? If the result is right, why worry about whether it was legitimate? The answer goes to the very foundation of democracy. Judges get to set aside the actions of our elected officials only when those actions violate some constitutional limitation on what election officials are permitted to do - not because judicial officers believe that "in this day and age" the legislature has chosen poorly or society "needs" something else.
"Three hundred and fifty thousand dollars is an insufficient amount in this day and age,”she said. “Whether the cap was categorically unconstitutional or arbitrarily too low, I think the result was correct.”,”she said.
What she said was that in her (not-so-humble) opinion, the caps, which were legislated by the Legislature, should have been re-legislated by....(ta-da) the Court.
Esenberg comments:
These malpractice caps were enacted by the people's democratically chosen representatives. Unless they are, for some reason, "categorically unconstitutional" then the court has no business setting them aside - whether or not Linda Clifford or a majority of justices think they are "too low." While our state's constitution does place certain limits on the legislature, the policy preferences of a majority of justices on the state's supreme court are not among them.
It so happens that I decried the stubborn and politicized refusal of the Assembly Majority Leader to accept a compromise cap-limit (IIRC, $750K). He's no longer in any public office, perhaps because of his stances...
But stubborn, politicized Legislators are not an excuse for abrogation of Legislative prerogative by a Court which "feels like it" one morning.
Now we have the possibility that Ms. Clifford will win a seat on the Court and take her electoral victory as a mandate to Legislate rather than Adjudicate.
Egads. Or, more elegantly:
Some of you might wonder why we should care. Isn't this just geeky lawyer stuff? If the result is right, why worry about whether it was legitimate? The answer goes to the very foundation of democracy. Judges get to set aside the actions of our elected officials only when those actions violate some constitutional limitation on what election officials are permitted to do - not because judicial officers believe that "in this day and age" the legislature has chosen poorly or society "needs" something else.
The Nuggets of Esenberg: Shirley's Theme Song
The Shark wrote an essay on Judicial Restraint which is a delight to read.
But rather than excerpting long, I'll present a few aphorisms--nuggets--for future reference. They combine brevity with memorability, and get to the heart of the matter.
Re checks and balances (and setting the table for the rest of the paper):
We have given judges the final say on what the law means because they do not get to say what the law is.
While discussing the Ferdon decision:
The precise contours of this carnivorous form of review are not clear.
On the Dairyland decision (which reversed another decision which was only 2 years old):
Because the parties to the 1991-1992 compacts believed that they would be able to negotiate for new casino-type games in the future (the compacts provided for amendment), the court held that it would be an impairment of contractual obligation to construe the 1993 amendment to defeat that expectation.
...
It seems unlikely that the court really intends to find an unconstitutional impairment of contract whenever someone's hope for a favorable contractual amendment is frustrated by subsequent legislation.
...but they DID find so to accomodate Governor Doyle and the Tribes. Would the Court rule, then, that someone's belief that taxes will not rise should invalidate increased taxes?
In sum:
Having voted to restrict the expansion of gaming, the state's residents now find that they have conferred a monopoly on the tribes to engage in any type of gaming that the Governor might agree to and that is permitted by federal law.
Bet you didn't know that, eh?
In Jarrell, the Court mandated recording of police interrogations of juveniles.
...the court's concern went beyond problems of proof (that were themselves not present in the case before it) to substantive judgments about how interrogations should be conducted that were rooted in neither the constitution nor the statutes.
Justifying such regulation because it is implemented through a rule of admissibility (and is, therefore, a rule "governing the courts") establishes a principle with no obvious stopping point.
On the "lead paint" decision (Collins):
...its suggestion that the constitutional provision maintaining that Article I, section 9 "does allow for a remedy through the existing common law"61 suggests that it believes that Article I, section 9 imports into the common law a constitutional imperative for a "remedy" whenever there is a "wrong," whether or not recognized at common law. The court acknowledged amicus' argument that such a broad constitutional command cannot be "maintained in some principled way thereby creating uncertainty in a number of cases,"62 but pronounced itself untroubled ...
Which, I suppose, hints at the title of Screechin'Shirley's personal theme song:
Que Sera, Sera. Whatever will be, will be/the future's not yours to see/It depends on ME!
That is precisely the nature of Screechin'Shirley's decisions on carrying a concealed weapon for self-defense, which Esenberg also discusses (no excerpts here.)
***********
Ms. Abrahamson has attempted to baptize (thus sanctify) her majority's meandering opinions as "The New Federalism," which has some appeal to people who disagree with the state of jurisprudence at the Federal level. You know, the 9th and 10th Amendments, and all that stuff. But the direction The Screecher has taken with her "New Federalism" looks a bit more like "Old Anarchy,"--a logical outcome of Social Science-based decisions.
In DuBose:
The court in DuBose, like Jerrell C.J., reached out to create a broad rule regarding what law enforcement procedures should be permitted in response to concerns that were not presented by the case before it.
...
both cases represent a departure from the way in which the court had generally handled such questions reflecting, perhaps, a diminished weight placed upon precedent. And as we have seen, Ferdon and Dairyland reversed very recent decisions, calling into question the extent to which anything can be regarded as settled other than by the type of head counting normally associated with political prognostication.
Esenberg concludes:
We have seen that a number of the Wisconsin Supreme Court's recent decisions have involved an aggressive re-examination of legislative fact-finding (Ferdon) or the rooting of a decision in facts that are controverted (Thomas) or outside of the record (Jerrell C.J., DuBose). We have seen the court engage in a judicial reformulation of legislation (Fisher) and adopt doctrine that it is unlikely to follow in future cases (Ferdon, Dairyland). ...
It is the purpose of this white paper to facilitate a discussion about this important trend and to foster a dialogue about the proper role of the courts in our state. It is the hope of its author that it begins now—in earnest
It is also the hope of rational citizens of this State, as well, Rick. Let's Get It On!!
But rather than excerpting long, I'll present a few aphorisms--nuggets--for future reference. They combine brevity with memorability, and get to the heart of the matter.
Re checks and balances (and setting the table for the rest of the paper):
We have given judges the final say on what the law means because they do not get to say what the law is.
While discussing the Ferdon decision:
The precise contours of this carnivorous form of review are not clear.
On the Dairyland decision (which reversed another decision which was only 2 years old):
Because the parties to the 1991-1992 compacts believed that they would be able to negotiate for new casino-type games in the future (the compacts provided for amendment), the court held that it would be an impairment of contractual obligation to construe the 1993 amendment to defeat that expectation.
...
It seems unlikely that the court really intends to find an unconstitutional impairment of contract whenever someone's hope for a favorable contractual amendment is frustrated by subsequent legislation.
...but they DID find so to accomodate Governor Doyle and the Tribes. Would the Court rule, then, that someone's belief that taxes will not rise should invalidate increased taxes?
In sum:
Having voted to restrict the expansion of gaming, the state's residents now find that they have conferred a monopoly on the tribes to engage in any type of gaming that the Governor might agree to and that is permitted by federal law.
Bet you didn't know that, eh?
In Jarrell, the Court mandated recording of police interrogations of juveniles.
...the court's concern went beyond problems of proof (that were themselves not present in the case before it) to substantive judgments about how interrogations should be conducted that were rooted in neither the constitution nor the statutes.
Justifying such regulation because it is implemented through a rule of admissibility (and is, therefore, a rule "governing the courts") establishes a principle with no obvious stopping point.
On the "lead paint" decision (Collins):
...its suggestion that the constitutional provision maintaining that Article I, section 9 "does allow for a remedy through the existing common law"61 suggests that it believes that Article I, section 9 imports into the common law a constitutional imperative for a "remedy" whenever there is a "wrong," whether or not recognized at common law. The court acknowledged amicus' argument that such a broad constitutional command cannot be "maintained in some principled way thereby creating uncertainty in a number of cases,"62 but pronounced itself untroubled ...
Which, I suppose, hints at the title of Screechin'Shirley's personal theme song:
Que Sera, Sera. Whatever will be, will be/the future's not yours to see/It depends on ME!
That is precisely the nature of Screechin'Shirley's decisions on carrying a concealed weapon for self-defense, which Esenberg also discusses (no excerpts here.)
***********
Ms. Abrahamson has attempted to baptize (thus sanctify) her majority's meandering opinions as "The New Federalism," which has some appeal to people who disagree with the state of jurisprudence at the Federal level. You know, the 9th and 10th Amendments, and all that stuff. But the direction The Screecher has taken with her "New Federalism" looks a bit more like "Old Anarchy,"--a logical outcome of Social Science-based decisions.
In DuBose:
The court in DuBose, like Jerrell C.J., reached out to create a broad rule regarding what law enforcement procedures should be permitted in response to concerns that were not presented by the case before it.
...
both cases represent a departure from the way in which the court had generally handled such questions reflecting, perhaps, a diminished weight placed upon precedent. And as we have seen, Ferdon and Dairyland reversed very recent decisions, calling into question the extent to which anything can be regarded as settled other than by the type of head counting normally associated with political prognostication.
Esenberg concludes:
We have seen that a number of the Wisconsin Supreme Court's recent decisions have involved an aggressive re-examination of legislative fact-finding (Ferdon) or the rooting of a decision in facts that are controverted (Thomas) or outside of the record (Jerrell C.J., DuBose). We have seen the court engage in a judicial reformulation of legislation (Fisher) and adopt doctrine that it is unlikely to follow in future cases (Ferdon, Dairyland). ...
It is the purpose of this white paper to facilitate a discussion about this important trend and to foster a dialogue about the proper role of the courts in our state. It is the hope of its author that it begins now—in earnest
It is also the hope of rational citizens of this State, as well, Rick. Let's Get It On!!
Thursday, March 15, 2007
About the Gross Domestic Product
Next time some yapper tells you about the glorious growth of the GDP, remind them of this:
GDP purportedly is now growing at 3.5%, and everyone seems pleased. What we fail to understand is how much government entitlement spending contributes to the increase in the GDP. Rebuilding infrastructure destroyed by hurricanes, which simply gets us back to even, is considered part of GDP growth. Wall Street profits and salaries, pumped up by the Fed’s increase in money, also contribute to GDP statistical growth. Just buying military weapons that contribute nothing to the well being of our citizens, sending money down a rat hole, contributes to GDP growth! Simple price increases caused by Fed monetary inflation contribute to nominal GDP growth. None of these factors represent any kind of real increases in economic output. So we should not carelessly cite misleading GDP figures which don’t truly reflect what is happening in the economy.
Ron Paul, MC
In other words, a good deal of Federal spending is counted as GDP--meaning that the larger the Feds' budget, the larger the GDP. Hell--FDR increased the GDP significantly, but gasoline was rationed, as was copper, and some food. Great GDP--just no benefit to the citizens (aside from winning the war.)
So who wants to look at the GWB spend-a-thon and re-calc GDP for actual growth?
GDP purportedly is now growing at 3.5%, and everyone seems pleased. What we fail to understand is how much government entitlement spending contributes to the increase in the GDP. Rebuilding infrastructure destroyed by hurricanes, which simply gets us back to even, is considered part of GDP growth. Wall Street profits and salaries, pumped up by the Fed’s increase in money, also contribute to GDP statistical growth. Just buying military weapons that contribute nothing to the well being of our citizens, sending money down a rat hole, contributes to GDP growth! Simple price increases caused by Fed monetary inflation contribute to nominal GDP growth. None of these factors represent any kind of real increases in economic output. So we should not carelessly cite misleading GDP figures which don’t truly reflect what is happening in the economy.
Ron Paul, MC
In other words, a good deal of Federal spending is counted as GDP--meaning that the larger the Feds' budget, the larger the GDP. Hell--FDR increased the GDP significantly, but gasoline was rationed, as was copper, and some food. Great GDP--just no benefit to the citizens (aside from winning the war.)
So who wants to look at the GWB spend-a-thon and re-calc GDP for actual growth?
Task Force 145
When you want to know what's going on in the War on Terrorists, Google "Task Force 145."
Last week, western forces from Afghanistan were reported to have crossed the Pakistani border, and captured Mullah Hakimallah Mehsud, a clansman of Baitullah and Abdullah Mehsud, the two leading Taliban commanders in South Waziristan. Yesterday, NATO's International Security Assistance Force spokesman denied any involvement in operations inside Pakistan. "Contrary to recent press reports, the NATO International Security Assistance Force has not and is not involved in the conduct of any operations inside of Pakistan," noted an ISAF press release. "" 'These reports are simply false,' said Col Tom Collins, ISAF spokesman." Colonel Collins is technically correct, this wasn't a NATO led mission, but, as we noted the day the news broke, one conducted by Task Force 145, the hunter-killer Special Operations group created to pursue senior al-Qaeda leadership.
It's a lot easier than asking the Bush Administration what's going on. They won't tell you.
HT: Roggio/Fourth Rail
Last week, western forces from Afghanistan were reported to have crossed the Pakistani border, and captured Mullah Hakimallah Mehsud, a clansman of Baitullah and Abdullah Mehsud, the two leading Taliban commanders in South Waziristan. Yesterday, NATO's International Security Assistance Force spokesman denied any involvement in operations inside Pakistan. "Contrary to recent press reports, the NATO International Security Assistance Force has not and is not involved in the conduct of any operations inside of Pakistan," noted an ISAF press release. "" 'These reports are simply false,' said Col Tom Collins, ISAF spokesman." Colonel Collins is technically correct, this wasn't a NATO led mission, but, as we noted the day the news broke, one conducted by Task Force 145, the hunter-killer Special Operations group created to pursue senior al-Qaeda leadership.
It's a lot easier than asking the Bush Administration what's going on. They won't tell you.
HT: Roggio/Fourth Rail
Weenie Report: Republican Mommies
Sure enough, the "Republicans" who will introduce a State-wide smoking ban have familiar names:
Carol Roessler (R-Oshkosh) and state Representatives Mark Gottllieb (R-Port Washington), Steve Wieckert (R-Appleton)
Evidently Ms. Roessler's primordial urge to be a Mother was frustrated someplace along the line. I would prefer that she mother someone else--not the entire State.
As to Gottlieb and Wieckert: you, too, can be Mothers. You're working hard enough at it. Just buy a dress and wear it as a start.
HT: Kevin Fischer
Carol Roessler (R-Oshkosh) and state Representatives Mark Gottllieb (R-Port Washington), Steve Wieckert (R-Appleton)
Evidently Ms. Roessler's primordial urge to be a Mother was frustrated someplace along the line. I would prefer that she mother someone else--not the entire State.
As to Gottlieb and Wieckert: you, too, can be Mothers. You're working hard enough at it. Just buy a dress and wear it as a start.
HT: Kevin Fischer
Screw The "Minneapolis Imams"
The Imams who were tossed off the plane in Minneapolis are suing.
But they're not just suing the airline (U S Airways.)
These jackasses are also suing the people who REPORTED their suspicious behavior.
Paragraph 22 adds: "Plaintiffs will seek leave to amend this Complaint to allege true names, capacities, and circumstances supporting [these defendants'] liability ... at such time as Plaintiffs ascertain the same."
Who are these unnamed culprits? The complaint describes them as "an older couple who was sitting [near the imams] and purposely turn[ed] around to watch" as they prayed. "The gentleman ('John Doe') in the couple ... picked up his cellular phone and made a phone call while watching the Plaintiffs pray," then "moved to a corner" and "kept talking into his cellular phone."
In retribution for this action, the unnamed couple probably will be dragged into court soon and face the prospect of hiring a lawyer, enduring hostile questioning and paying huge legal bills. The same fate could await other as-yet-unnamed passengers on the US Airways flight who came forward as witnesses.
Perhaps it is un-civil to suggest that this lawsuit should be tossed at first sight and the jackass Imams required to leave the country immediately. OK. I'll be un-civil.
Do not pack your bags. Do not take a toothbrush. Just get the Hell outta here.
HT: Powerline
But they're not just suing the airline (U S Airways.)
These jackasses are also suing the people who REPORTED their suspicious behavior.
Paragraph 22 adds: "Plaintiffs will seek leave to amend this Complaint to allege true names, capacities, and circumstances supporting [these defendants'] liability ... at such time as Plaintiffs ascertain the same."
Who are these unnamed culprits? The complaint describes them as "an older couple who was sitting [near the imams] and purposely turn[ed] around to watch" as they prayed. "The gentleman ('John Doe') in the couple ... picked up his cellular phone and made a phone call while watching the Plaintiffs pray," then "moved to a corner" and "kept talking into his cellular phone."
In retribution for this action, the unnamed couple probably will be dragged into court soon and face the prospect of hiring a lawyer, enduring hostile questioning and paying huge legal bills. The same fate could await other as-yet-unnamed passengers on the US Airways flight who came forward as witnesses.
Perhaps it is un-civil to suggest that this lawsuit should be tossed at first sight and the jackass Imams required to leave the country immediately. OK. I'll be un-civil.
Do not pack your bags. Do not take a toothbrush. Just get the Hell outta here.
HT: Powerline
PJB and Relativity--the Chaos Machine
As we pointed out below, "relativism," the philosophical equivalent to "I'm OK, You're OK" is a certain path to chaos, as Benedict XVI tells us.
And that "relativism" showed its shapeless face in the Peter Pace brouhaha, on which PJBuchanan hits the nail on the head, again:
What this uproar tells us is that America is no longer a moral community. On the most fundamental issues – abortion, promiscuity, homosexuality, euthanasia, sterilization, cloning, and the creation of, and buying and selling of, fetuses for research – we are at war. What part of the nation sees as progress, the other sees as depravity.
And where there is no moral community, there will not long be one country. For in a religious or culture war, there is no peaceful coexistence.
One side wins, the other side loses.
"A house divided against itself...."
And that "relativism" showed its shapeless face in the Peter Pace brouhaha, on which PJBuchanan hits the nail on the head, again:
What this uproar tells us is that America is no longer a moral community. On the most fundamental issues – abortion, promiscuity, homosexuality, euthanasia, sterilization, cloning, and the creation of, and buying and selling of, fetuses for research – we are at war. What part of the nation sees as progress, the other sees as depravity.
And where there is no moral community, there will not long be one country. For in a religious or culture war, there is no peaceful coexistence.
One side wins, the other side loses.
"A house divided against itself...."
Lonesome George (Bush)
There's been some angst midst the Radio Snorters over the "Prosecutors Fired" thing.
Not because the Prosecutors were Fired. Not because the Dim(o)wits are making it into a propaganda campaign which would do Goebbels proud.
Not because NBCABCCBSCNN are repeating the propaganda like the monkey-brained twits they are.
But because the Conservative base doesn't seem to care.
Farah has an opinion which has a bearing on this:
Now, again, I have to point out that Bush administration incompetence is indeed staggering to behold. Only the Bush White House and its Justice Department could manage to look so guilty when they have done nothing wrong. They are pathetic and deserve whatever fate befalls them in this make-believe crisis
...This whole drama is kind of a metaphor for the Bush administration. These guys, starting at the top, have been over their heads from day one. Bush tried so hard to get along with the Democrats. He cared so much about appearances and the way the New York Times, Washington Post and Associated Press covered his actions. He didn't care about his campaign promises to his base. He didn't even seem to care if he lost control of Congress – which he did.
GWB won't even defend his own AG (who should be fired for his incompetence on other grounds--like his failure to send Sandy Burglar to Club Fed, or his failure to ruthlessly prosecute the Corn-A-Hole crowd for insider-dealing, or for allowing his boyzzzz to jail Border Patrol personnel.)
Why the Hell should Conservatives defend him?
Not because the Prosecutors were Fired. Not because the Dim(o)wits are making it into a propaganda campaign which would do Goebbels proud.
Not because NBCABCCBSCNN are repeating the propaganda like the monkey-brained twits they are.
But because the Conservative base doesn't seem to care.
Farah has an opinion which has a bearing on this:
Now, again, I have to point out that Bush administration incompetence is indeed staggering to behold. Only the Bush White House and its Justice Department could manage to look so guilty when they have done nothing wrong. They are pathetic and deserve whatever fate befalls them in this make-believe crisis
...This whole drama is kind of a metaphor for the Bush administration. These guys, starting at the top, have been over their heads from day one. Bush tried so hard to get along with the Democrats. He cared so much about appearances and the way the New York Times, Washington Post and Associated Press covered his actions. He didn't care about his campaign promises to his base. He didn't even seem to care if he lost control of Congress – which he did.
GWB won't even defend his own AG (who should be fired for his incompetence on other grounds--like his failure to send Sandy Burglar to Club Fed, or his failure to ruthlessly prosecute the Corn-A-Hole crowd for insider-dealing, or for allowing his boyzzzz to jail Border Patrol personnel.)
Why the Hell should Conservatives defend him?
Wednesday, March 14, 2007
The Vote on Frank the Fixer
These are the State Senators who voted AGAINST confirming Frank the Fixer as Sec'y/DOT:
ELLIS
FITZGERALD
HARSDORF
KEDZIE
LAZICH
LEIBHAM
I suspect the rest of them are interested in watching the plot thicken.
ELLIS
FITZGERALD
HARSDORF
KEDZIE
LAZICH
LEIBHAM
I suspect the rest of them are interested in watching the plot thicken.
For Farmer Hahn, Sen. Grassley, and the Other Ladies of the Evening
Perhaps you recall some of this language:
...That whenever any Form of Government becomes destructive of these ends, it is the Right of the People to alter or to abolish it...
But when a long train of abuses and usurpations, pursuing invariably the same Object evinces a design to reduce them under absolute Despotism, it is their right, it is their duty, to throw off such Government, and to provide new Guards for their future security.
...He has erected a multitude of New Offices, and sent hither swarms of Officers to harass our people, and eat out their substance.
...For imposing Taxes on us without our Consent...
...A [Representative] whose character is thus marked by every act which may define a Tyrant, is unfit to be the ruler of a free people.
Think positive. George III was not executed during the ensuing...ah....difficulties.
...That whenever any Form of Government becomes destructive of these ends, it is the Right of the People to alter or to abolish it...
But when a long train of abuses and usurpations, pursuing invariably the same Object evinces a design to reduce them under absolute Despotism, it is their right, it is their duty, to throw off such Government, and to provide new Guards for their future security.
...He has erected a multitude of New Offices, and sent hither swarms of Officers to harass our people, and eat out their substance.
...For imposing Taxes on us without our Consent...
...A [Representative] whose character is thus marked by every act which may define a Tyrant, is unfit to be the ruler of a free people.
Think positive. George III was not executed during the ensuing...ah....difficulties.
More on The Papal Document
From Fr. Z.:
...Benedict is forcefully underscoring the importance of the liturgical action itself. The action is the rite. Thus the celebration of the Eucharist conforms Christian life. It conforms the Christian through participation in a mystery which is to be lived. So, there is a direct connection between the way the rite, the actio, is celebrated and living like a Christian.
This logically leads to the necessary of a reform of the way the Church is celebrating the actio. The idea is this: celebrate the liturgy well (I would add especially Holy Mass, the Eucharist) and it forms us to live better. The impact of good liturgical celebration on Christian living requires, therefore, great vigilance and fidelity. Thus, there is both a qualitative dimension to the effect of good liturgical celebration (actio) and even the quantitative dimension!
... Benedict argues for a direct dependence of actuosa participatio on the ars celebrandi. This is not so new, if you think about it with common sense. The Pope says that to go into the depths of the ars celebrandi (and thus create the proper impact on the Church through active "personal" participation, there must be close fidelity to the rite itself which is the the actio and which makes the actio happen.
Which also re-inforces the priest as the alter Christus. The 'good-time-Charlie' priest is not able to engender a well-formed actuosa participatio, thus his flock will be mis-formed, as well. But that is qualified:
"Any attempt to make themselves the centre of the liturgical action contradicts their very identity." Thus the priest must use "obedience to the rite, uniting himself to it in mind and heart and avoiding anything that might give the impression of an inordinate emphasis on his own personality."
Which is to say, "alter Christus but not The Christus"
And as to actuosa participatio, Benedict says:
"We must not overlook the fact that some misunderstanding has occasionally arisen concerning the precise meaning of [active] participation. It should be made clear that the word "participation" does not refer to mere external activity during the celebration… ... it must be understood in more substantial terms."
Like metanoia, for example.
...Benedict is forcefully underscoring the importance of the liturgical action itself. The action is the rite. Thus the celebration of the Eucharist conforms Christian life. It conforms the Christian through participation in a mystery which is to be lived. So, there is a direct connection between the way the rite, the actio, is celebrated and living like a Christian.
This logically leads to the necessary of a reform of the way the Church is celebrating the actio. The idea is this: celebrate the liturgy well (I would add especially Holy Mass, the Eucharist) and it forms us to live better. The impact of good liturgical celebration on Christian living requires, therefore, great vigilance and fidelity. Thus, there is both a qualitative dimension to the effect of good liturgical celebration (actio) and even the quantitative dimension!
... Benedict argues for a direct dependence of actuosa participatio on the ars celebrandi. This is not so new, if you think about it with common sense. The Pope says that to go into the depths of the ars celebrandi (and thus create the proper impact on the Church through active "personal" participation, there must be close fidelity to the rite itself which is the the actio and which makes the actio happen.
Which also re-inforces the priest as the alter Christus. The 'good-time-Charlie' priest is not able to engender a well-formed actuosa participatio, thus his flock will be mis-formed, as well. But that is qualified:
"Any attempt to make themselves the centre of the liturgical action contradicts their very identity." Thus the priest must use "obedience to the rite, uniting himself to it in mind and heart and avoiding anything that might give the impression of an inordinate emphasis on his own personality."
Which is to say, "alter Christus but not The Christus"
And as to actuosa participatio, Benedict says:
"We must not overlook the fact that some misunderstanding has occasionally arisen concerning the precise meaning of [active] participation. It should be made clear that the word "participation" does not refer to mere external activity during the celebration… ... it must be understood in more substantial terms."
Like metanoia, for example.
The Games Translators Play
As pointed out by the inestimable Fr. Z (and reported by CWN), the English-translation jiggerbugger/liturgeisters were working when translating B-16's recent document.
Yup. It changed the meaning. Not by 180 degrees (that sort of thing is reserved to retired Cardinals of Washington DC.) But just enough.
Here's the scoop:
In order to express more clearly the unity and universality of the Church, I wish to endorse the proposal made by the Synod of Bishops, in harmony with the directives of the Second Vatican Council, that, with the exception of the readings, the homily and the prayer of the faithful, such liturgies [i.e., large-scale or international liturgies] could be celebrated in Latin. [Para. 62]
But that's not what the Latin said:
Ad melius ostendendam unitatem et universalitatem Ecclesiae, cupimus commendare suasiones Synodi Episcoporum, consonantes cum normis Concilii Vaticani II: exceptis lectionibus, homilia et oratione fidelium, aequum est ut huiusmodi celebrationes fiant lingua Latina
And as we all know from the Preface' Dialogue, "Aequum est" is better translated "It is FITTING," (or "it is right.")
An erosion here, a corner de-burred there, and pretty soon you have Liturgeist-Approved Translations!
Yup. It changed the meaning. Not by 180 degrees (that sort of thing is reserved to retired Cardinals of Washington DC.) But just enough.
Here's the scoop:
In order to express more clearly the unity and universality of the Church, I wish to endorse the proposal made by the Synod of Bishops, in harmony with the directives of the Second Vatican Council, that, with the exception of the readings, the homily and the prayer of the faithful, such liturgies [i.e., large-scale or international liturgies] could be celebrated in Latin. [Para. 62]
But that's not what the Latin said:
Ad melius ostendendam unitatem et universalitatem Ecclesiae, cupimus commendare suasiones Synodi Episcoporum, consonantes cum normis Concilii Vaticani II: exceptis lectionibus, homilia et oratione fidelium, aequum est ut huiusmodi celebrationes fiant lingua Latina
And as we all know from the Preface' Dialogue, "Aequum est" is better translated "It is FITTING," (or "it is right.")
An erosion here, a corner de-burred there, and pretty soon you have Liturgeist-Approved Translations!
Self-Interest and Lies About Guns
Well, here we go again.
The owner of Badger Guns (who is under intense scrutiny) has endorsed a proposal which would significantly enhance Badger Guns' revenues. No surprise there. Hell, he could become a Legislator and vote self-interest, just like Farmer Hahn.
The proposal would ban private gun-sales in Milwaukee County, which has some "GooGoo" about it--but the propaganda support happens to consist of a lie from "Mothers Against Gun Violence."
MAGW claims that there is no legal barrier to selling a gun to a felon.
WRONG!! BZZZZZZT!!
In reality, committing such an act is a federal felony, as well as a crime as defined in Wisconsin code sections 941.29(4) and 939.05(2)(b).
If you're so motivated, advise your Leggie that LRB 0861/2 should be squashed.
The owner of Badger Guns (who is under intense scrutiny) has endorsed a proposal which would significantly enhance Badger Guns' revenues. No surprise there. Hell, he could become a Legislator and vote self-interest, just like Farmer Hahn.
The proposal would ban private gun-sales in Milwaukee County, which has some "GooGoo" about it--but the propaganda support happens to consist of a lie from "Mothers Against Gun Violence."
MAGW claims that there is no legal barrier to selling a gun to a felon.
WRONG!! BZZZZZZT!!
In reality, committing such an act is a federal felony, as well as a crime as defined in Wisconsin code sections 941.29(4) and 939.05(2)(b).
If you're so motivated, advise your Leggie that LRB 0861/2 should be squashed.
Brookfield vs. Brookfield: The Union Wants Jobs!
This doesn't surprise me at all, but Bob Flessas did the digging.
According to one local fire staffer on the condition of anonymity, the city may be intentionally making it hard on the Town because “[city fire staff] would be losing geographical area for their fire service. The IAFF union is lobbying hard against any services provided by the town’s fire department, even if they are equal or better.
By ‘equal’, I’m referring to City trained paramedics; by ‘better’ I mean response times to Weston Hills.”
“The thought is the city’s FD is justifying their firehouse staffing levels based on Weston Hills residency, that would in essence be gone if the town covers that area.”
“This matter goes well beyond the right thing to do for residents of the city.”
The City of Brookfield's Fire Department pisses away a lot of money...on firefighters, of course. The Union wants to keep it that way, and Jeff Speaker is (in effect) fronting for them.
So when the Town of Brookfield offered to "cover" the Weston Hills area for the City (a very logical and efficient offer,) the Fire Fighters' Union went ballistic, knowing that if the Town did the work, the Union Firefighters would lose jobs.
Speaker is playing toady for the Union here, and costing the City's taxpayers some money.
While all of us knew that Mayor Jeff was not particularly bright, none of us suspected that he was actually a Union front-man.
On the other hand, no City Alderman will ever question the Union-mandated (and Chief-supported) featherbedding--sending an engine to accompany ambo-runs. The Aldermen are aware of it, and simply have no interest.
According to one local fire staffer on the condition of anonymity, the city may be intentionally making it hard on the Town because “[city fire staff] would be losing geographical area for their fire service. The IAFF union is lobbying hard against any services provided by the town’s fire department, even if they are equal or better.
By ‘equal’, I’m referring to City trained paramedics; by ‘better’ I mean response times to Weston Hills.”
“The thought is the city’s FD is justifying their firehouse staffing levels based on Weston Hills residency, that would in essence be gone if the town covers that area.”
“This matter goes well beyond the right thing to do for residents of the city.”
The City of Brookfield's Fire Department pisses away a lot of money...on firefighters, of course. The Union wants to keep it that way, and Jeff Speaker is (in effect) fronting for them.
So when the Town of Brookfield offered to "cover" the Weston Hills area for the City (a very logical and efficient offer,) the Fire Fighters' Union went ballistic, knowing that if the Town did the work, the Union Firefighters would lose jobs.
Speaker is playing toady for the Union here, and costing the City's taxpayers some money.
While all of us knew that Mayor Jeff was not particularly bright, none of us suspected that he was actually a Union front-man.
On the other hand, no City Alderman will ever question the Union-mandated (and Chief-supported) featherbedding--sending an engine to accompany ambo-runs. The Aldermen are aware of it, and simply have no interest.
Dodd to "Rescue" Mortgage-Holders, $1.64BN
Senator Chris Dodd (D-Conn) says he's going to "rescue" mortgage-holders.
Congress might step in to protect the country's 2.2 million subprime mortgage holders, said Christopher Dodd (D-Conn.), chairman of the Senate Banking Committee. He suggested laws might be needed to give them a chance to regain financial balance.
Peculiar way to phrase what he's really doing: the proposal is to shove $1.64 Billion in tax dollars into certain mortgage-banking firms.
This is not "to rescue" the home-buyers. It's "to rescue" the lender syndicates.
HT for Mish's column to Random10
Congress might step in to protect the country's 2.2 million subprime mortgage holders, said Christopher Dodd (D-Conn.), chairman of the Senate Banking Committee. He suggested laws might be needed to give them a chance to regain financial balance.
Peculiar way to phrase what he's really doing: the proposal is to shove $1.64 Billion in tax dollars into certain mortgage-banking firms.
This is not "to rescue" the home-buyers. It's "to rescue" the lender syndicates.
HT for Mish's column to Random10
Where's Your Money? Clinton. Both Bushes, Took It
The Feds are spending it. (You expected another answer?)
Heritage has put up a series of charts, and this is one. (Can't get it to upload to Blogger...)
Inflation-adjusted, your Congress is spending a LOT of your money:
For 2006, the average household will pay $20,664, down from $22,647 in 2000 but much higher than $13,017 in 1965.
They actually WERE "the Good Old Days."
But that's not all. (Those suffering from clinical depression should stop reading right now.)
Your Congress-Critters are spending a LOT.
Real annual federal spending more than tripled since 1965 and nearly doubled since 1980.
And they're spending your money to get re-elected (or to obtain more election funds):
Total nominal spending increased over 2,000 percent since 1965, while the Consumer Price Index increased a relatively modest 500 percent. Less than half of the increase in federal spending came from defense and homeland security spending.
And they spend regardless of the underlying ability-to-pay.
Federal spending increased 250 percent since 1965, five times faster than median income, which rose just over 40 percent.
The local angle? DarthDoyle is doing his damndest to emulate these bozos.
Heritage has put up a series of charts, and this is one. (Can't get it to upload to Blogger...)
Inflation-adjusted, your Congress is spending a LOT of your money:
For 2006, the average household will pay $20,664, down from $22,647 in 2000 but much higher than $13,017 in 1965.
They actually WERE "the Good Old Days."
But that's not all. (Those suffering from clinical depression should stop reading right now.)
Your Congress-Critters are spending a LOT.
Real annual federal spending more than tripled since 1965 and nearly doubled since 1980.
And they're spending your money to get re-elected (or to obtain more election funds):
Total nominal spending increased over 2,000 percent since 1965, while the Consumer Price Index increased a relatively modest 500 percent. Less than half of the increase in federal spending came from defense and homeland security spending.
And they spend regardless of the underlying ability-to-pay.
Federal spending increased 250 percent since 1965, five times faster than median income, which rose just over 40 percent.
The local angle? DarthDoyle is doing his damndest to emulate these bozos.
The Stadium Royal Flush
Do you suppose that the plumbing contractor's going to pay for the fix--or will it just be tacked on to the endless, priceless, Stadium Tax?
Tuesday, March 13, 2007
Renovating a Church
Above are the "Before" and "After" pictures of the Cathedral in Philadelphia. Here's a bit of the story:In his first pastoral letter as Archbishop of Philadelphia, Cardinal Justin Rigali asked pastors to consider placing the tabernacle in the center of the church behind the main altar if it was not already there and if individual circumstances made such a move feasible.
On Sunday, March 4 at the Cathedral of S.S. Peter and Paul, the Cardinal led the way and made the mother church of the Archdiocese an example to all when he blessed a brand new tabernacle which has been relocated from a side altar to the center of the Cathedral’s sanctuary where it is visible by all.
The tabernacle has been placed on a ledge which is part of a luminous new reredos, a freestanding “screen” erected a few feet behind the main altar. Amazingly, it looks for all the world as if it has been there ever since the altar itself was installed 50 years ago.
A very significant concept follows:
“Cardinal Rigali has been telling everyone they should keep Christ in the center of their lives, and what better way to do that than to keep Him in the center of our churches also,” said Louis DiCocco, president of The St. Jude Shop, which was responsible for the new tabernacle, reredos and matching candlesticks.
Another project for Abp. Dolan.
HT: The New Liturgical MovementChant and Latin in B-16's Exhortation
Perhaps there will be a dozen parishes in the Archdiocese of Milwaukee which will take this seriously.
Then again, perhaps not.
42. In the ars celebrandi, liturgical song has a pre-eminent place. Saint Augustine rightly says in a famous sermon that “the new man sings a new song. Singing is an expression of joy and, if we consider the matter, an expression of love.”. The People of God assembled for the liturgy sings the praises of God. In the course of her two-thousand-year history, the Church has created, and still creates, music and songs which represent a rich patrimony of faith and love. This heritage must not be lost. Certainly as far as the liturgy is concerned, we cannot say that one song is as good as another. Generic improvisation or the introduction of musical genres which fail to respect the meaning of the liturgy should be avoided. As an element of the liturgy, song should be well integrated into the overall celebration. Consequently everything – texts, music, execution – ought to correspond to the meaning of the mystery being celebrated, the structure of the rite and the liturgical seasons. Finally, while respecting various styles and different and highly praiseworthy traditions, I desire, in accordance with the request advanced by the Synod Fathers, that Gregorian chant be suitably esteemed and employed as the chant proper to the Roman liturgy….
62. … I am thinking here particularly of celebrations at international gatherings, which nowadays are held with greater frequency. The most should be made of these occasions. In order to express more clearly the unity and universality of the Church, I wish to endorse the proposal made by the Synod of Bishops, in harmony with the directives of the Second Vatican Council, that, with the exception of the readings, the homily and the prayer of the faithful, such liturgies could be celebrated in Latin. Similarly, the better-known prayers of the Church’s tradition should be recited in Latin and, if possible, selections of Gregorian chant should be sung. Speaking more generally, I ask that future priests, from their time in the seminary, receive the preparation needed to understand and to celebrate Mass in Latin, and also to use Latin texts and execute Gregorian chant; nor should we forget that the faithful can be taught to recite the more common prayers in Latin, and also to sing parts of the liturgy to Gregorian chant.
I'm willing to bet that my older children know more Latin (and more about Latin) than priests who were ordained in Milwaukee between c. 1980-2000. And about Chant, too.
Abp. Dolan will certainly follow the wishes of the Pope in this matter, requiring Latin study for his seminarians, right?
About 4 years at 6 credits/year should be sufficient for starters.
Then again, perhaps not.
42. In the ars celebrandi, liturgical song has a pre-eminent place. Saint Augustine rightly says in a famous sermon that “the new man sings a new song. Singing is an expression of joy and, if we consider the matter, an expression of love.”. The People of God assembled for the liturgy sings the praises of God. In the course of her two-thousand-year history, the Church has created, and still creates, music and songs which represent a rich patrimony of faith and love. This heritage must not be lost. Certainly as far as the liturgy is concerned, we cannot say that one song is as good as another. Generic improvisation or the introduction of musical genres which fail to respect the meaning of the liturgy should be avoided. As an element of the liturgy, song should be well integrated into the overall celebration. Consequently everything – texts, music, execution – ought to correspond to the meaning of the mystery being celebrated, the structure of the rite and the liturgical seasons. Finally, while respecting various styles and different and highly praiseworthy traditions, I desire, in accordance with the request advanced by the Synod Fathers, that Gregorian chant be suitably esteemed and employed as the chant proper to the Roman liturgy….
62. … I am thinking here particularly of celebrations at international gatherings, which nowadays are held with greater frequency. The most should be made of these occasions. In order to express more clearly the unity and universality of the Church, I wish to endorse the proposal made by the Synod of Bishops, in harmony with the directives of the Second Vatican Council, that, with the exception of the readings, the homily and the prayer of the faithful, such liturgies could be celebrated in Latin. Similarly, the better-known prayers of the Church’s tradition should be recited in Latin and, if possible, selections of Gregorian chant should be sung. Speaking more generally, I ask that future priests, from their time in the seminary, receive the preparation needed to understand and to celebrate Mass in Latin, and also to use Latin texts and execute Gregorian chant; nor should we forget that the faithful can be taught to recite the more common prayers in Latin, and also to sing parts of the liturgy to Gregorian chant.
I'm willing to bet that my older children know more Latin (and more about Latin) than priests who were ordained in Milwaukee between c. 1980-2000. And about Chant, too.
Abp. Dolan will certainly follow the wishes of the Pope in this matter, requiring Latin study for his seminarians, right?
About 4 years at 6 credits/year should be sufficient for starters.
MATC: "Going Concern" Warning
Kevin brings us a most interesting choice of words from the Legislative Audit Bureau:
LAB notes that the magnitude of Milwaukee Area’s liability suggests the district could be challenged to meet its future financial obligations without significantly increasing revenues or significantly reducing its operating budget
Although the context is different, this is almost a "Paragraph of Death" wording--that is, the "going concern" warning which usually puts privately-held companies out of business when it comes from the CPA.
But what's $228 million to the Milwaukee taxpayers, anyway?
LAB notes that the magnitude of Milwaukee Area’s liability suggests the district could be challenged to meet its future financial obligations without significantly increasing revenues or significantly reducing its operating budget
Although the context is different, this is almost a "Paragraph of Death" wording--that is, the "going concern" warning which usually puts privately-held companies out of business when it comes from the CPA.
But what's $228 million to the Milwaukee taxpayers, anyway?
Fox Lake's Police Chief: Not Really Right
Last night, the TV news carried an excerpt of an interview with the Chief of Police of Fox Lake. He stated that '...the woman did the right thing' [by driving to the Fox Lake Police Department.]
What does THAT mean? The woman is dead--murdered in the lobby of the PD by her husband.
We have a better suggestion:

What does THAT mean? The woman is dead--murdered in the lobby of the PD by her husband.
We have a better suggestion:

Peter Pace: Right, But Not Fabulous
The Chairman of the Joint Chiefs, Gen. Peter Pace, will have to survive a withering storm of cat-scratches, hissyfits, pink parasols, and nasty name-calling in the next few weeks. And the fashionability of his clothing will be subject to intense negative scrutiny.
That USMC training will come in handy, no?
To earn the utter disdain of the "Gay" community, Pace opined that 'homosexual activity is immoral' while testifying about the "Don't Ask Don't Tell" policy in the Armed Forces.
The General understated the case. He should have said what is really true: that homosexual activity is un-natural, and thus it is immoral.
Semper Fi, General!
That USMC training will come in handy, no?
To earn the utter disdain of the "Gay" community, Pace opined that 'homosexual activity is immoral' while testifying about the "Don't Ask Don't Tell" policy in the Armed Forces.
The General understated the case. He should have said what is really true: that homosexual activity is un-natural, and thus it is immoral.
Semper Fi, General!
Blame State Aid? Waukesha Schools Squeeze
In Waukesha, the folks turned out to try to get more State money for the school system.
About 500 parents, students and spectators packed a school auditorium Monday night, pleading for help from local legislators in dealing with a financial situation that some predicted would devastate the School District.
Administrators have recommended eliminating the equivalent of 62 full-time staff positions, which would raise class sizes, delay band and orchestra instruction and nearly eliminate elementary guidance, elementary library and gifted programs in the district.
Here's where the fun starts:
They blame the school system's financial woes on perennial discrepancies between what the state allows the district to raise under revenue caps and its actual expenses. A separate law, the qualified economic offer, virtually guarantees teachers annual compensation increases of 3.8% while revenue grows by about 2%.
Well--yeah. When most of the "expense" column is pay and bennies, and that column rises at 190% of your "income" column every year, there's going to be a problem.
The Lone Applauder had a worthwhile suggestion:
One solution each offered was a change in state law that would allow school districts to switch teachers' health care coverage. State Rep. Bill Kramer (R-Waukesha) estimated that if the School District adopted the health plan offered to state employees it could save $6 million annually.
Somehow, the Mayor of Waukesha didn't think that would be useful in the long-term:
But Waukesha Mayor Larry Nelson encouraged the crowd to find more permanent solutions.
"I think part of our jobs as citizens is to encourage our legislators to work with our governor, to work in a non-partisan way with their colleagues across the aisle and say 'This problem has reached a boiling point,' " said Nelson, a district middle school teacher who is on leave.
How about the possibility of Local Control and an end to binding arbitration, Larry?
About 500 parents, students and spectators packed a school auditorium Monday night, pleading for help from local legislators in dealing with a financial situation that some predicted would devastate the School District.
Administrators have recommended eliminating the equivalent of 62 full-time staff positions, which would raise class sizes, delay band and orchestra instruction and nearly eliminate elementary guidance, elementary library and gifted programs in the district.
Here's where the fun starts:
They blame the school system's financial woes on perennial discrepancies between what the state allows the district to raise under revenue caps and its actual expenses. A separate law, the qualified economic offer, virtually guarantees teachers annual compensation increases of 3.8% while revenue grows by about 2%.
Well--yeah. When most of the "expense" column is pay and bennies, and that column rises at 190% of your "income" column every year, there's going to be a problem.
The Lone Applauder had a worthwhile suggestion:
One solution each offered was a change in state law that would allow school districts to switch teachers' health care coverage. State Rep. Bill Kramer (R-Waukesha) estimated that if the School District adopted the health plan offered to state employees it could save $6 million annually.
Somehow, the Mayor of Waukesha didn't think that would be useful in the long-term:
But Waukesha Mayor Larry Nelson encouraged the crowd to find more permanent solutions.
"I think part of our jobs as citizens is to encourage our legislators to work with our governor, to work in a non-partisan way with their colleagues across the aisle and say 'This problem has reached a boiling point,' " said Nelson, a district middle school teacher who is on leave.
How about the possibility of Local Control and an end to binding arbitration, Larry?
More Stink from Ethanol
This line is high-test distilled manure:
Hahn, (R) who chairs the committee on biofuels and sustainable energy, said he has been promoting ethanol for years and was trying to help farmers when he invested in the Friesland plant.
"When they were looking for someone to invest, I said, 'Yes, I'll take a chance on losing my money,' " he said.
But just to bring the odds around to his favor:
Hahn introduced Assembly Bill 85, which would provide a $1,000 tax credit to Wisconsinites who buy or lease a new flex-fuel vehicle. ... But if passed, it would boost demand for ethanol, already in tight supply under President Bush's new alternative fuels initiatives.
Jackass scumbag.
Hahn, (R) who chairs the committee on biofuels and sustainable energy, said he has been promoting ethanol for years and was trying to help farmers when he invested in the Friesland plant.
"When they were looking for someone to invest, I said, 'Yes, I'll take a chance on losing my money,' " he said.
But just to bring the odds around to his favor:
Hahn introduced Assembly Bill 85, which would provide a $1,000 tax credit to Wisconsinites who buy or lease a new flex-fuel vehicle. ... But if passed, it would boost demand for ethanol, already in tight supply under President Bush's new alternative fuels initiatives.
Jackass scumbag.
Monday, March 12, 2007
The Legionnnaire Judges the Pro-Life Priest, UPDATED
There's a lot of chutzpah out there these days.
Amy reprints a short note from Fr. Johnathon Morris, a Legionary who (to put it mildly) disapproves of Fr. Euteneur's disapproval of Hannity's Brand of Catholicism:
As I watched a fellow Catholic priest spar with you on the March 9 edition of Hannity and Colmes, I hung my head in shame and sadness. My colleague in religion (whom I've never met) used the public airways and Internet to call you a heretic and hypocrite. Because he chose to do this in a public forum, I want you and your viewers to know, publicly, that as an analyst of this television network, I believe this good priest, who does great work, exercised, on this occasion, shockingly poor judgment. I consider his willingness to give his personal opinion about your status within the Church inappropriate and ill-considered, to say the least.
Amy relates that Fr. E's 'poor judgment' was to accept an invitation to the H&C shoutfest. But once he's there, he's in a bad box. Says Amy:
Another possibility, that I hear no one mention: that upon hearing about Fr. Euteneuer's original column, if Hannity was so concerned and really invested in being a faithful Catholic, he could have contact Father and asked, "I'm wondering about that column you wrote...could you enlighten me further? Because you're a priest, and I'm a Catholic in the punditocracy, and gosh, I want to make sure I get Catholic teaching right before I spout off about it to millions. That's a responsibility I take seriously."
But no, he invited him on his show, yelled at him, and allowed him very little time to speak without interruption.
But of course, taking religious instruction from Hannity (or several other self-identified Catholics-in-punditry) is not a reliable path to salvation.
Buy Bp. Sheen video copies instead, if you MUST have it in TV format.
UPDATE: There's a response-letter from Fr. Euteneur.
Your letter to Sean Hannity indicates that you did not know that I asked to speak to him in private about this matter in 2004 otherwise you may have tempered your remarks about my supposed lack of charity in dealing with a high profile Catholic who dissents from clearly-defined and reiterated Church teachings.
...The question that comes to mind is an obvious one: if you are a Fox analyst on Catholic matters, wouldn’t you have been the one to have had those “private conversations” on birth control with Mr. Hannity? How about discussions on his abortion exceptions? When you told Sean “in person” that you “disagreed with him,” was it on the issue of birth control? If you had done that, I applaud you, but your powers of persuasion may need a little honing—Sean has only gotten more vocal on this issue over time. If you did not speak to him about his public dissent, then I ask you, “Why?”
...I would sincerely hope that you are not teaching by word or example the young men in your charge to be politically correct sissies who are afraid to roll up their sleeves and defend the Church in private and in public. We have tons of those types in the clergy already. I would advise you to drink deeply of the wisdom of the Number Two man at our Headquarters who has in no uncertain terms told all of us that high profile dissenters are a scourge and a danger to souls. [See item: “Bertone: Dissident Catholics More Worrying Than Atheists.”
We'll expect a letter of apology from the LC shortly.
Right....
Amy reprints a short note from Fr. Johnathon Morris, a Legionary who (to put it mildly) disapproves of Fr. Euteneur's disapproval of Hannity's Brand of Catholicism:
As I watched a fellow Catholic priest spar with you on the March 9 edition of Hannity and Colmes, I hung my head in shame and sadness. My colleague in religion (whom I've never met) used the public airways and Internet to call you a heretic and hypocrite. Because he chose to do this in a public forum, I want you and your viewers to know, publicly, that as an analyst of this television network, I believe this good priest, who does great work, exercised, on this occasion, shockingly poor judgment. I consider his willingness to give his personal opinion about your status within the Church inappropriate and ill-considered, to say the least.
Amy relates that Fr. E's 'poor judgment' was to accept an invitation to the H&C shoutfest. But once he's there, he's in a bad box. Says Amy:
Another possibility, that I hear no one mention: that upon hearing about Fr. Euteneuer's original column, if Hannity was so concerned and really invested in being a faithful Catholic, he could have contact Father and asked, "I'm wondering about that column you wrote...could you enlighten me further? Because you're a priest, and I'm a Catholic in the punditocracy, and gosh, I want to make sure I get Catholic teaching right before I spout off about it to millions. That's a responsibility I take seriously."
But no, he invited him on his show, yelled at him, and allowed him very little time to speak without interruption.
But of course, taking religious instruction from Hannity (or several other self-identified Catholics-in-punditry) is not a reliable path to salvation.
Buy Bp. Sheen video copies instead, if you MUST have it in TV format.
UPDATE: There's a response-letter from Fr. Euteneur.
Your letter to Sean Hannity indicates that you did not know that I asked to speak to him in private about this matter in 2004 otherwise you may have tempered your remarks about my supposed lack of charity in dealing with a high profile Catholic who dissents from clearly-defined and reiterated Church teachings.
...The question that comes to mind is an obvious one: if you are a Fox analyst on Catholic matters, wouldn’t you have been the one to have had those “private conversations” on birth control with Mr. Hannity? How about discussions on his abortion exceptions? When you told Sean “in person” that you “disagreed with him,” was it on the issue of birth control? If you had done that, I applaud you, but your powers of persuasion may need a little honing—Sean has only gotten more vocal on this issue over time. If you did not speak to him about his public dissent, then I ask you, “Why?”
...I would sincerely hope that you are not teaching by word or example the young men in your charge to be politically correct sissies who are afraid to roll up their sleeves and defend the Church in private and in public. We have tons of those types in the clergy already. I would advise you to drink deeply of the wisdom of the Number Two man at our Headquarters who has in no uncertain terms told all of us that high profile dissenters are a scourge and a danger to souls. [See item: “Bertone: Dissident Catholics More Worrying Than Atheists.”
We'll expect a letter of apology from the LC shortly.
Right....
Relativism Gets Us Nowhere--or to Chaos
Here are a few excerpts from an essay on the topic of 'Relativism,' now the leading intellectual disease of the West. This was written for Zenit by Bishop Giampaolo Crepaldi, secretary of the Pontifical Council for Justice and Peace (and a very smart guy.) Update: At the very end of this will be a link to a First Things essay, in which Solzhenitsyn is quoted on the very same topic, (albeit using different names.) Funny thing, those great minds....no?
And, Rick, this is for you--the "breathing" Constitution is debunked herein--at least philosophically.
Public reason is human reason that believes it can attain, through dialogue and research, certain truths about man and, in particular, about man in society. Public reason is certainly a critical reason, but is also a constructive reason that is not only capable of achieving the "consensus" of opinions, but can also attain the truth and the good of man in society for which it has a cognitive and an arguing ability.
...Public reason is not possible in a culture that is dominated by the "dictatorship of relativism,"[1] for a very simple reason: Relativism is a dogma and therefore it a priori rejects rational argumentation, even toward itself. Those with a taste for paradox could say that relativism is a fundamentalism.
The 'relativism' is the "I'm OK, You're OK" which shows up in discussions of theology.
The "dictatorial" character -- in the cultural sense -- of relativism, prevents the use of public reason because it prevents the public use of reason.
...For Kant, reason has a public use that serves a critical purpose. To illustrate this public use, Kant especially dwells on the rational critique of religion, i.e. the complete freedom of citizens, indeed even the calling, "to impart to the public all of his carefully considered and well-intentioned thoughts concerning mistaken aspects of that symbol, as well as his suggestions for the better arrangement of religious and church matters."[3]
Reason, with its own categories, claims to be the testing ground and the measure of faith and religion too. Why is a public reason to which Kant assigned such challenging tasks now reduced to relativism, which is incapable of critiquing not just religion, but even itself?
The reason lies in the "self-limitation" of reason, as Benedict XVI has suggested many times.[4] This self-limitation underpins the dogmatically blind assumption of relativism and its inability to play any kind of critical role. The faith in relativism can exist only when the scope of reason has been drastically limited.
...relativism can only either be "implicit" -- lived and not justified -- or dogmatically "assumed" -- accepted, for example, by an act of faith. In this sense then, the "dictatorship of relativism" is the necessary conclusion of the "self-limitation" of reason. However, with relativism, the public role of reason fails.
...In 2004, Cardinal Ratzinger participated in a debate with philosopher Jurgen Habermas in Munich that focused exactly on the public role of reason.[6] On that occasion, he argued that if terrorism that is fuelled by religious fundamentalism is the symptom of a pathology of religion that must be corrected by reason, then in the same way the technical-scientific capability of producing human beings is the symptom of a pathology of reason that needs to be corrected by religion.
This is his conclusion: "There are extremely dangerous pathologies in religion that require us to consider the divine light of reason as a control mechanism ... there are also pathologies of reason that are not less dangerous … therefore reason has to accept warning as to its limits and must be willing to listen to the great religious traditions of mankind."[7]
Relativism is a de facto attack on religion (and the religious, of course):
Relativism, unfoundedly dogmatic, views religions as unjustified beliefs. Because it does so in an unfounded manner, it cannot demonstrate it, hence it simply "believes it." Relativism "believes" that religions are unfounded, thus they cannot be compared. In other words, it believes that religions have nothing to do with reason and truth. Then all religions are dogmatic, in the trivial sense of the word, i.e. in the sense of "accepted without evidence" (just like relativism, but relativism does not seem to be aware of that).
Where does that lead?
In this way, all religions are reduced to myth, i.e. to a way of exorcizing mysterious, bizarre and irrational forces. If religions are unfounded, it means that the divine forces they refer to are irrational and that arbitrariness rules the word. If the primordial forces are arbitrary, religion is a form of insurance against the repercussions of this imponderableness. Therefore religious relativism regresses to a kind of religious primitivism: religion is a way of exorcizing irrational forces.
Jean-Paul Sartre, call home!
To consider religion as something irrational, according to Benedict XVI, is entirely inconsistent with our whole Western and Christian history. In fact, both Greek thought and the Jewish religion, as well as Christianity, of course, rejected the vision of religion as myth and conceived religion as knowledge and God as Logos.[8]
For the Greeks,
...the path had been opened by Socrates and will be ratified by Plato: "The gods are not magicians who transform themselves, neither do they deceive mankind in any way" ("The Republic," II, 376 c). Therefore Greek philosophy detaches itself from myth and definitely turns to God as Logos. For Aristotle, the supersensible Substance is Intelligence that eternally grasps itself. The world has an order that is transparent to reason and reason can know it because the gods are rational and act according to truth, as Plato's Demiurge, who does not mould and shape things at random, but drawing inspiration from the truth of eternal forms.
As for the Hebrews,
If we look at the Jewish religion, we find the same path.[10] The "God of the Fathers" Israel looks to is not a local or a political god, he is not Baal nor Moloch. He is "he who is," he who existed before all powers and will continue to exist even after them.
St. Paul's success with the Greeks did not happen because he was selling a bill of goods which was "New!" Christianity was compatible with Greek philosophy, and (obviously) with Hebrew thought and knowledge.
So we have synthesis:
We believe that at the beginning of everything is the eternal Word, with Reason and not Unreason.[13] Justin (second century) believed that the Word had sown its seeds in Greek philosophy because what is true for reason comes always from the Word. Clement of Alexandria even thought that Greek philosophy had been a natural revelation of the Christian God.
Ockham was wrong:
This is precisely what Ockham thought: To say that God cannot produce something that is intrinsically impossible would be to limit the divine freedom and omnipotence. Then came St. Thomas. His opinion is the following: "Whatever implies contradiction does not come within the scope of divine omnipotence, because it cannot have the aspect of possibility. Hence it is better to say that such things cannot be done, than that God cannot do them." Divine omnipotence is wise, not arbitrary and capricious.
But Ockham retains devotees--and he is the father of Western Relativism.
The "Regensburg Speech" is only part of the conversation.
Christian faith confirms and supports the rational search for truth and calls for a public role of reason that will also include the critique of religions. In fact, we cannot say that all religions relate to truth and reason in the same way as Christianity. They relate to truth and reason in a different manner, which is the same as saying that they are more or less rational and that they can more or less adequately support the public role of reason. This was the theme touched upon by the Holy Father at Regensburg.
And here's the exercise in logic which shows how the hand plays out:
If a religion teaches a way of life that is not righteous, it cannot be a true religion. Only when man has lost sight of the ability to know what is good and what is true, then all offers of salvation become the same. If we do not have any standards of right living, then all religions are the same. If the standards for right living are relativized, man remains trapped inside religions. Again, this demonstrates that religious relativism is founded on philosophical relativism. Cardinal Ratzinger points out that St. Paul (Romans 2:14ff) does not say that non-Christians will be saved by following their religion, but by following natural religion.
As for the democracies--there is a danger:
Of course, if the political power is based on the relativistic democracy, it will not feel any obligation in this regard. Relativism, in fact, can only express a procedural public reason. When the truth is replaced by the decision of the majority, culture is set against truth. The relativistic presumption leads to the tearing up of people's spiritual roots and the destruction of the network of social relationships.[17]
That "procedural reason" is precisely what is behind such concepts as "Gay Marriage."
The State which relies on relativism is on its way to internal turmoil (at best...):
All this happens when a society is no longer able to use public reason to criticize religions that proclaim polygamy, that incorporate the rite of physical mutilation, that do not respect the dignity of women, that preach violence or offer religious paths that depersonalize and hamper human reason and knowledge. How will our public reason be able to discern between religions if it loses sight of authentic humanity?
According to the declaration "Dignitatis humanae" of the Second Vatican Council, the right to religious freedom "leaves untouched traditional Catholic doctrine on the moral duty of men and societies toward the true religion and toward the one Church of Christ."[19]
The onus of the State lies in understanding the common good--which calls for the ability to use "public reason."
Now, from where does the state, which is secular, derive these obligations to the true religion? Not from being a "Christian" state, but from reason, that is from the natural ability to see truths about man in society, from the ability to understand the common good. This also founds the ability to see that one religion consolidates and helps pursue humanization objectives while another contributes to the degradation of man. Christian religion has this claim, the claim of preaching a "God with a human face."[20]
As a consequence, "relativism" cannot be tolerated (other than as a curiosity) if order is to prevail.
HT: Cosmos-Liturgy-Sex
Also see: First Things :
Solzhenitsyn reiterated a claim that was central to his controversial commencement address at Harvard University in 1978: “if there are neither true or false judgments, man is no longer held [accountable] for anything. Without universal foundations, morality is not possible.”
And, Rick, this is for you--the "breathing" Constitution is debunked herein--at least philosophically.
Public reason is human reason that believes it can attain, through dialogue and research, certain truths about man and, in particular, about man in society. Public reason is certainly a critical reason, but is also a constructive reason that is not only capable of achieving the "consensus" of opinions, but can also attain the truth and the good of man in society for which it has a cognitive and an arguing ability.
...Public reason is not possible in a culture that is dominated by the "dictatorship of relativism,"[1] for a very simple reason: Relativism is a dogma and therefore it a priori rejects rational argumentation, even toward itself. Those with a taste for paradox could say that relativism is a fundamentalism.
The 'relativism' is the "I'm OK, You're OK" which shows up in discussions of theology.
The "dictatorial" character -- in the cultural sense -- of relativism, prevents the use of public reason because it prevents the public use of reason.
...For Kant, reason has a public use that serves a critical purpose. To illustrate this public use, Kant especially dwells on the rational critique of religion, i.e. the complete freedom of citizens, indeed even the calling, "to impart to the public all of his carefully considered and well-intentioned thoughts concerning mistaken aspects of that symbol, as well as his suggestions for the better arrangement of religious and church matters."[3]
Reason, with its own categories, claims to be the testing ground and the measure of faith and religion too. Why is a public reason to which Kant assigned such challenging tasks now reduced to relativism, which is incapable of critiquing not just religion, but even itself?
The reason lies in the "self-limitation" of reason, as Benedict XVI has suggested many times.[4] This self-limitation underpins the dogmatically blind assumption of relativism and its inability to play any kind of critical role. The faith in relativism can exist only when the scope of reason has been drastically limited.
...relativism can only either be "implicit" -- lived and not justified -- or dogmatically "assumed" -- accepted, for example, by an act of faith. In this sense then, the "dictatorship of relativism" is the necessary conclusion of the "self-limitation" of reason. However, with relativism, the public role of reason fails.
...In 2004, Cardinal Ratzinger participated in a debate with philosopher Jurgen Habermas in Munich that focused exactly on the public role of reason.[6] On that occasion, he argued that if terrorism that is fuelled by religious fundamentalism is the symptom of a pathology of religion that must be corrected by reason, then in the same way the technical-scientific capability of producing human beings is the symptom of a pathology of reason that needs to be corrected by religion.
This is his conclusion: "There are extremely dangerous pathologies in religion that require us to consider the divine light of reason as a control mechanism ... there are also pathologies of reason that are not less dangerous … therefore reason has to accept warning as to its limits and must be willing to listen to the great religious traditions of mankind."[7]
Relativism is a de facto attack on religion (and the religious, of course):
Relativism, unfoundedly dogmatic, views religions as unjustified beliefs. Because it does so in an unfounded manner, it cannot demonstrate it, hence it simply "believes it." Relativism "believes" that religions are unfounded, thus they cannot be compared. In other words, it believes that religions have nothing to do with reason and truth. Then all religions are dogmatic, in the trivial sense of the word, i.e. in the sense of "accepted without evidence" (just like relativism, but relativism does not seem to be aware of that).
Where does that lead?
In this way, all religions are reduced to myth, i.e. to a way of exorcizing mysterious, bizarre and irrational forces. If religions are unfounded, it means that the divine forces they refer to are irrational and that arbitrariness rules the word. If the primordial forces are arbitrary, religion is a form of insurance against the repercussions of this imponderableness. Therefore religious relativism regresses to a kind of religious primitivism: religion is a way of exorcizing irrational forces.
Jean-Paul Sartre, call home!
To consider religion as something irrational, according to Benedict XVI, is entirely inconsistent with our whole Western and Christian history. In fact, both Greek thought and the Jewish religion, as well as Christianity, of course, rejected the vision of religion as myth and conceived religion as knowledge and God as Logos.[8]
For the Greeks,
...the path had been opened by Socrates and will be ratified by Plato: "The gods are not magicians who transform themselves, neither do they deceive mankind in any way" ("The Republic," II, 376 c). Therefore Greek philosophy detaches itself from myth and definitely turns to God as Logos. For Aristotle, the supersensible Substance is Intelligence that eternally grasps itself. The world has an order that is transparent to reason and reason can know it because the gods are rational and act according to truth, as Plato's Demiurge, who does not mould and shape things at random, but drawing inspiration from the truth of eternal forms.
As for the Hebrews,
If we look at the Jewish religion, we find the same path.[10] The "God of the Fathers" Israel looks to is not a local or a political god, he is not Baal nor Moloch. He is "he who is," he who existed before all powers and will continue to exist even after them.
St. Paul's success with the Greeks did not happen because he was selling a bill of goods which was "New!" Christianity was compatible with Greek philosophy, and (obviously) with Hebrew thought and knowledge.
So we have synthesis:
We believe that at the beginning of everything is the eternal Word, with Reason and not Unreason.[13] Justin (second century) believed that the Word had sown its seeds in Greek philosophy because what is true for reason comes always from the Word. Clement of Alexandria even thought that Greek philosophy had been a natural revelation of the Christian God.
Ockham was wrong:
This is precisely what Ockham thought: To say that God cannot produce something that is intrinsically impossible would be to limit the divine freedom and omnipotence. Then came St. Thomas. His opinion is the following: "Whatever implies contradiction does not come within the scope of divine omnipotence, because it cannot have the aspect of possibility. Hence it is better to say that such things cannot be done, than that God cannot do them." Divine omnipotence is wise, not arbitrary and capricious.
But Ockham retains devotees--and he is the father of Western Relativism.
The "Regensburg Speech" is only part of the conversation.
Christian faith confirms and supports the rational search for truth and calls for a public role of reason that will also include the critique of religions. In fact, we cannot say that all religions relate to truth and reason in the same way as Christianity. They relate to truth and reason in a different manner, which is the same as saying that they are more or less rational and that they can more or less adequately support the public role of reason. This was the theme touched upon by the Holy Father at Regensburg.
And here's the exercise in logic which shows how the hand plays out:
If a religion teaches a way of life that is not righteous, it cannot be a true religion. Only when man has lost sight of the ability to know what is good and what is true, then all offers of salvation become the same. If we do not have any standards of right living, then all religions are the same. If the standards for right living are relativized, man remains trapped inside religions. Again, this demonstrates that religious relativism is founded on philosophical relativism. Cardinal Ratzinger points out that St. Paul (Romans 2:14ff) does not say that non-Christians will be saved by following their religion, but by following natural religion.
As for the democracies--there is a danger:
Of course, if the political power is based on the relativistic democracy, it will not feel any obligation in this regard. Relativism, in fact, can only express a procedural public reason. When the truth is replaced by the decision of the majority, culture is set against truth. The relativistic presumption leads to the tearing up of people's spiritual roots and the destruction of the network of social relationships.[17]
That "procedural reason" is precisely what is behind such concepts as "Gay Marriage."
The State which relies on relativism is on its way to internal turmoil (at best...):
All this happens when a society is no longer able to use public reason to criticize religions that proclaim polygamy, that incorporate the rite of physical mutilation, that do not respect the dignity of women, that preach violence or offer religious paths that depersonalize and hamper human reason and knowledge. How will our public reason be able to discern between religions if it loses sight of authentic humanity?
According to the declaration "Dignitatis humanae" of the Second Vatican Council, the right to religious freedom "leaves untouched traditional Catholic doctrine on the moral duty of men and societies toward the true religion and toward the one Church of Christ."[19]
The onus of the State lies in understanding the common good--which calls for the ability to use "public reason."
Now, from where does the state, which is secular, derive these obligations to the true religion? Not from being a "Christian" state, but from reason, that is from the natural ability to see truths about man in society, from the ability to understand the common good. This also founds the ability to see that one religion consolidates and helps pursue humanization objectives while another contributes to the degradation of man. Christian religion has this claim, the claim of preaching a "God with a human face."[20]
As a consequence, "relativism" cannot be tolerated (other than as a curiosity) if order is to prevail.
HT: Cosmos-Liturgy-Sex
Also see: First Things :
Solzhenitsyn reiterated a claim that was central to his controversial commencement address at Harvard University in 1978: “if there are neither true or false judgments, man is no longer held [accountable] for anything. Without universal foundations, morality is not possible.”
Gonzales: Dead Man Walking
Chuckie Schumer, an enemy of civil rights (e.g., the RKBA) calls for Attorney General Gonzales' resignation. Ordinarily, a Conservative treats statements from Schumer as either Red Flag Warnings or background noise. Fortunately, "background noise" has predominated over the last few years.
In this case it may be different--because a lot of Conservatives happen to agree that Gonzales is a nincompoop.
The top Republican on the House's main investigative committee, Rep. Thomas Davis of Virginia, is charging the Justice Department with stonewalling his inquiries about the FBI's assertion that it closed several leak investigations because of a lack of cooperation on the part of other government officials.
In January, Mr. Davis asked the Justice Department about a report in The New York Sun that at least three leak inquiries were shut down after officials at the "victim agency" ignored phone calls and canceled meetings with FBI agents assigned to the probes. The agents said some requests for information were rebuffed for more than a year.
On Friday, the lawmaker, the ranking Republican member of the Oversight and Government Reform Committee, sent a sharply worded letter to Attorney General Gonzales, expressing "aggravation" at the Justice Department's handling of questions about the aborted investigations.
Another element is the recent canning of 8 US Attorneys. It's being played up as a "political" housecleaning, which may have traction.
But there's more:
On Friday, Mr. Gonzales came under fire on a second front, regarding alleged misuse of administrative subpoenas which do not require judicial approval and are known as national security letters. A report by the Justice Department's inspector general found that the FBI sometimes issued the letters without proper authority, obtained data beyond what the law permits, and failed to include more than 8,000 of the information demands in statistics provided to Congress.
And, of course, there is Justice's persecution of the two Border Patrol officers who have been sent to Club Fed for.....doing their job...after which a number of issues were raised which go to the question of "prosecutorial misconduct."
Rohrabacher is calling for a new trial, charging the new documents show Sutton "knowingly presented a false picture of the drug smuggler in order to justify his ruthless prosecution of Border Patrol agents Ramos and Compean."
It gets worse.
Sandy "Burglar" Berger's case--which involved removing documents from the National Archives which could have had extremely grave national-security implications--was settled with a small fine ($50K) and some public-service crap.
On the other hand, the Libby case (which was an expensive farce) winds up differently.
One might ask "what the Hell's going on over there?" without any partisanship.
Gonzales' DoJ seems to be schizophrenic, or perhaps paranoid. Either way, it's not good for the Country.
HT: Powerline
In this case it may be different--because a lot of Conservatives happen to agree that Gonzales is a nincompoop.
The top Republican on the House's main investigative committee, Rep. Thomas Davis of Virginia, is charging the Justice Department with stonewalling his inquiries about the FBI's assertion that it closed several leak investigations because of a lack of cooperation on the part of other government officials.
In January, Mr. Davis asked the Justice Department about a report in The New York Sun that at least three leak inquiries were shut down after officials at the "victim agency" ignored phone calls and canceled meetings with FBI agents assigned to the probes. The agents said some requests for information were rebuffed for more than a year.
On Friday, the lawmaker, the ranking Republican member of the Oversight and Government Reform Committee, sent a sharply worded letter to Attorney General Gonzales, expressing "aggravation" at the Justice Department's handling of questions about the aborted investigations.
Another element is the recent canning of 8 US Attorneys. It's being played up as a "political" housecleaning, which may have traction.
But there's more:
On Friday, Mr. Gonzales came under fire on a second front, regarding alleged misuse of administrative subpoenas which do not require judicial approval and are known as national security letters. A report by the Justice Department's inspector general found that the FBI sometimes issued the letters without proper authority, obtained data beyond what the law permits, and failed to include more than 8,000 of the information demands in statistics provided to Congress.
And, of course, there is Justice's persecution of the two Border Patrol officers who have been sent to Club Fed for.....doing their job...after which a number of issues were raised which go to the question of "prosecutorial misconduct."
Rohrabacher is calling for a new trial, charging the new documents show Sutton "knowingly presented a false picture of the drug smuggler in order to justify his ruthless prosecution of Border Patrol agents Ramos and Compean."
It gets worse.
Sandy "Burglar" Berger's case--which involved removing documents from the National Archives which could have had extremely grave national-security implications--was settled with a small fine ($50K) and some public-service crap.
On the other hand, the Libby case (which was an expensive farce) winds up differently.
One might ask "what the Hell's going on over there?" without any partisanship.
Gonzales' DoJ seems to be schizophrenic, or perhaps paranoid. Either way, it's not good for the Country.
HT: Powerline
Fred Thompson? Hot Damn!!
Not bad at all. Quick-witted, charming, immediate recognition, and a Conservative.
From GOP3, a bio:
Born in Sheffield, Alabama, Thompson grew up attending the public schools in Lawrenceburg, Tennessee. He first attended the University of North Alabama and then Memphis State University where he earned an undergraduate degree in philosophy and political science in 1964. He received a J.D. degree from Vanderbilt University Law School in 1967.
He was admitted to the Tennessee bar in 1967 and commenced the practice of law, serving as an assistant U.S. attorney from 1969–1972. He was the campaign manager for Senator Howard Baker’s successful re-election campaign in 1972, which led to a close personal friendship with Baker, and he served as co-chief counsel to the Senate Watergate Committee in its investigation of the Watergate scandal, (1973–1974).…
On November 8, 1994, Thompson was elected to the United States Senate to fill the unexpired portion of the term ending January 3, 1997, left vacant by the resignation of Al Gore, defeating six-term Democratic U.S. Representative Jim Cooper in a landslide which represented the most votes anyone had ever received for a statewide office in Tennessee history up to that point. Thompson took the oath of office on December 2, 1994.
Almost immediately upon his arrival in Washington, D.C. (”while I was still unpacking my boxes,” as he put it), Thompson was selected by the Republicans to give a reply to a nationally-televised address by President Bill Clinton. This was no doubt due to his acting background, but many pundits saw this as an attempt to groom him for an even larger political role. Thompson was easily re-elected in 1996 for the term ending January 3, 2003 over Democratic attorney Houston Gordon of Covington, Tennessee by an even larger margin than that by which he had defeated Cooper two years earlier.
His name was regularly mentioned in the year 2000 as a potential candidate for Vice President alongside the Republican Presidential nominee George W. Bush.…Thompson was not a candidate for re-election in 2002. He had never planned to make a lifetime career of the Senate, and had often publicly stated as much. Although he announced in the wake of the September 11, 2001 attacks his intention to seek re-election, upon further reflection, which seems to have been prompted in large part by the sudden death of his daughter from unrelated events, he decided not to pursue this course.
In the final months of his term, he joined the cast of the long-running NBC television series Law & Order, playing Arthur Branch. In doing so, he became the first serving U.S. Senator concurrently to hold a full-time television acting job; however, his first scenes as Branch were filmed during the Senate’s August 2002 recess, so he missed no legislative time in order to act on television.…After the retirement of Supreme Court Associate Justice Sandra Day O’Connor in 2005, he was given an informal position by President George W. Bush to help guide the nominated John Roberts to the confirmation through the United States Senate.
Much as I like Brownback, Fred has a lot more cachet.
From GOP3, a bio:
Born in Sheffield, Alabama, Thompson grew up attending the public schools in Lawrenceburg, Tennessee. He first attended the University of North Alabama and then Memphis State University where he earned an undergraduate degree in philosophy and political science in 1964. He received a J.D. degree from Vanderbilt University Law School in 1967.
He was admitted to the Tennessee bar in 1967 and commenced the practice of law, serving as an assistant U.S. attorney from 1969–1972. He was the campaign manager for Senator Howard Baker’s successful re-election campaign in 1972, which led to a close personal friendship with Baker, and he served as co-chief counsel to the Senate Watergate Committee in its investigation of the Watergate scandal, (1973–1974).…
On November 8, 1994, Thompson was elected to the United States Senate to fill the unexpired portion of the term ending January 3, 1997, left vacant by the resignation of Al Gore, defeating six-term Democratic U.S. Representative Jim Cooper in a landslide which represented the most votes anyone had ever received for a statewide office in Tennessee history up to that point. Thompson took the oath of office on December 2, 1994.
Almost immediately upon his arrival in Washington, D.C. (”while I was still unpacking my boxes,” as he put it), Thompson was selected by the Republicans to give a reply to a nationally-televised address by President Bill Clinton. This was no doubt due to his acting background, but many pundits saw this as an attempt to groom him for an even larger political role. Thompson was easily re-elected in 1996 for the term ending January 3, 2003 over Democratic attorney Houston Gordon of Covington, Tennessee by an even larger margin than that by which he had defeated Cooper two years earlier.
His name was regularly mentioned in the year 2000 as a potential candidate for Vice President alongside the Republican Presidential nominee George W. Bush.…Thompson was not a candidate for re-election in 2002. He had never planned to make a lifetime career of the Senate, and had often publicly stated as much. Although he announced in the wake of the September 11, 2001 attacks his intention to seek re-election, upon further reflection, which seems to have been prompted in large part by the sudden death of his daughter from unrelated events, he decided not to pursue this course.
In the final months of his term, he joined the cast of the long-running NBC television series Law & Order, playing Arthur Branch. In doing so, he became the first serving U.S. Senator concurrently to hold a full-time television acting job; however, his first scenes as Branch were filmed during the Senate’s August 2002 recess, so he missed no legislative time in order to act on television.…After the retirement of Supreme Court Associate Justice Sandra Day O’Connor in 2005, he was given an informal position by President George W. Bush to help guide the nominated John Roberts to the confirmation through the United States Senate.
Much as I like Brownback, Fred has a lot more cachet.
Jews in France and England Targets of Hizbollah
Since the Iranian spymaster's defection, there have been a few changes:
In fact, Kuwaiti daily Al Seyassah believes that Paris and London have reinforced security measures after the Israeli Mossad provided them with reliable information on the terrorist threat represented by Hezbollah cells helped by Iranian Services based in the Iranian embassies and consulates in Europe. The targets would be the Israeli diplomatic and consular representations as well as Israeli nationals and Israeli interests in Europe in general.
According to British sources quoted by the newspaper, “some Lebanese Shiites living legally in Great Britain, and other clandestine ones, are being monitored since last Tuesday, whereas other Arab nationals infiltrated clandestinely in the United Kingdom were stopped and expelled”. The daily newspaper adds that “hundreds of Lebanese Shiites who own small restaurants and taxis, use their businesses to to spy and smuggle goods. From now on, they are monitored by Scotland Yard and MI-5”.
France is more a concern since their internal security is very weak.
HT: Counterterrorism Blog
In fact, Kuwaiti daily Al Seyassah believes that Paris and London have reinforced security measures after the Israeli Mossad provided them with reliable information on the terrorist threat represented by Hezbollah cells helped by Iranian Services based in the Iranian embassies and consulates in Europe. The targets would be the Israeli diplomatic and consular representations as well as Israeli nationals and Israeli interests in Europe in general.
According to British sources quoted by the newspaper, “some Lebanese Shiites living legally in Great Britain, and other clandestine ones, are being monitored since last Tuesday, whereas other Arab nationals infiltrated clandestinely in the United Kingdom were stopped and expelled”. The daily newspaper adds that “hundreds of Lebanese Shiites who own small restaurants and taxis, use their businesses to to spy and smuggle goods. From now on, they are monitored by Scotland Yard and MI-5”.
France is more a concern since their internal security is very weak.
HT: Counterterrorism Blog
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

